Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!The Arab world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion

Last week, a huge scandal rocked the Tunisian and Arab scientific and educational world: a PhD student submitted a thesis declaring Earth to be flat, unmoving, young (only 13,500 years of age), and the centre of the universe.

Going even bolder and further, the student explicitly rejected the physics of Newton and Einstein, the astronomy of Copernicus and Kepler, the cosmology of the Big Bang, the main models of atmospheric and geological activity, and most of modern climatology.

The student submitted her thesis after five years of work; it was then sent to two assessors, thus passing the first stage of approvals. The reports were expected soon, for the thesis defence to be scheduled.

It was at this stage that fate luckily intervened: a copy of the thesis was “leaked” to the former president of the Tunisian Astronomical Association, who checked that it was not a hoax and then quickly rang the alarm by posting on Facebook the general conclusions of the thesis, verbatim.

Gulf News readers may recall that two years ago, I wrote a column lamenting the talk that a Saudi cleric had given in the UAE insisting that Earth does not rotate, neither around itself nor around the Sun; I described the moment as a “debacle” and tried to draw lessons from it.

This new scandal is much worse, because it does not come from a cleric (that was bad enough) but rather from a PhD student in science, her supervisor held the Professor rank (the highest in academia), and they were explicitly rejecting major parts of modern science.

They also went further than just submit a thesis, they published a paper (in an obscure and disreputable journal) presenting “physical and astronomical arguments” for geo-centrism (Earth being central and fixed in the universe).

The paper is available online, and anyone can quickly check that both the paper and the journal are worthless: countless grammatical errors, mediocre references, puny scientific arguments; the journal is classified as “fake and predatory”, one of those “pay and we’ll publish your article quickly, with no reviewing or editing”…

General conclusion

I don’t mean to belabour the point, but it is worth citing a few ideas from the general conclusion given at the end of the thesis, if at least to fully impress upon the reader the size of the calamity that has just occurred — before we analyse its causes.

The “results” of this doctoral thesis include: the Earth is flat and young, and it stands immobile at the centre of the universe, which is made of only one galaxy; the sun’s diameter is 1,135km (not 1.4 million km), the moon is 908 km wide, and they lie 687 and 23 times closer to Earth, respectively; there are 11 planets; stars are “limited” in number and have a diameter of 292 km (not millions of km).

How does one explain such stunning ignorance of basic astronomy, coupled with such brashness and insolence — rejecting Copernicus, Kepler, Newton, Einstein, Hubble, and everything in science?

In this particular case, I believe this was due to an adherence to religious, scriptural literalism, in other words taking the meanings of religious texts literally and blindly, at the cost of rejecting all knowledge that appears to contradict it, no matter how much evidence supports it.

Indeed, we find in the conclusions of the thesis clear indications of this stand and approach, expressions such as: “using physical and religious arguments”, “also proving the world scale of [Noah’s] flood”, “proposed a new kinematic approach that conforms to the verses of the Quran”, “the roles of the stars are: (1) to be ornaments of the sky; (2) to stone the devils; and (3) as signs to guide creatures in the darkness of earth”; and finally “the geo-centric model… accords with the verses of the Quran and the pronouncements of our Prophet.”

Comeback

Flat-Earthism has lately been making a comeback and spreading like bush fire through social media.

Search for “flat earth” on YouTube and you’ll find almost a million videos; “flat earth society” gets 400,000 pages on the web; “flat earth proof” gets you 200,000 pages; etc.

But this social media trend I attribute to people’s inclination toward conspiracy theories: “Nasa has faked the moon-landing”; “Nasa photoshops space images”; “Give us real proofs that these interplanetary spacecraft are factual”; etc.

In 2001, when the internet was still young, and the “moon-landing hoax” was just emerging as a trending meme (without social media to support its spread), I gave several talks titled “Did Nasa fake the moon landing… or are we miserably failing to educate the public?”

But the latest shocking event (the PhD thesis) implies that we are not only failing to educate the public (that is manifest in the trendy “flat earth” and “Nasa lies” memes on social media) but also our brightest students.

It has been reported that the PhD student had previously graduated at the top of her class.

What we are failing to clarify and communicate is how to distinguish between scientific knowledge (facts, models, theories, etc.) and religious knowledge (what verses mean and what they intend to teach us).

I believe the Arab-Muslim world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises, not to mention a total lack of understanding of science, until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion, without diminishing the value of each.

