Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from Airbnb

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from AirbnbAirbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders

Since the entry of Airbnb into the hospitality industry in 2008, media attention has largely focused on the disruptive nature of the service. Industry reports, as well as lively debates at hotel, travel and tourism conferences, have kept the spotlight on Airbnb’s growth and success. But despite all this attention, we still know little about its real impact on hotel sales.

In a recent publication in the International Journal of Hospitality Management, Dr. Manisha Singal (Virginia Tech University) and Dr. Jonathan Templin (University of Kansas) examined how Airbnb supply, price, and perceived quality affect the sales performance of incumbent hotels in the San Francisco market. In particular, they explored the impact of the development of Airbnb supply and users’ satisfaction on hotel sales patterns, and whether different hotel segments have been affected by Airbnb’s entry.

The findings revealed that:

Total Airbnb volume does not impact RevPar

Total Airbnb listings (i.e., total inventory) do not impact the growth trajectory of hotel RevPAR, which confirms the argument that Airbnb’s offering a supplementary service. These results are also consistent with a 2017 report on the Airbnb effect in Boston, and with an STR 2017 study of 13 global markets. However,

The average price of an Airbnb offer can have an impact on RevPAR

And that impact varies across different segments of the industry. Airbnb property prices had a positive effect on hotel RevPAR: the higher the price of the rentals posted on the platform, the higher the RevPAR of the hotels. Also,

  • The increase in the quality of the Airbnb service has a direct adverse impact on hotel performance. The higher the average satisfaction score of an Airbnb property, the lower the RevPAR for the hotels in the sample.  More specifically, every increase in the review score of an Airbnb property had a negative impact of -$25.54 on hotel RevPAR for hotels in the sample. Finally,
  • This last effect varies across segments. Airbnb rental prices had an effect on hotels’ RevPAR in the luxury segment, with an increase in RevPAR of $0.651 for every dollar increase in the average rental price of the Airbnb units.

In conclusion

Not just a supplement: The study reveals that Airbnb’s listings/offers do not merely supplement the lodging market, but rather show substitute characteristics in their long-term effects on hotel sales’ patterns.

Customers make comparisons: The effect of Airbnb on hotels sales is intricate, and appears to be based on customers’ dynamic comparison of the price and value offered by the two products.  The research results imply that guests do consider both products when booking rooms and compare the benefits of each through user reviews.

Signs of disruption: The results provide empirical evidence that Airbnb will disrupt the hotel business, and that the more Airbnb users are satisfied with their experience, the more likely it is that demand for hotel rooms will decrease. Hotel managers therefore need to be aware of the level of service and price offered by Airbnb and other sharing platforms in their market.  Airbnb offers in their locality can no longer be ignored and should be considered when developing revenue management strategies.

Airbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders.  The impact of the sharing economy is not related so much to the volume of the offers on the platform, but rather on the pricing and price-to-value proposition as perceived by guests.

Read more at ehotelier.com

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: pixabay.com

 

Tornos
  1. 16/06 20:34

    Helmos Mountain Festival | Kalavryta ski resort as an art and entertainment theme park

  2. 16/06 17:37

    The Kalamata-Crete air connection will boost tourism in the two regions

  3. 16/06 15:30

    Ol. Kefalogianni on Israel: So far, there are no cancellations – “We are resilient to crises”

  4. 16/06 13:53

    Promotion of Greek wine tourism in Germany

  5. 16/06 13:20

    Repatriation flights for stranded Israelis in 72 hours

  6. 16/06 12:57

    FedHATTA/ HATTA: Meeting with the Minister of Culture for a unified direction in cultural tourism

