Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the Americas

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the AmericasThe fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers

Among the many theories about which civilization first sailed to the Americas and discovered them, there is also the theory that the ancient Phoenicians were the first.

This theory became popular in the 18th century and is closely connected with the petroglyphs on Dighton Rock which are still of unknown origin. This theory is not quite as popular as the one that says that the Norse made the discovery first, but still, it is worth mentioning.

Back in the 18th century, a lot of scholars started to offer ideas about the true origin of the inscriptions on the rock. Ezra Stiles, a theologian, author, and also the seventh President of Yale College, claimed that the inscriptions are in Hebrew. Antoine Court de Gébelin, who is mainly known for the popularization of the Tarot, had his own idea about the rock. He believed that the inscription was made by Carthaginian sailors who commemorated their journey to the shores of Massachusetts.

In the 19th century, the theory that a group of Israelite people visited the New World was widely adopted in the Mormon community.

Later, Ross T. Christensen, an American archeologist, speculated that the Mulekites, who are mentioned in the Book of Mormon, were probably of Phoenician ethnic origin.

Stone tablet with inscription

The Phoenician theory is also supported in a book written in 1871, by John Denison Baldwin, an American anthropologist. In Ancient America, Baldwin wrote,

“The known enterprise of the Phoenician race, and this ancient knowledge of America, so variously expressed, strongly encourage the hypothesis that the people called Phoenicians came to this continent, established colonies in the region where ruined cities are found, and filled it with civilized life. It is argued that they made voyages on the ‘great exterior ocean,’ and that such navigators must have crossed the Atlantic; and it is added that symbolic devices similar to those of the Phoenicians are found in the American ruins, and that an old tradition of the native Mexicans and Central Americans described the first civilizers as ‘bearded white men,’ who ‘came from the East in ships’.”

A stone tablet with an inscription that was supposed to be of Phoenician origin appeared in Brazil in the 1870s. The tablet was given to Ladislau de Souza Mello Netto, who was the director of the National Museum of Brazil at that time, and he immediately acknowledged the artifact as genuine. The inscription allegedly told the story of some Sidonian Canaanites who visited the shore of Brazil. It was later discovered that the symbols that appear on the tablet were variations of letters that appeared in different periods over a span of 800 years. It was impossible for all the letters to appear on the same tablet at the same time, so the artifact and the inscription were dismissed as fake.

In the 20th century, a few new artifacts appeared that again spiked the theory of Phoenician or Semitic discovery. One of these artifacts was the Bat Creek inscription. Cyrus Herzl Gordon, Near Eastern cultures and ancient languages expert, believed that the inscription of this tablet was in Paleo-Hebrew. Gordon thought that this was proof that Semitic people visited the continent prior to Columbus. Later, the Bat Creek inscription, together with another artifact called the Las Lunas Decalogue Stone, were proven to be forgeries and Gordon’s claim was dismissed.

Phoenician sailors visited the Americas 

In 1996, Mark McMenamin, an American paleontologist, speculated that Phoenician sailors visited the Americas around 350 BC. He based his theory on some gold stater coins that were allegedly made by the state of Carthage. On the back of the coins was a map of the Mediterranean and another land on the west, across the Atlantic. McMenamin interpreted that land as the Americas but later discovered that those coins were actually a modern forgery.

Another form of written evidence that slightly goes in favor of the arrival of Phoenicians in the Americas can be found in Ptolemy’s Geography. Lucio Russo, an Italian physicist, mathematician, and historian of science, analyzed Ptolemy’s book and noticed that he gives the coordinates of the Fortunate Isles.

The fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers. Russo also noticed that the size of the world in Ptolemy’s Geography is smaller than what Eratosthenes measured. After he gave the same coordinates of the Fortunate Islands to the Antilles, the map irregularities in Ptolemy’s descriptions disappeared. According to Russo, Ptolemy could have known about the Antilles from his source, Hipparcos, who lived in Rhodes. It is possible that Hipparcos heard about the Antilles from Phoenicians sailors who controlled the western Mediterranean in those days. This is a far-fetched idea, but still, an interesting one.

Modern-day scholars

Most of the modern-day scholars deny the idea that Phoenicians, Canaanites, or Carthaginians discovered the Americas first.

Ronald H. Fritze, an American historian, says that although it was technically possible for those people to reach the Americas, it probably never happened:

“No archaeological evidence has yet been discovered to prove the contentions of Irwin, Gordon, Bailey, Fell and others. Since even the fleeting Norse presence in Vinland left definite archaeological remains at L’Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland, it seems logical that the allegedly more extensive Phoenician and Carthaginian presence would have left similar evidence. The absence of such remains is strong circumstantial evidence that the Phoenicians and Carthaginians never reached the Americas.”

Until some concrete evidence appears, this theory will remain only a fantasy.

