Research demonstrates low risk for coronavirus transmission inflight

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Research demonstrates low risk for coronavirus transmission inflightManufacturer studies provide insight into extremely few incidents of COVID-19 inflight infections

 The International Air Transport Association (IATA) demonstrated the low incidence of inflight COVID-19 transmission with an updated tally of published cases. Since the start of 2020, there have been 44 cases of COVID-19 reported in which transmission is thought to have been associated with a flight journey (inclusive of confirmed, probable, and potential cases). Over the same period, some 1.2 billion passengers have traveled.

“The risk of a passenger contracting COVID-19 while onboard appears very low. With only 44 identified potential cases of flight-related transmission among 1.2 billion travelers, that’s one case for every 27 million travelers. We recognize that this may be an underestimate but even if 90% of the cases were un-reported, it would be one case for every 2.7 million travelers. We think these figures are extremely reassuring.  Furthermore, the vast majority of published cases occurred before the wearing of face coverings inflight became widespread,” said Dr. David Powell, IATA’s Medical Advisor.

New insight into why the numbers are so low has come from the joint publication by Airbus, Boeing and Embraer of separate computational fluid dynamics (CFD) research conducted by each manufacturer in their aircraft. While methodologies differed slightly, each detailed simulation confirmed that aircraft airflow systems do control the movement of particles in the cabin, limiting the spread of viruses. Data from the simulations yielded similar results: 

  • Aircraft airflow systems, High-Efficiency Particulate Air (HEPA) filters, the natural barrier of the seatback, the downward flow of air, and high rates of air exchange efficiently reduce the risk of disease transmission on board in normal times.
  • The addition of mask-wearing amid pandemic concerns adds a further and significant extra layer of protection, which makes being seated in close proximity in an aircraft cabin safer than most other indoor environments.

Data Collection

IATA’s data collection, and the results of the separate simulations, align with the low numbers reported in a recently published peer-reviewed study by Freedman and Wilder-Smith in the Journal of Travel Medicine. Although there is no way to establish an exact tally of possible flight-associated cases, IATA’s outreach to airlines and public health authorities combined with a thorough review of available literature has not yielded any indication that onboard transmission is in any way common or widespread. Further, the Freedman/Wilder-Smith study points to the efficacy of mask-wearing in further reducing risk.

Layered Approach of Preventive Measures

Mask-wearing on board was recommended by IATA in June and is a common requirement on most airlines since the subsequent publication and implementation of the Takeoff Guidance by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). This guidance adds multiple layers of protection on top of the airflow systems which already ensure a safe cabin environment with very low risks of inflight transmission of disease.

“ICAO’s comprehensive guidance for safe air travel amid the COVID-19 crisis relies on multiple layers of protection, which involve the airports as well as the aircraft. Mask-wearing is one of the most visible. But managed queuing, contactless processing, reduced movement in the cabin, and simplified onboard services are among the multiple measures the aviation industry is taking to keep flying safely. And this is on top of the fact that airflow systems are designed to avoid the spread of disease with high airflow rates and air exchange rates and highly effective filtration of any recycled air,” said Powell.

Aircraft design characteristics add a further layer of protection contributing to the low incidence of inflight transmission. These include:

  • Limited face-to-face interactions as passengers face forward and move about very little
  • The effect of the seat-back acting as a physical barrier to air movement from one row to another
  • The minimization of the forward-aft flow of air, with a segmented flow design which is directed generally downward from ceiling to floor
  • The high rate of fresh air coming into the cabin. Air is exchanged 20-30 times per hour on board most aircraft, which compares very favorably with the average office space (average 2-3 times per hour) or schools (average 10-15 times per hour).
  • The use of HEPA filters which have more than 99.9% bacteria/virus removal efficiency rate ensuring that the air supply entering the cabin is not a pathway for introducing microbes.

Manufacturer Studies

The interaction of those design factors in creating a uniquely low-risk environment had been intuitively understood but not previously modeled prior to the CFD simulations by the three major manufacturers in each of their aircraft cabins.

The following are highlights from the manufacturers’ research:

Airbus

Airbus used CFD to create a highly accurate simulation of the air in an A320 cabin, to see how droplets resulting from a cough move within the cabin airflow. The simulation calculated parameters such as airspeed, direction, and temperature at 50 million points in the cabin, up to 1,000 times per second.

