Atlantic Council analysis: How Russia beat Turkey in Syria

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Atlantic Council analysis: How Russia beat Turkey in SyriaThe Russian decision to intervene in late September 2015 directly challenged Turkish interests

The Atlantic Council released the following very interesting analysis on the Russian-Turkish relation regarding Syria:

Turkish-Russian relations have been poor for years because of conflicting agendas in Syria. The Russian decision to intervene in late September 2015 directly challenged Turkish interests. At the outset of the Russian military operation, the goal appeared to be point defense of core regime areas, including the Latakia coast and the road to Damascus. Turkey, in contrast, worked for years to expand opposition held territory out to the coast, as part of its broader effort to empower the opposition to challenge the regime. This sub-set of the broader Turkish proxy war sparked a major escalation with Russia, and in so doing, contributed to the Turkish defeat in Syria.

This author undertook a study of Turkish, Kurdish, American, and Russian military actions in northern Aleppo between July 2014 and March 2017. The data suggested that counter escalation actions by Russian and Kurdish forces occurred when challenged by Turkey during operation Euphrates Shield, Turkey’s cross border military operation. Russia retains escalation dominance vis-a-vis Turkey and has a demonstrated track record of using the Afrin-based Syrian Kurdish YPG as a counter escalation tool to blunt Turkish efforts to regain leverage over Moscow. This dynamic has been a staple of the Syrian conflict after Russia’s direct military intervention.

For much of the Syrian civil conflict, the Turkish Air Force had been flying combat air patrols along the border, as part of an effort to deter regime air strikes along a narrow strip along the border. The Turkish effort intended to protect supply lines through Azaz to Aleppo through means of coercion and deterrence. Russia, starting in October 2015, directly challenged aspects of this policy. In an incident foreshadowing later developments, the Turkish air force downed a Russian Orlans-10 remotely piloted aircraft near the Kilis border in mid-October 2015. Just over a month later, on November 24, a Turkish F-16, most probably operating under relaxed rules of engagement and firing from beyond visual range, downed a Russian SU-24 bomber, after it strayed into Turkish airspace for 17 seconds. The incident took place in the Latakia mountains and long the likely route for Turkish backed forces to advance out to the coast.

The incident prompted Russia to focus on cutting Ankara off from Aleppo. This effort, according to Russia analyst Michael Kofman, is intended to help “shape the Syrian opposition on the ground, by eliminating those parts of it that it finds disagreeable at the negotiating table.” In late November, Russian expanded its strike areas to include the Azaz-Aleppo corridor. This bombing had three outcomes: 1) It grounded the Turkish Air Force, then conducting strike operations in the area, as part of the anti-ISIS coalition; 2) It upended US-Turkish planning to use trained rebels to close the Manbij pocket; 3) It culminated in the use of Russian air power and the YPG to knock Ankara out of northern Aleppo. These three interlinked objectives came together in early February 2016, wherein a span of 10 days, the Turkish link to Aleppo through Azaz was severed and the YPG moved out and took Minagh Air Force base and Tel Rifaat. It was only after Russia achieved these objectives that it agreed to a ceasefire on February 16, 2016.

The ceasefire allowed Turkey to reorient its actions in Syria towards the defeat of the Islamic State (ISIS, ISIL, Daesh). Turkish artillery, deployed along the border, began to shell ISIS positions, in support of the beleaguered Marea line rebels. Despite US support for this effort, the rebel groups were weak and divided, making them susceptible to ISIS counter attacks. The ‘ping-pong’ control over small and sparsely populated villages played out for months along the Turkish border, before the United States opted to use the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), a multi-ethnic military umbrella dominated by the Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG), to take Manbij. This offensive began in late May 2016, and by June, Manbij was besieged.