Source: gulfnews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 23/09 16:06

    Arcturos Sanctuary to give home to three rare Eurasian lynxes in Greece

  2. 23/09 15:57

    Greek organic farm wins two gold awards at the 'Great Taste Awards 2021' in London

  3. 23/09 15:37

    'Under the Light of Apollo: The Louvre in Delphi' exhibition inaugurated in Greece

  4. 23/09 14:27

    Wine helping tourism recover in Greece

  5. 23/09 14:01

    Cyprus to participate in EXPO2020 to be organized in Dubai

  6. 23/09 13:43

    Greek Island of Milos presented by Louis Vuitton in new ad campaign

  7. 23/09 12:49

    World Tourism Organization organizes First World Sports Tourism Congress

  8. 23/09 12:22

    Council of Rectors in favour of in-person attendance at Greek universities

  9. 23/09 11:32

    Harvard University and Tufts University hold conference on Greek Revolution

  10. 23/09 09:10

    IATA urges Ethiopian government to maintain support for aviation sector

  11. 22/09 23:28

    Media report: Despite COVID-19 rise, Greece won't tighten health measures

  12. 22/09 22:43

    Real estate taxes for 2021 posted by Greece's tax service online

  13. 22/09 21:39

    Five lesser known Greek islands featured in Condé Nast Traveler

  14. 22/09 21:02

    Greece records 2,329 new Covid-19 infections and 26 fatalities on Wednesday

  15. 22/09 20:52

    Investment ministers of Greece and Saudi Arabia discuss strategic cooperation

  16. 22/09 20:35

    Athens Acropolis Museum upgrades services with new, interactive website

  17. 22/09 19:48

    Cyprus narrows its safe list down to three EU countries for tourist arrivals

  18. 22/09 17:10

    IATA announces speakers and agenda for the World Air Transport Summit in Boston

  19. 22/09 15:06

    2022 Edition IATA manuals reflecting vital airline standard updates now available

  20. 22/09 13:56

    UNWTO: Urgent global call for commitment to a decade of climate action in tourism

  21. 21/09 19:00

    Greek government spokeperson: 'This is now a pandemic for the unvaccinated'

  22. 21/09 17:03

    US Navy will add second base at Souda Bay on Greek island of Crete

  23. 21/09 15:10

    Sector chiefs: Revenues from Greek tourism could reach €12 bln this year

  24. 21/09 13:45

    U.S. to relax travel restrictions permitting entry for vaccinated European visitors

  25. 21/09 12:55

    IATA on US decision to lift COVID-19 travel restrictions from certain countries

  26. 21/09 12:52

    Temperatures to plunge up to 9C below seasonal average in Greece this week

  27. 21/09 11:26

    Third dose vaccination appointments for those over 60 to open in Greece on September 30

  28. 20/09 17:11

    French president and wife visit the Athens Acropolis on Friday

  29. 20/09 16:59

    Norwegian Ambassador to Athens: Changes in Greek energy sector are impressive

  30. 20/09 16:48

    Greek Education Minister notes high rate of vaccination among students

  31. 20/09 16:13

    Monica Bellucci in Athens for three nights for play about Greek diva Maria Callas

  32. 20/09 16:06

    World Tourism Day 2021 theme coincides with Cyprus National Tourism Strategy

  33. 20/09 15:54

    Travel and Leisure: Greece dominates list of top-20 islands of Europe

  34. 20/09 14:16

    Bank of Greece: Greek travel receipts soared 139.7% during first seven months in 2021

  35. 20/09 13:36

    Greek government spokesperson: The Athens Declaration a milestone for EU Med 9

  36. 20/09 12:04

    The Greek National Opera returns to Stavros Niarchos Hall in Athens

  37. 19/09 21:20

    Deputy Education Minister: High vaccination rate in Greek universities encouraging

  38. 19/09 20:00

    Greece to administer third dose of Covid vaccines to those older than 60

  39. 19/09 19:26

    1,305 new Covid-19 cases and 33 fatalities recorded in Greece on Sunday

  40. 18/09 16:43

    Air passenger traffic in Greece “took off” in August

  41. 16/09 19:31

    Metro will not be reaching Athens Airport station for several hours on Friday and Saturday

  42. 16/09 19:22

    Greece records 2,322 new covid-19 infections and 42 fatalities on Thursday

  43. 16/09 18:41

    Athens Acropolis site to shut down for 3 hours on Sunday

  44. 16/09 17:35

    AP: Greece's courts require workers and users vaccinated or not COVID-19 infected

  45. 16/09 16:57

    EUmed 9 summit being held at SNFCC in Greek capital of Athens on Friday

  46. 16/09 16:26

    Irish airline Ryanair planning to create 5,000 jobs over the next five years

  47. 16/09 15:10

    Passione Rossa Ferrari Club road show at Piraeus port for 'Days of the Sea' festival

  48. 16/09 13:15

    Gordon, Gino & Fred Go Greek kicks off on ITV channel on September 27

  49. 16/09 11:05

    Cyprus Deputy Minister sees prospects for Saudi tourists through Bahrain

  50. 16/09 10:49

    Minister estimates that €6 bln will be chanelled to IT and telecoms projects in Greece

  51. 15/09 14:49

    COVID-19 pandemic expected to infect 50,000 children aged 12-18 in Greece in Autumn

  52. 15/09 14:47

    UNWTO members plan coordinated restart of sector in Asia and the Pacific

  53. 15/09 13:30

    Greek Finance Minister leaves open possibility of further favourable interventions