Airbus then used the same tools to model a non-aircraft environment, with several individuals keeping six feet (1.8 meters) distance between them. The result was that potential exposure was lower when seated side by side on a plane than when staying six feet apart in an environment such as an office, classroom or grocery store.

“After multiple, highly-detailed simulations using the most accurate scientific methods available, we have concrete data which reveals the aircraft cabin offers a much safer environment than indoor public spaces,” said Bruno Fargeon, Airbus Engineering and the leader of the Airbus Keep Trust in Air Travel Initiative. “The way that air circulates is filtered and replaced on airplanes creates an absolutely unique environment in which you have just as much protection being seated side-by-side as you would standing six feet apart on the ground.”

Boeing

Using CFD, Boeing researchers tracked how particles from coughing and breathing move around the airplane cabin. Various scenarios were studied including the coughing passenger with and without a mask, the coughing passenger located in various seats including the middle seat, and different variations of passengers’ individual overhead air vents (known as gaspers) on and off.

“This modeling determined the number of cough particles that entered the breathing space of the other passengers”, said Dan Freeman, the chief engineer for Boeing’s Confident Travel Initiative.  “We then compared a similar scenario in other environments, such as an office conference room. Based on the airborne particle count, passengers sitting next to one another on an airplane is the same as standing more than seven feet (or two meters) apart in a typical building environment.”

Embraer

Using CFD, cabin airflow and droplet dispersion models validated in full-scale cabin environment testing, Embraer analyzed the cabin environment considering a coughing passenger in several different seats and airflow conditions in our different aircraft to measure these variables and their effect. The research Embraer completed shows that the risk of onboard transmission is extremely low, and the actual data on in-flight transmissions that may have occurred, supports these findings.

Luis Carlos Affonso, Senior Vice-President of Engineering, Technology and Strategy, Embraer, said, "The human need to travel, to connect, and to see our loved ones has not disappeared. In fact, at times like this, we need our families and friends even more. Our message today is that because of the technology and procedures in place, you can fly safely – all the research demonstrates this.  In fact, the cabin of a commercial aircraft is one of the safer spaces available anywhere during this pandemic."

Safety is Always the Top Priority

This research effort demonstrates the cooperation and dedication to the safety of all involved in air transport and provides evidence that cabin air is safe.

Aviation earns its reputation on safety with each and every flight. This is not different for flying in the time of COVID-19. A recent IATA study found that 86% of recent travelers felt that the industry’s COVID-19 measures were keeping them safe and were well-implemented.

“There is no single silver-bullet measure that will enable us to live and travel safely in the age of COVID-19. But the combination of measures that are being put in place is reassuring travelers the world over that COVID-19 has not defeated their freedom to fly. Nothing is completely risk-free. But with just 44 published cases of potential inflight COVID-19 transmission among 1.2 billion travelers, the risk of contracting the virus on board appears to be in the same category as being struck by lightning,” said Alexandre de Juniac, IATA’s Director General and CEO.

“The detailed computational fluid dynamics research of the aircraft manufacturers demonstrates that combining the aircraft’s existing design features with mask-wearing creates a low-risk environment for COVID-19 transmission. As always, airlines, manufacturers, and every entity involved in aviation will be guided by science and global best practices to keep flying safely for passengers and crew,” said de Juniac.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinationsGreek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: pixabay.com

 

Tornos
  1. 01/12 01:00

    Survey: E-commerce turnover tripled to 15 billion euros in Greece during 2020

  2. 01/12 00:50

    Theaters of Ancient of Sikyon and Messene get more funds to improve access by visitors

  3. 30/11 21:08

    Greek government to announce updates concerning Covid-19 measures later in the week

  4. 30/11 19:39

    Greece records 1,044 new Covid-19 cases and 85 fatalities on Monday

  5. 30/11 19:26

    World Travel Awards 2020: Global prizes for Greek tourism - the full list of winners

  6. 30/11 19:04

    Greek researchers produce the first Greek Covid-19 rapid antigen test

  7. 30/11 14:55

    Revenue from tourism dropped by 83% in Cyprus during September 2020

  8. 30/11 14:41

    Greek PM: Slight improvement in northern Greece but next days will be difficult

  9. 30/11 00:45

    Greeks pay more than half a million euros in Covid-19 fines within a day

  10. 29/11 23:30

    Teleworking in Greece extended until December 31st due to pandemic

  11. 29/11 23:27

    Pfizer's CEO: Proud of how Greece handled the Covid-19 pandemic

  12. 29/11 23:24

    Prime Minister: “ Greece must not become low cost investment destination”