After the failed July 2016 coup, after which the Justice and Development Party (AKP) purged the internal opposition to it intervening in Syria, Ankara took steps to secure Russian acquiescence for what would later be dubbed operation Euphrates Shield. In late July, the Syrian regime besieged Aleppo, with assistance from Russian advisers and air power. Turkey and the United States engaged in negotiations with Moscow to evacuate Eastern Aleppo, but it was Turkey that finalized the arrangement. On August 9, Presidents Erdogan and Putin met in St. Petersburg, where, in retrospect, it appears that the two agreed to a deconfliction arrangement to allow for the forthcoming Turkish invasion. Five days later, on August 14, Manbij fell to the SDF, prompting concerns in Ankara that the group would expand to Jarablus and al-Bab, the latter of which would then allow for the connecting of Kurdish territory along the Turkish-Syrian border.

On August 24, the Turkish military moved across the border, facing little resistance. The operation was derisively labeled as Turkey trading Aleppo for al-Bab. This portrayal, however, fails to account for Russian efforts throughout the campaign to ensure that Ankara did not threaten its core interests in Aleppo. Moscow also continued with its strategy of using the YPG as a counter-escalation tool against Turkey. This first incident took place in mid-October, when Turkish military forces and its allied proxies clashed with the YPG south of Tel Rifaat, some 25 kilometers west of al-Bab. Then, on November 24, an Iranian drone, most probably flying in support of the Syrian Armed Forces or an allied militia, struck Turkish forces, killing three. A day later, Presidents Erdogan and Putin spoke on the telephone, and Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusolgu visited Tehran on November 26. The fighting in the area de-escalated the day of the Putin-Erdogan phone call and, shortly thereafter, a small Kurdish militia allied with the Syrian regime linked up with the SDF in the area to act as a buffer force.

A similar dynamic took place in Manbij, in February 2017. After the fall of al-Bab in mid-November, Turkish allied forces began to attack SDF held positions west of al-Arima. The previous month, Ankara had sought to prevent the town from falling to the SDF, but because the allied militias that fought alongside Turkey were weak, they were unable to fight on multiple fronts at once. Turkish artillery, used to offset the weaknesses of its allied ground forces, was unable to prevent the town from falling. After al-Bab fell to Turkish backed forces in late February, Turkish backed forces attacked SDF positions west of al-Arima. In the ensuing clashes, SDF elements lost control over a few villages. This prompted the SDF to counter-escalate. On March 1, Russia, the regime, and the SDF reached an agreement to form a small, jointly enforced ribbon around the western edge of SDF held territory.

At the outset of this arrangement, the tactics mimicked those south of Tel Rifaat, where SDF and regime allied militias simply co-located, perhaps with some SDF elements simply wearing Syrian regime uniforms. Russia re-escalated its involvement in the area on March 8, one day after Turkey convened a trilateral meeting with Moscow and Washington. On March 9, President Erdogan travelled to Moscow for a two-day summit. Upon his return to Ankara, on March 10, all the clashes had stopped in Turkish controlled territory with Syria. Up to that point, Ankara had repeatedly used artillery to strike Tel Rifaat, Minagh Air Force Base, and Manbij, most likely to soften YPG and SDF defensives for an expansion of its military offensive.

The trilateral summit and the Moscow visit went poorly for Turkey. Turkey’s continued challenge along the western outskirts of al-Arima prompted Russia to deepen its footprint in the area, an outcome that ultimately ended the fighting. Moreover, the Russian government kept some of the economic sanctions levied in December 2015 after the SU-24 bombing in place. It appears that Turkey imposed retaliatory sanctions against Russia on March 16, 2017, imposing a tariff on Russian wheat imports. Ankara denies that this amounts to an official sanction, but up until mid-March, Russia had been importing wheat duty free.

Finally, on March 20, the Russian military announced that it was setting up a military area in YPG-held Afrin to monitor a cease-fire brokered with Turkey, in Astana, months earlier. The ceasefire has not held, but the Russian framing of the arrangement—and concurrent announcement of forces in the area—is at odds with Ankara’s long-standing portrayal that it has the right to target the YPG because Turkey lists them as a terrorist group. The outcome of this latest Russian move has boxed Turkey in northern Aleppo.

