Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!The Arab world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion

Last week, a huge scandal rocked the Tunisian and Arab scientific and educational world: a PhD student submitted a thesis declaring Earth to be flat, unmoving, young (only 13,500 years of age), and the centre of the universe.

Going even bolder and further, the student explicitly rejected the physics of Newton and Einstein, the astronomy of Copernicus and Kepler, the cosmology of the Big Bang, the main models of atmospheric and geological activity, and most of modern climatology.

The student submitted her thesis after five years of work; it was then sent to two assessors, thus passing the first stage of approvals. The reports were expected soon, for the thesis defence to be scheduled.

It was at this stage that fate luckily intervened: a copy of the thesis was “leaked” to the former president of the Tunisian Astronomical Association, who checked that it was not a hoax and then quickly rang the alarm by posting on Facebook the general conclusions of the thesis, verbatim.

Gulf News readers may recall that two years ago, I wrote a column lamenting the talk that a Saudi cleric had given in the UAE insisting that Earth does not rotate, neither around itself nor around the Sun; I described the moment as a “debacle” and tried to draw lessons from it.

This new scandal is much worse, because it does not come from a cleric (that was bad enough) but rather from a PhD student in science, her supervisor held the Professor rank (the highest in academia), and they were explicitly rejecting major parts of modern science.

They also went further than just submit a thesis, they published a paper (in an obscure and disreputable journal) presenting “physical and astronomical arguments” for geo-centrism (Earth being central and fixed in the universe).

The paper is available online, and anyone can quickly check that both the paper and the journal are worthless: countless grammatical errors, mediocre references, puny scientific arguments; the journal is classified as “fake and predatory”, one of those “pay and we’ll publish your article quickly, with no reviewing or editing”…

General conclusion

I don’t mean to belabour the point, but it is worth citing a few ideas from the general conclusion given at the end of the thesis, if at least to fully impress upon the reader the size of the calamity that has just occurred — before we analyse its causes.

The “results” of this doctoral thesis include: the Earth is flat and young, and it stands immobile at the centre of the universe, which is made of only one galaxy; the sun’s diameter is 1,135km (not 1.4 million km), the moon is 908 km wide, and they lie 687 and 23 times closer to Earth, respectively; there are 11 planets; stars are “limited” in number and have a diameter of 292 km (not millions of km).

How does one explain such stunning ignorance of basic astronomy, coupled with such brashness and insolence — rejecting Copernicus, Kepler, Newton, Einstein, Hubble, and everything in science?

In this particular case, I believe this was due to an adherence to religious, scriptural literalism, in other words taking the meanings of religious texts literally and blindly, at the cost of rejecting all knowledge that appears to contradict it, no matter how much evidence supports it.

Indeed, we find in the conclusions of the thesis clear indications of this stand and approach, expressions such as: “using physical and religious arguments”, “also proving the world scale of [Noah’s] flood”, “proposed a new kinematic approach that conforms to the verses of the Quran”, “the roles of the stars are: (1) to be ornaments of the sky; (2) to stone the devils; and (3) as signs to guide creatures in the darkness of earth”; and finally “the geo-centric model… accords with the verses of the Quran and the pronouncements of our Prophet.”

Comeback

Flat-Earthism has lately been making a comeback and spreading like bush fire through social media.

Search for “flat earth” on YouTube and you’ll find almost a million videos; “flat earth society” gets 400,000 pages on the web; “flat earth proof” gets you 200,000 pages; etc.

But this social media trend I attribute to people’s inclination toward conspiracy theories: “Nasa has faked the moon-landing”; “Nasa photoshops space images”; “Give us real proofs that these interplanetary spacecraft are factual”; etc.

In 2001, when the internet was still young, and the “moon-landing hoax” was just emerging as a trending meme (without social media to support its spread), I gave several talks titled “Did Nasa fake the moon landing… or are we miserably failing to educate the public?”

But the latest shocking event (the PhD thesis) implies that we are not only failing to educate the public (that is manifest in the trendy “flat earth” and “Nasa lies” memes on social media) but also our brightest students.

It has been reported that the PhD student had previously graduated at the top of her class.

What we are failing to clarify and communicate is how to distinguish between scientific knowledge (facts, models, theories, etc.) and religious knowledge (what verses mean and what they intend to teach us).

I believe the Arab-Muslim world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises, not to mention a total lack of understanding of science, until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion, without diminishing the value of each.