  54. 15/09 12:03

    Greek government takes balanced measures to protect the health and the rights of citizens

  55. 15/09 09:33

    Hellenic Development Bank and Federation of Industries of Greece sign joint actions memo

  56. 14/09 18:58

    AP: 80% of adult population vaccinated with at least one dose in Cyprus

  57. 14/09 15:23

    Education Minister: Health protocols in Greek schools will change

  58. 14/09 14:22

    IATA Regional Vice President in Asia-Pacific

  59. 13/09 21:52

    14th Animasyros 2021 International Animation Festival starts on September 22

  60. 12/09 14:32

    Greece puts squeeze on unvaccinated citizens barring them from indoor spots

  61. 12/09 12:36

    Greek Foreign Ministry expresses solidarity to U.S.A. on 20th anniversary of 9-11 attacks

  62. 11/09 16:27

    Athens Half Marathon race to be dedicated to late composer Mikis Theodorakis

  63. 11/09 16:20

    UNWTO: Innovation and partnerships to make wine tourism driver rural development

  64. 11/09 16:11

    Modified covid test requirements for domestic travel in Greece on Monday, September 13

  65. 09/09 22:37

    Minister: Coronavirus vaccination centers coming to Greek universities

  66. 09/09 21:59

    Greek PM: EKO Acropolis Rally 2021 'Rally of Gods' is 'here to stay'

  67. 09/09 20:29

    1 in 4 high school students in Greece have received at least one dose of Covid-19 vaccine

  68. 09/09 19:50

    Greece records 2,170 new covid-19 infections and 43 fatalities on Thursday

  69. 09/09 14:54

    Minister: Larnaca Port and Marina project the largest project ever in Cyprus

  70. 08/09 19:41

    Greece will launch COVID-19 vaccination campaign to 12-17 year-olds

  71. 08/09 19:30

    Statement concerning Celestyal Cruises sale of The Experience published

  72. 08/09 16:36

    Greek weather service warns of heavy rain and storms

  73. 08/09 15:25

    Education Minister outlines protocol for schooling system in Greece

  74. 08/09 11:45

    Free self-tests available to all school students in Greece as of Wednesday

  75. 07/09 18:08

    Greece records 2,807 new COVID-19 cases and 38 fatalities on Tuesday

  76. 07/09 16:32

    AP: Vulnerable Greeks and over-60’s to get COVID-19 booster shots

  77. 07/09 16:04

    Roads temporarily closed in downtown Athens due to EKO Acropolis Rally

  78. 07/09 14:24

    Tourism Minister: Greece will continue to receive USA visitors until end of the season

  79. 07/09 14:11

    ELSTAT: Greek economy grew 16.2% in Q2

  80. 06/09 20:05

    AP: Greece starts administering COVID-19 vaccines outside churches

  81. 06/09 19:01

    Greece records 1,765 new Covid-19 cases and 47 fatalities on Monday

  82. 06/09 17:55

    UNWTO connects investors with Ministers of Tourism at Cabo Verde Forum

  83. 06/09 15:15

    Meeting discusses measures for Greece's Acropolis Rally 2021 on September 9

  84. 06/09 14:08

    Greek government has two goals: protecting public health and restoring public life

  85. 06/09 13:16

    French aerobatic team flies in formation using Greek colours above Athens Acropolis

  86. 06/09 12:05

    Strong winds disrupt some ferry lines in the Aegean Sea of Greece

  87. 06/09 11:11

    UNWTO: Africa's tourism chiefs identify investments as key to sustainable recovery

  88. 05/09 22:12

    Cyprus announces that August of 2021 was hottest month on record since 1983

  89. 03/09 22:22

    IATA: European travel rules confusion wasting advantages of Digital Covid Certificate

  90. 02/09 19:14

    Greece records 2,840 new Covid-19 cases and 33 fatalities on Thursday

  91. 02/09 18:06

    Cyprus air passenger traffic shows signs of recovery after 18 months

  92. 02/09 15:57

    Greece mourns the loss of music composer Mikis Theodorakis at 96

  93. 02/09 14:18

    Cypriot made halloumi cheese finally gets EU protection

  94. 01/09 21:21

    Strong global aviation cargo demand continues in July

  95. 01/09 21:10

    Media report: New luxury hotel earmarked for Larnaca in Cyprus

  96. 01/09 20:52

    Greece records 2,871 new Covid-19 infections and 47 deaths on Wednesday

  97. 01/09 19:45

    Media: Greece already passes 6 million tourists in 2021 despite COVID-19 pandemic

  98. 01/09 19:03

    Greek Finance Minister welcomes successful reissue of 5- and 30-year bonds

  99. 01/09 18:00

    Cyprus tightens coronavirus pandemic restrictions for German travelers

  100. 01/09 14:37

    Greek PM: We do not want a repeat of the uncontrolled migration flows in 2015