  13. 29/11 23:00

    AP: Cyprus lifting coronavirus local lockdowns but not curfew

  14. 29/11 21:17

    Cyprus announces 152 coronavirus cases and 114 positive rapid tests on Sunday

  15. 29/11 15:20

    Greek Shipping Minister hospitalized for 'faster treatment' of infection

  16. 29/11 15:14

    Government spokesperson: There's only one Covid-19 registry in Greece

  17. 28/11 23:10

    UNWTO advancing an international code for protection of tourists

  18. 28/11 23:06

    Greek PM urges Patras to observe health measures during patron saint holiday

  19. 27/11 14:05

    International Air Transport Association launches new exchange for offsets trading​

  20. 27/11 14:01

    Greek Health Minister: The national health system is standing

  21. 27/11 13:53

    AP: Thanksgiving travelers try to reach destinations and miss COVID-19 (video)

  22. 27/11 13:51

    Minister: Schools in Greece could reopen before holidays if epidemiological data permits

  23. 27/11 13:47

    New electric bus hits the streets of the Greek capital of Athens

  24. 27/11 13:42

    Athens Benaki Museum launches online benefit auction of donated art works

  25. 27/11 13:36

    Slovakia adds Greece to Covid-19 high-risk countries after rise in cases

  26. 27/11 13:32

    GNTO head Angela Gerekou: Our goal is sustainable tourism growth

  27. 27/11 13:26

    UNWTO chief in Tunisia: Investments and education focus of high-level visit

  28. 27/11 11:22

    Frontex: Refugee influx to Greece fell 74 % so far during 2020

  29. 27/11 10:53

    European Parliament condemns Varosha reopening by Turkey in Cyprus

  30. 26/11 22:06

    Greece's car Covid-19 mask wearing rules during lockdown explained

  31. 26/11 21:49

    No air carriers to 22 countries forces Cyprus to cancel mail service

  32. 26/11 20:58

    JetBlue Airways to host IATA AGM and World Air Transport Summit in Boston

  33. 26/11 20:06

    Athens cultural institutions to receive emergency funding by Culture Ministry

  34. 26/11 18:46

    Aviation industry agrees on critical slot use relief

  35. 26/11 17:40

    IATA calls on governments to support industry move to sustainable aviation fuel

  36. 26/11 15:33

    Greek state budget showed primary deficit of 9.065 billion euros in January-October

  37. 26/11 13:20

    IATA: International air connectivity crisis threatens global economic recovery

  38. 26/11 11:52

    First visitors of Kerkini Lake started arriving from the north: Swans

  39. 26/11 11:31

    Strong frost expected during the night in northern Greece

  40. 26/11 01:20

    Greek tourism 2020: Loss of 20.8 million tourists and €12.6 billion in first 9 months

  41. 25/11 23:13

    No disruptions in international and domestic flights on Thursday and Friday

  42. 25/11 22:58

    Athens metro on strike, tram on work stoppage, buses & trolleys operate today

  43. 25/11 19:49

    Minister: National health agency has important role to play in pandemic response

  44. 25/11 15:42

    UNWTO global tourism plastics initiative welcomes 26 new signatories

  45. 25/11 13:30

    Minister: Our priority is for schools to reopen after experts offer advice

  46. 25/11 02:00

    "Greek Freak" hands out food to the needy in his old Athens neighbourhood

  47. 25/11 01:56

    Greek PM: Doctors working in ICUs to become permanent staff members

  48. 25/11 01:53

    House prices in Cyprus continued to rise in Q2 despite the pandemic

  49. 25/11 01:06

    7 creative things to do during the lockdown (and always)

  50. 24/11 20:14

    Greece offers 50% tax deductions to foreigners and Greeks who live abroad

  51. 24/11 20:10

    Nobel prize winner's plan on Greece's development posted for public consultation

  52. 24/11 19:46

    Media report: Coronavirus lockdown won't be lifted for travel inside Greece yet

  53. 24/11 19:31

    Greek Minister: Our aim is to give the health system 10 days to 'catch its breath'

  54. 24/11 19:20

    IATA: Aviation industry deep losses continue into 2021

  55. 24/11 19:02

    U.S. Travel Association survey: Future travel with family is a priority for Americans