The sequence of events clearly demonstrates how Russia is working at cross-purposes with Ankara in Syria, and how Russia and the YPG have a mutually beneficial relationship in countering Turkey in Syria. Turkey still has means to put pressure on Russia in Syria. Ankara is training rebels in Turkey to join its proxies in northern Aleppo. Turkey could simply send these to other areas in Idlib or down to Hama to attack regime positions. However, the events between November 2015 and February 2017 clearly shows that Russia has escalation dominance in Syria vis-a-vis Turkey. Moreover, the YPG in Afrin—well armed and now with overt Russian assistance—could move south to take the Reyhanli / Bab al-Hawa border crossing. Russia could easily justify such action as necessary to defeat Syria’s al-Qaeda affiliate, which has a strong presence in Idlib. To stop them, Ankara would have to risk targeting Russian soldiers, risking a broader clash, wherein Turkey is the weaker of the two parties.

Yet, for Turkey, Russia remains a valuable tool to try and put pressure on the United States. Ankara rejects US support for the SDF, as it also empowers the YPG along the northeastern border. Turkey has sought to use Moscow to signal to the United States that it has options, beyond the US-Turkish alliance and, by extension, Turkish reliance on NATO for its security. The events in Syria clearly contradict this. Russia is not an ally of Turkey. Instead, Russia is using all the means at its disposal to shape the opposition to serves its end goals of a negotiated settlement on its own terms—goals at odds with Turkish interests. Turkey has few options to alter this dynamic, especially since the United States is pushing ahead with its preferred partner in northeastern Syria, the SDF. Turkey has even fewer options to stop the trajectory of these two larger powers.

Source: atlanticcouncil.org

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 11/12 20:02

    Survey: Greeks rank as the 4th most religious people in Europe

  2. 11/12 19:54

    Students from Panama learn Greek language and plan to visit Greece

  3. 11/12 19:42

    First Greek lending library opens with huge success in London

  4. 11/12 19:29

    "Women in Diplomacy and Public Life" event organized in Athens

  5. 11/12 19:23

    Religious Tourism: Nativity Church renovation lifts Christmas spirit in Bethlehem

  6. 11/12 19:14

    Chinese buyers leading Greek real estate boom

  7. 11/12 19:05

    Building permits value soars due to large-scale projects in Cyprus

  8. 11/12 18:14

    Internationally famed Greek dancer at Thessaloniki’s Vassiliko Theater (video)

  9. 11/12 18:03

    Greek literary masterpiece “My Mother’s Sin” presented for first time in English

  10. 11/12 15:55

    Υellow vests: Tourists cancel Paris hotel Christmas bookings due to violent protests

  11. 11/12 15:13

    Historic Tourism: Bactria, the Ancient Greek State in Afghanistan

  12. 11/12 15:04

    Greek academics call for private universities to be recognized in country

  13. 11/12 14:58

    Greek airports among Europe's top-7 in passenger traffic

  14. 11/12 14:33

    Greek farmers from Thessaly exhibit a sexy side in new calendar

  15. 11/12 13:52

    Athens University of Agriculture gives EU Commissioner honorary doctorate

  16. 11/12 13:42

    10 finalists in 1st UNWTO-Globalia Tourism Startup Competition announced

  17. 11/12 13:21

    Funding approved for four new Ionian island water airports in Greece

  18. 11/12 11:16

    Corporate bonds put on hold in Greece until market turmoil eases off

  19. 11/12 01:53

    Christmas celebrations at the National Observatory of Athens

  20. 11/12 01:47

    Anti-fascist film festival commences at Studio cinema in Athens today

  21. 10/12 23:49

    Greek trade deficit declines in October as exports continue to grow

  22. 10/12 22:36

    Greek architects present "smart" hotel room at 5th Athens International Tourism Expo