Source:thevintagenews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

 

Tornos
  1. 18/09 21:39

    Competitiveness of Austrian aviation critical for jobs and prosperity

  2. 18/09 21:34

    Greek telecom OTE's 500 million bond coupon at historic lows of 0.875%

  3. 18/09 21:24

    25th Athens International Film Festival between September 18-29

  4. 18/09 19:41

    Greek Tourism Minister: Development of Kaiafa thermal springs and more tourists to Ancient Olympia

  5. 18/09 17:17

    ETOA stresses visitor economy value and risk of tourism taxes in Europe

  6. 18/09 15:50

    Travelhorizons Report: Americans increasingly seek cultural experiences abroad

  7. 18/09 13:02

    Shipping Minister presents framework for limited-traffic ferry routes in Greece

  8. 17/09 22:02

    Greek Culture Minister slams British Museum over Elgin Marbles

  9. 17/09 15:57

    Prime Minister briefed on restoration work at Ancient Greek theatre of Dodoni

  10. 17/09 15:52

    Greek Ministers taking part in Tallinn Digital Summit 2019

  11. 17/09 15:26

    New ABTA campaign aims to maintain customer confidence despite Brexit

  12. 17/09 15:02

    Tourism: TripAdvisor stops over 1m fake reviews, enforces penalties on 35k firms

  13. 17/09 14:49

    Athens appoints its first female Ambassador to Cyprus

  14. 17/09 13:42

    5th Panhellenic Conference of Hellenic Thermal Medicine Academy on Oct. 11-13

  15. 17/09 12:57

    Ambassador Pyatt: U.S. decisive factor in transforming energy landscape in Greece

  16. 17/09 10:04

    No ferry service in Greece next Tuesday due to 24h strike

  17. 16/09 21:46

    WWF urges Greek hotels and customers to stop food waste

  18. 16/09 15:33

    Expedia launches new podcast: "Out Travel The System"

  19. 16/09 15:29

    Greek Prime Minister Mitsotakis to meet US President Trump on September 24

  20. 16/09 15:18

    Greek state records primary surplus of €2.9 billion in January-August

  21. 16/09 14:39

    'Silk in Ancient Greece and its Resonance' event in Athens on September 19

  22. 16/09 14:27

    US gambling giants Mohegan and Hard Rock bid for Hellenikon casino in Greece

  23. 16/09 14:16

    Deputy Finance Minister: Greece will attain 3.5% primary surplus target in 2019

  24. 15/09 21:38

    UNWTO and Globalia launch 2nd Global Tourism Start-up Competition

  25. 15/09 20:31

    23rd UNWTO General Assembly: Tourism has ‘life-changing potential’

  26. 14/09 20:09

    Eminent Greek poet Nanos Valaoritis passes away at 98 (video)

  27. 13/09 22:16

    New Greek government to sell 30% share of Athens’ Airport

  28. 13/09 22:12

    Morocco wins vote to host World Tourism Organization General Assembly in 2021

  29. 13/09 22:12

    Show opening: Romaniote Memories, a Jewish trip from Ioannina to NYC

  30. 13/09 22:06

    Israeli kayakers rescued on island hop by Greek Coast Guard

  31. 13/09 22:05

    U.S. Ambassador visits works at northern Greek port of Alexandroupolis

  32. 13/09 21:25

    Strong winds keep ferries docked at Piraeus and Lavrion ports in Greece

  33. 13/09 20:25

    Classical-era shipwreck at Peristera off Alonisos island accessible from next summer

  34. 13/09 19:48

    Swedish interest in cooperation with Greece on medical tourism

  35. 13/09 01:11

    ESM: Stronger growth and lower interest rates can lead to lower surplus targets

  36. 13/09 00:55

    Greek President: Refusal to return Elgin Marbles 'offends British culture and history'

  37. 13/09 00:40

    Prime Minister stresses will to speed up asset development in Greece

  38. 13/09 00:15

    Bankruptcies set for 8% decrease in Greece during 2019

  39. 13/09 00:07

    Interest for unfinished commercial high-rise in downtown Piraeus Port

  40. 13/09 00:03

    Deputy Foreign Minister meets President of the Greek Festival of Sydney

  41. 12/09 22:31

    The Hellenic Initiative Australia’s events promote Greece

  42. 12/09 22:23

    New bill foresees tighter rules for state officials and employers in Greece

  43. 12/09 22:17

    Thessaloniki ring road to be upgraded through a €300 million PPP project

  44. 12/09 20:19

    Greek unemployment rate eases to 16.9% of the workforce during Q2

  45. 12/09 17:12

    New York City Greek Film Festival to run between October 17-23

  46. 12/09 14:58

    Revenues and visitors to Greek museums and sites rise in May 2019

  47. 12/09 12:50

    IMF: High primary surplus targets a drag Greece's economic recovery

  48. 12/09 00:15

    Real estate: Another setback for Greece’s lagging land registry

  49. 11/09 23:05

    Just 26% of properties in Greece registered with national cadastre yet

  50. 11/09 22:46

    Niketown SoHo goes Greek to honour of NBA’s MVP Giannis Antetokounmpo

  51. 11/09 22:33

    Greek exports rebound in July 2018 posting a 7.2% increase

  52. 11/09 22:32

    Opinion poll: 'Honeymoon' period continues for new Greek government

  53. 11/09 21:28

    Greek government approves 'immediate action' to sell 30% stake in Athens airport

  54. 11/09 20:20

    UNWTO General Assembly opens with sustainability and innovation top of the agenda