  56. 24/11 18:54

    Bank of Greece chief: Public debt sustainable at least until 2030

  57. 24/11 15:04

    Qantas CEO: Passengers will need vaccine proof for international flights

  58. 24/11 13:27

    Greek government spokesperson: It is not realistic to open on December 1

  59. 24/11 11:13

    Ipsos: Greece ranks 5th in top tourism brands globally

  60. 24/11 02:49

    International Air Transport Association's Director General will step down

  61. 24/11 02:45

    Greek economy to grow in 2021 with the Covid-19 vaccine a positive factor

  62. 24/11 02:41

    UNWTO in Uruguay: Marking resilience and supporting tourism's sustainable restart

  63. 23/11 22:38

    Greece records significant decrease in COVID-19 cases during last 24 hours

  64. 23/11 21:45

    The Greek government continues to support the national health system

  65. 23/11 19:00

    IATA digital health travel pass key to reopening borders safely

  66. 23/11 17:33

    No metro or tram in Athens on Thursday due to 24-hour strike action

  67. 23/11 17:09

    Greece offers €20 million in financial support to coastal ferry companies

  68. 23/11 13:14

    Interview - Eduardo Santander (ETC): Governments must support tourism firms with easy loans and relief

  69. 22/11 02:23

    Reconstruction of emblematic French Pier greenlighted by Greece's Culture Ministry

  70. 21/11 21:29

    Greek PM calls for for extension of support of EU economies against pandemic

  71. 21/11 20:35

    Greece registers 2,311 new Covid-19 cases and 108 fatalities on Saturday

  72. 21/11 18:39

    U-M Modern Greek Program cooperates with Aristotle University of Thessaloniki

  73. 21/11 15:52

    Air traffic controllers and safety mechanics to strike in Greece next week

  74. 21/11 15:24

    Greek PM to volunteer nurses: 'Act of kindness and deeply patriotic gesture'

  75. 21/11 13:47

    Hellenic College Holy Cross classes to continue online for Spring Semester

  76. 21/11 13:29

    European Commission President warns of 3rd coronavirus wave

  77. 21/11 11:44

    Registered unemployment increases in Greece during October

  78. 20/11 21:19

    Greek PM discusses child protection policy with UNICEF's new chief

  79. 20/11 21:14

    Hellenic Post warns customers not to open this phishing scam e-mail

  80. 20/11 20:57

    2.581 new Covid-19 cases and 72 fatalities recorded in Greece

  81. 20/11 20:15

    Celestyal Cruises offers early ‘Black Friday’ discount & Special Hero’s Day in Greece

  82. 20/11 19:59

    Survey: Greek capital of Athens is the top destination for British travelers

  83. 20/11 16:55

    SNF donation of 174 ICU beds to be delivered gradually in Greece from end December

  84. 20/11 15:02

    Transport Turnover Value Index 30% down in Cyprus during first 9 months of 2020

  85. 20/11 14:20

    Greek Interior Minister: The end of lockdown has to be done very warily

  86. 20/11 14:08

    Greek state budget forecasts economy to grow by 4.8 pct during 2021

  87. 20/11 12:05

    World Children's Day celebrated in Greece on November 20

  88. 19/11 21:55

    Greek PM visits United Arab Emirates for promoting bilateral relations

  89. 19/11 21:50

    AP: Two Cyprus casinos close and three open during COVID-19 pandemic

  90. 19/11 21:45

    Thessaloniki Port sets up subsidiary in Bulgaria linking through rail to Europe

  91. 19/11 21:05

    Greek FM: EU must adopt measures obliging Turkey to respect international law

  92. 19/11 19:46

    Strong winds in the Aegean Sea keep some ships tied at Greek ports

  93. 19/11 18:55

    New draft bill on stricter recycling rules goes on public consultation in Greece

  94. 19/11 18:51

    UNWTO official visit to Brazil to support sustainable recovery of tourism sector

  95. 19/11 17:00

    Infographic: EasyJet records €1.34 billion annual loss in 2020

  96. 19/11 15:10

    3.227 new Covid-19 cases and 59 fatalities recorded in Greece during last 24 hours

  97. 19/11 13:37

    Greece assumes presidency and coordination of Mediterranean Diet in 2021

  98. 18/11 22:08

    Expert: Sewage signs show imminent Covid-19 slowing in Greece

  99. 18/11 22:01

    Greece records 3,209 new Covid-19 cases in last 24 hours

  100. 18/11 21:53

    Rare gospel stolen in 1917 to return to monastery in NE Greek city of Drama