  23. 10/12 22:31

    Magical night of Broadway classics at the SNFCC in Athens

  24. 10/12 20:26

    Greek President inaugurates Athena Center for Science and Technology

  25. 10/12 18:36

    Infrastructure investment: ERGOSE's new-generation railway projects in Greece

  26. 10/12 17:26

    Winter tourism: Arachova, Greece’s top skiing destination

  27. 10/12 16:19

    Welt: One in every two new LNG ship orders by Greek companies

  28. 10/12 15:09

    EU Commission's Costello urges Greece to conclude privatizations and reforms

  29. 10/12 14:10

    Last Greeks of Alexandria strive to keep their historic community alive

  30. 10/12 13:58

    Prime Minister at NY Forum: Greece is a safe investment destination

  31. 09/12 13:35

    Unique experiences at Athens Museum of Illusions on central Ermou Street

  32. 09/12 13:32

    2018 Global Migration Film Festival in Cyprus honouring migrants

  33. 09/12 13:19

    Greek island of Kea pays tribute to American archaeologist Miriam Caskey

  34. 09/12 13:11

    Cosco eyes separating draft master plan for Piraeus port to speed up process

  35. 09/12 13:05

    Nicosia advises Cyprus citizens on 'yellow vests' riots across France

  36. 09/12 12:55

    'Right-of-use' extending into decades for illegally built structures in Greek forests

  37. 09/12 12:45

    EBRD: TAP pipeline a great opportunity to give up use of coal in Greece

  38. 09/12 12:36

    New York City taxi board sets minimum pay for app-based drivers

  39. 09/12 12:36

    Greek top-500 companies generated impressive profits in 2017

  40. 09/12 10:10

    Greek doctors and hospital staff on work stoppage between 11:00-15:00 on Monday

  41. 08/12 13:45

    Island of Corfu to host International Open Chess Festival at Easter

  42. 08/12 13:37

    Holiday season festivities guide: Celebrating Christmas in Athens

  43. 08/12 12:51

    Daily Mail dream job report: Get paid 90,000 euros to travel

  44. 08/12 12:45

    Foreign Minister Lavrov: New starting point in Greek-Russian relations

  45. 08/12 12:34

    Three Greek hotels voted best in the world at Small Luxury Hotels (SLH) competition

  46. 08/12 12:25

    Draft law on thematic tourism approved in Greek parliament

  47. 08/12 12:04

    President Putin: Record one million Russian tourists to visit Greece in 2019 (video)

  48. 08/12 11:56

    Ryanair launches new Thessaloniki – Krakow route in summer 2019

  49. 08/12 11:02

    Alitalia accepts purchase offer from Italian State Railways (FS)

  50. 08/12 10:54

    Bronze age finds from excavations at Agios Sozomenos- Ampelia and Nikolides sites

  51. 07/12 18:04

    Duke and Duchess of Cambridge visit Cyprus to spread Christmas spirit

  52. 07/12 17:57

    Construction works for Kasteli Airport in Crete to commence in January 2019

  53. 07/12 17:50

    First e-charging of commercial vessel at Greek port of Kyllini this month

  54. 07/12 17:45

    Commercial property prices grow by 3.5% in Greece during H1 of 2018

  55. 07/12 17:13

    Media report: Thousands of Turks flee Erdogan’s purge by seeking asylum in Greece