  55. 11/09 19:41

    Greek FinMin to raise early repayment of IMF loans at Eurogroup

  56. 11/09 17:08

    Piraeus Bank supports €650 million infrastructure investment programme

  57. 11/09 13:41

    Greece and Bulgaria strengthen strategic partnership at bilateral and regional level

  58. 11/09 11:58

    Aegean Regatta will return to the Greek islands of the Dodecanese in 2020

  59. 10/09 23:53

    European Bank for Reconstruction and Development to open office in Thessaloniki

  60. 10/09 23:39

    Survey: Greek hotels continue to rate higher compared to competitor countries

  61. 10/09 21:28

    IATA urges dialogue between government and industry in Panamá

  62. 10/09 15:53

    Atlas Obscura’s hidden world wonders now available on Airbnb

  63. 10/09 15:28

    Prime Minister: Greece to submit request on early IMF loan repayment this week

  64. 10/09 15:22

    Planet Jupiter’s recently discovered moons receive Ancient Greek names

  65. 10/09 13:30

    Psarotherma hot springs on Greek island of Samothrace recognised as therapeutic

  66. 10/09 01:15

    San Sebastian clinches UNWTO Award for Sustainability and Governance

  67. 09/09 23:05

    Show on rare Trebizond Alexander Romance Codex in Greek city of Thessaloniki

  68. 09/09 22:45

    Athens University opens its botanical garden to residents and tourists

  69. 09/09 22:30

    Slowing global air passenger demand growth for July

  70. 09/09 22:26

    Ministerial proposal on Greeks Abroad postal vote ready in mid October

  71. 09/09 21:51

    Indian Group GMR eyes privatization of 23 Greek regional airports

  72. 09/09 21:27

    Rich Antiquity, Early Christian and Byzantine finds at excavation on Greek island of Kythnos

  73. 09/09 21:11

    New York Times feature on house hunting in Greek island of Crete

  74. 09/09 16:12

    Regional Governor of Attica meets Governor of Jeollanamdo Province of South Korea

  75. 09/09 14:09

    Greek PM: Crete Northern Motorway Axis, an inspiring project for the island

  76. 09/09 10:19

    Greek FM: Aegean Sea should be completely visible to authorities 24/7

  77. 09/09 01:05

    World Tourism Organization reports 4% growth in global tourism during H1 2019

  78. 09/09 00:46

    120 countries gather in Russia for World Tourism Organization General Assembly

  79. 08/09 21:33

    "Oloi Mazi Boroume" charity concert takes place in central Athens

  80. 08/09 21:15

    Indian Minister: Increasing trade with Greece to $1 billion 'a realistic target'

  81. 08/09 18:17

    Sports Tourism: Two great Greek athletes partner with Navarino challenge

  82. 08/09 16:06

    Museum of Cycladic Art Picasso show attracts over 20K visitors in two months

  83. 08/09 13:00

    Prime Minister: Greece will be the pleasant surprise in the Eurozone

  84. 08/09 11:59

    Greek Prime Minister Mitsotakis to speak in Astoria on September 25

  85. 08/09 00:06

    Religious Tourism: Feast Day of Theotokos Nativity celebrated in Greece

  86. 07/09 23:46

    Greek Orthodox Church marks century of vital work in Uganda (video)

  87. 07/09 21:18

    Study: Greece’s Golden Visa program very attractive for investors

  88. 07/09 18:42

    One extra ferry between Alexandroupolis-Samothrace from September 9-15

  89. 07/09 18:28

    EU Commission to focus on Greek PDO products at 84th TIF 2019

  90. 07/09 18:07

    Minister: Greece needs to win the digital governance wager

  91. 07/09 15:05

    Fisherman in Cyprus saves turtle with plastic ring around her neck (video)

  92. 07/09 14:56

    Huge Amphipolis monument to open possibly in Northern Greece by 2021

  93. 06/09 23:00

    Duchenne awareness event takes place in Greek capital of Athens

  94. 06/09 22:58

    Greek feta cheese becomes riddle for EU-Australia trade deal

  95. 06/09 21:57

    US Ambassador: Greece is ”the guardian of European energy security”

  96. 06/09 18:33

    Travel agency tips: Four reasons to visit Greece in September

  97. 06/09 15:32

    Investments in Greece dominate PM's meeting with US Trade Sec.

  98. 06/09 15:17

    Media: Piraeus tops Valencia as Mediterranean Sea's largest container port

  99. 06/09 15:08

    Greek 10-year bond yields dropped to new record low

  100. 05/09 23:00

    IATA: Trade war impacting international air freight demand