Source: gulfnews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 26/11 22:06

    Greece's car Covid-19 mask wearing rules during lockdown explained

  2. 26/11 21:49

    No air carriers to 22 countries forces Cyprus to cancel mail service

  3. 26/11 20:58

    JetBlue Airways to host IATA AGM and World Air Transport Summit in Boston

  4. 26/11 20:06

    Athens cultural institutions to receive emergency funding by Culture Ministry

  5. 26/11 18:46

    Aviation industry agrees on critical slot use relief

  6. 26/11 17:40

    IATA calls on governments to support industry move to sustainable aviation fuel

  7. 26/11 15:33

    Greek state budget showed primary deficit of 9.065 billion euros in January-October

  8. 26/11 13:20

    IATA: International air connectivity crisis threatens global economic recovery

  9. 26/11 11:52

    First visitors of Kerkini Lake started arriving from the north: Swans

  10. 26/11 11:31

    Strong frost expected during the night in northern Greece

  11. 26/11 01:20

    Greek tourism 2020: Loss of 20.8 million tourists and €12.6 billion in first 9 months

  12. 25/11 23:13

    No disruptions in international and domestic flights on Thursday and Friday

  13. 25/11 22:58

    Athens metro on strike, tram on work stoppage, buses & trolleys operate today

  14. 25/11 19:49

    Minister: National health agency has important role to play in pandemic response

  15. 25/11 15:42

    UNWTO global tourism plastics initiative welcomes 26 new signatories

  16. 25/11 13:30

    Minister: Our priority is for schools to reopen after experts offer advice

  17. 25/11 02:00

    "Greek Freak" hands out food to the needy in his old Athens neighbourhood

  18. 25/11 01:56

    Greek PM: Doctors working in ICUs to become permanent staff members

  19. 25/11 01:53

    House prices in Cyprus continued to rise in Q2 despite the pandemic

  20. 25/11 01:06

    7 creative things to do during the lockdown (and always)

  21. 24/11 20:14

    Greece offers 50% tax deductions to foreigners and Greeks who live abroad

  22. 24/11 20:10

    Nobel prize winner's plan on Greece's development posted for public consultation

  23. 24/11 19:46

    Media report: Coronavirus lockdown won't be lifted for travel inside Greece yet

  24. 24/11 19:31

    Greek Minister: Our aim is to give the health system 10 days to 'catch its breath'

  25. 24/11 19:20

    IATA: Aviation industry deep losses continue into 2021

  26. 24/11 19:02

    U.S. Travel Association survey: Future travel with family is a priority for Americans

  27. 24/11 18:54

    Bank of Greece chief: Public debt sustainable at least until 2030

  28. 24/11 15:04

    Qantas CEO: Passengers will need vaccine proof for international flights

  29. 24/11 13:27

    Greek government spokesperson: It is not realistic to open on December 1

  30. 24/11 11:13

    Ipsos: Greece ranks 5th in top tourism brands globally

  31. 24/11 02:49

    International Air Transport Association's Director General will step down

  32. 24/11 02:45

    Greek economy to grow in 2021 with the Covid-19 vaccine a positive factor

  33. 24/11 02:41

    UNWTO in Uruguay: Marking resilience and supporting tourism's sustainable restart

  34. 23/11 22:38

    Greece records significant decrease in COVID-19 cases during last 24 hours

  35. 23/11 21:45

    The Greek government continues to support the national health system

  36. 23/11 19:00

    IATA digital health travel pass key to reopening borders safely

  37. 23/11 17:33

    No metro or tram in Athens on Thursday due to 24-hour strike action

  38. 23/11 17:09

    Greece offers €20 million in financial support to coastal ferry companies

  39. 23/11 13:14

    Interview - Eduardo Santander (ETC): Governments must support tourism firms with easy loans and relief

  40. 22/11 02:23

    Reconstruction of emblematic French Pier greenlighted by Greece's Culture Ministry

  41. 21/11 21:29

    Greek PM calls for for extension of support of EU economies against pandemic

  42. 21/11 20:35

    Greece registers 2,311 new Covid-19 cases and 108 fatalities on Saturday

  43. 21/11 18:39

    U-M Modern Greek Program cooperates with Aristotle University of Thessaloniki

  44. 21/11 15:52

    Air traffic controllers and safety mechanics to strike in Greece next week

  45. 21/11 15:24

    Greek PM to volunteer nurses: 'Act of kindness and deeply patriotic gesture'

  46. 21/11 13:47

    Hellenic College Holy Cross classes to continue online for Spring Semester

  47. 21/11 13:29

    European Commission President warns of 3rd coronavirus wave

  48. 21/11 11:44

    Registered unemployment increases in Greece during October

  49. 20/11 21:19

    Greek PM discusses child protection policy with UNICEF's new chief

  50. 20/11 21:14

    Hellenic Post warns customers not to open this phishing scam e-mail

  51. 20/11 20:57

    2.581 new Covid-19 cases and 72 fatalities recorded in Greece

  52. 20/11 20:15

    Celestyal Cruises offers early ‘Black Friday’ discount & Special Hero’s Day in Greece