  56. 07/12 16:24

    Large-scale infrastructure projects to be delivered across Greece by 2021

  57. 07/12 15:20

    Trolleys to hold 3-hour work stoppage in Athens on December 12

  58. 07/12 14:00

    Unemployment in Greece drops further to 18.6% in September year on year

  59. 07/12 12:53

    Greek PM promises to upgrade infrastructure in islands

  60. 07/12 10:45

    OTE presents Greece's first pilot 5G network in Athens suburb of Zografou

  61. 06/12 22:35

    Welcome the New Year in Athens at SNFCC’s First Run 2019

  62. 06/12 22:31

    City of Athens turns into Christmas city of angels during holiday season

  63. 06/12 22:20

    Getty Museum vows to assert its right to keep prized Greek statue

  64. 06/12 22:07

    Greece unveils new draft law on attracting strategic investments

  65. 06/12 21:16

    Greece sets terms and conditions for casino licensing and operations

  66. 06/12 21:08

    Aegean Airways signs preliminary deal to purchase Pratt & Whitney engines

  67. 06/12 21:01

    Greek Minister: PM's meetings will confirm Greece's good relations with Russia

  68. 06/12 20:24

    Daily Mail: Danish family books Airbnb house which turns out to be a brothel

  69. 06/12 19:43

    Greek PM to meet with Putin and Medvedev at visit in Moscow on Friday

  70. 06/12 19:33

    Outdoor activities tourism: Greece voted 3rd destination in the world for summer 2018

  71. 06/12 19:27

    10th Honey and Bee Products festival opens in Athens on Friday

  72. 06/12 18:01

    Research Institute: Supermarket prices significantly lower in Greece

  73. 06/12 17:59

    Union of Greek Shipowners announces joining Arctic Economic Council (AEC)

  74. 06/12 17:41

    South Australia to celebrate all things Greek at Semaphore Beach in Adelaide

  75. 06/12 17:24

    Infographic: Global 5G smartphone adoption to take off in 2021

  76. 06/12 17:14

    Panepistimio metro station in central Athens closes again due to rallies

  77. 06/12 16:15

    Reuters report: EBRD approves extension of mandate in Greece until 2025

  78. 06/12 14:06

    AHFWPA marks 125 years of Greek presence in Pittsburgh

  79. 06/12 12:56

    Ambassador Pyatt: US capital market will support Greek enterprises

  80. 06/12 10:34

    Diaspora report: 15 things all Greek-Americans experience growing up

  81. 05/12 22:10

    City Breaks: Three Greek entries among World’s Top City Destinations in 2018

  82. 05/12 22:00

    Itinerary fixed for Greek PM's visit to Moscow on Friday

  83. 05/12 21:55

    Jurij Subic exhibition opens on Wednesday in Athens

  84. 05/12 21:50

    Marine tourism professionals in Greece await governmental decision on VAT imposition

  85. 05/12 21:42

    Extension of Antikythera Shipwreck exhibition at the Forbidden City approved

  86. 05/12 20:41

    SETE workshop to boost wine tourism across Greece

  87. 05/12 20:36

    Tourist arrivals and departures show increase in Cyprus during October

  88. 05/12 20:30

    Elgin’s descendant claims Athens Acropolis Marbles were a gift

  89. 05/12 19:54

    Athens' top-5 museums with nice cafes

  90. 05/12 18:55

    Greece to suspend implementation of 15% capital tax on property transactions

  91. 05/12 18:26

    Island of Corfu clinches best European Film Location Award for 2018

  92. 05/12 16:20

    Greek passport among the ten most powerful in the planet

  93. 05/12 16:13

    Bureau Veritas' 29th marine technical committee meeting in Greek port of Piraeus

  94. 05/12 14:01

    UNWTO/UNESCO: Cultural tourism supports communities and living heritage

  95. 05/12 12:50

    IATA: Air freight records modest growth in October by 3.1%

  96. 05/12 10:32

    Greek youngster creates new world with “Playmogreek” dolls

  97. 04/12 20:39

    City Break report: Pangrati, a hip neighbourhood in Athens is born

  98. 04/12 20:36

    Hellenistic and Byzantine Jewelry at New York Met Museum exhibition

  99. 04/12 20:26

    Cretan olive oil fetches price of €1,020 per liter at Dutch auction

  100. 04/12 20:21

    Eurozone to pressure Greece over 'bad debt' and main residences protection