  53. 20/11 19:59

    Survey: Greek capital of Athens is the top destination for British travelers

  54. 20/11 16:55

    SNF donation of 174 ICU beds to be delivered gradually in Greece from end December

  55. 20/11 15:02

    Transport Turnover Value Index 30% down in Cyprus during first 9 months of 2020

  56. 20/11 14:20

    Greek Interior Minister: The end of lockdown has to be done very warily

  57. 20/11 14:08

    Greek state budget forecasts economy to grow by 4.8 pct during 2021

  58. 20/11 12:05

    World Children's Day celebrated in Greece on November 20

  59. 19/11 21:55

    Greek PM visits United Arab Emirates for promoting bilateral relations

  60. 19/11 21:50

    AP: Two Cyprus casinos close and three open during COVID-19 pandemic

  61. 19/11 21:45

    Thessaloniki Port sets up subsidiary in Bulgaria linking through rail to Europe

  62. 19/11 21:05

    Greek FM: EU must adopt measures obliging Turkey to respect international law

  63. 19/11 19:46

    Strong winds in the Aegean Sea keep some ships tied at Greek ports

  64. 19/11 18:55

    New draft bill on stricter recycling rules goes on public consultation in Greece

  65. 19/11 18:51

    UNWTO official visit to Brazil to support sustainable recovery of tourism sector

  66. 19/11 17:00

    Infographic: EasyJet records €1.34 billion annual loss in 2020

  67. 19/11 15:10

    3.227 new Covid-19 cases and 59 fatalities recorded in Greece during last 24 hours

  68. 19/11 13:37

    Greece assumes presidency and coordination of Mediterranean Diet in 2021

  69. 18/11 22:08

    Expert: Sewage signs show imminent Covid-19 slowing in Greece

  70. 18/11 22:01

    Greece records 3,209 new Covid-19 cases in last 24 hours

  71. 18/11 21:53

    Rare gospel stolen in 1917 to return to monastery in NE Greek city of Drama

  72. 18/11 21:38

    EU Commission: Greece steps up pace of reforms despite Covid-19

  73. 18/11 19:45

    Tram services to and from Syntagma in Athens to resume from November 20th

  74. 18/11 18:55

    National Geographic: Alonissos island among destinations on the rise for 2021

  75. 18/11 17:33

    Severe weather warning with heavy rainfalls and winds forecast in Greece

  76. 18/11 15:30

    Passenger traffic in Greek airports drops 59.7% during October

  77. 18/11 12:22

    Greek government plans to open restaurants and cafes before Christmas

  78. 18/11 01:18

    Healthy Greek extra virgin olive oils win international awards

  79. 17/11 19:06

    Space Tourism: SpaceX successfully launches first crewed mission

  80. 17/11 19:01

    US State Secretary met with Ecumenical Patriarch in Constantinople

  81. 17/11 18:40

    Infographic: Cruise sector sails in troubled waters

  82. 17/11 17:20

    Expedia.com unveils the top travel trends and tips for American travelers in 2021

  83. 17/11 16:35

    Tourist arrivals in Cyprus decrease by 76.9% during October

  84. 17/11 15:00

    Minister: Greek government to continue exploitation of domestic and EU funds

  85. 17/11 14:15

    Minister:TAP pipeline is a milestone for the energy security of Greece and SE Europe

  86. 17/11 13:55

    New IATA guidance prepares for global Covid-19 vaccine distribution

  87. 17/11 11:07

    Germany adds North Aegean and Peloponnese to its coronavirus travel warning list

  88. 17/11 09:29

    Asylum services in Thessaloniki city suspended between November 17-20

  89. 16/11 23:22

    McKinsey study: Tourism recovery speeds from pandemic will vary across markets

  90. 16/11 23:01

    THI virtual gala raises more than $1.6 million for Greece and Cyprus

  91. 16/11 22:47

    Ambassador: U.S. and Cyprus set to expand bilateral trade and investment

  92. 16/11 22:39

    Five metro stations to close down at noon on Tuesday, November 17

  93. 16/11 22:10

    Survey: Number of American students studying in Greece records steady rise

  94. 16/11 21:52

    Greece records 2,198 new Covid-19 infections and 59 fatalities in last 24 hours

  95. 16/11 10:23

    Hermes head, part of Herma column unearthed during roadworks in Athens

  96. 15/11 22:18

    Greek authorities slap offenders of coronavirus measures with €237,750 fines on Friday

  97. 15/11 14:11

    Greek PM adviser on Bloomberg: Three London City banks moving to Greece

  98. 15/11 14:08

    Greece passes 1,000-death mark from Covid-19 with 2,835 new cases on Saturday

  99. 15/11 13:57

    Primary schools, kindergartens, and nurseries closed in Greece until November 27

  100. 15/11 13:53

    AFCAC, IATA, AFRAA promote jointly aviation safety and connectivity in Africa