  7. 16/06 11:59

    65-page tribute to Rhodes in the online magazine of the University of Naples

  8. 16/06 11:08

    Fraport Greece: Which airports "passed the mark" in May

  9. 16/06 11:03

    New Dolce by Wyndham hotel in Sicily

  10. 16/06 07:25

    14 reasons why Crete is irresistible, according to Condé Nast Traveller

  11. 16/06 06:41

    Cruise Tourism in the Mediterranean Is Changing - And We’re Here to Lead the Way

  12. 15/06 08:22

    Region of the Aegean | Extraordinary campaign with TUI to promote Santorini

  13. 15/06 06:25

    Ververoda Easy Trail Run 2025 and Porto Heli Night Run 2025 in Porto Heli

  14. 14/06 13:19

    The cruise ship Norwegian Viva is in the port of Volos

  15. 14/06 07:30

    “Kefalonian Tratarisma”: Second Gastronomic and Wine Festival in Argostoli

  16. 14/06 07:28

    The new Head of Direct Sales and Customer Loyalty at alltours

  17. 14/06 07:07

    McKinsey: Europeans’ summer vacation sentiment is up - the US market is sluggish

  18. 13/06 19:59

    Strengthening Greek-Polish tourism diplomacy

  19. 13/06 19:02

    Athens Airport and Gulf Air celebrated the company’s 75th anniversary together

  20. 13/06 15:05

    Ministerial Meeting with CLIA: Focus on Sustainable Cruise Development in Greece

  21. 13/06 14:16

    All marine areas of the Heraklion Regional Unit are suitable for swimming

  22. 13/06 12:21

    Rodos Park: Summer events program starting on June 19

  23. 13/06 11:54

    ABTA | Outbound tourism from Britain to grow by 20% by 2030

  24. 13/06 11:24

    The “Mountain School” begins in the Municipality of Sfakia

  25. 13/06 08:28

    Heraklion hosts the first Tourism Law Conference

  26. 13/06 07:32

    easyJet: New connections to Corfu and Rhodes from Newcastle in 2026

  27. 13/06 07:13

    The Cyclades on travmagazine.be: A paradise of experiences in the Aegean

  28. 13/06 06:19

    National Geographic’s Ode to Authentic Greek Cuisine

  29. 13/06 06:16

    New cycle of excavations at the Homeric School in Ithaca

  30. 12/06 04:55

    TUI: Cyprus and Greece are the "hot" destinations for Swedes this summer

  31. 12/06 04:55

    The Olive Tree of Peace: From Ancient Olympia to Brussels

  32. 12/06 04:52

    8th Lykourgos Logothetis Trophy: Sports, Culture and Tourism Development in Samos

  33. 12/06 04:50

    Air Haifa: When does the new seasonal connection to Rhodes start

  34. 12/06 04:38

    Greece in the top 10 most accessible countries in Europe for digital nomads

  35. 12/06 04:35

    Rethymno: On the front lines for the protection of the Loggerhead Sea Turtle

  36. 11/06 21:31

    Fokion Karavias | India, a great opportunity for Greek tourism

  37. 11/06 16:34

    Taste of Loutraki 2025: Corinth at the forefront of culinary tourism

  38. 11/06 15:42

    Digital promotion of Pieria as a tourist destination

  39. 11/06 15:38

    The Region of Crete at the “London Wine Fair 2025” exhibition

  40. 11/06 14:49

    Wyndham Hotels: Partnership with Pegasus Airlines for new loyalty program

  41. 11/06 14:47

    EOT at ITB China 2025 - Promotional actions in the Chinese market

  42. 11/06 11:54

    Vamos! Flamenco Camp 2025 | Art and cultural workshop in Vamos, Apokoronas

  43. 11/06 11:25

    Where will the French travel this year | Greece remains at the top

  44. 11/06 08:58

    Why Americans prefer extended-stay hotels

  45. 11/06 08:07

    Cultural actions in Technopolis by the Ministry of Culture, Region, and Municipality

  46. 11/06 08:05

    Nautical Week in Volos 2025 with Crete as the honored region

  47. 11/06 08:02

    The Sun's Tribute to Karpathos | Significant Promotion of the Island in Britain

  48. 10/06 23:47

    Olga Kefalogianni: Greece at the center of international investment developments in tourism

  49. 10/06 17:56

    Mandrakia Artis Festival 2025 for the third year in Milos

  50. 10/06 17:53

    Scientific meeting on elderly care in Crete

  51. 10/06 17:42

    Americans, Britons, and French choose Greece at the last minute

  52. 10/06 15:00

    Visa Survey | Beaches, Culture, and Scenic Destinations Draw Tourists to Greece

  53. 10/06 11:05

    Greece “Best Travel Destination in the World” for Finns

  54. 10/06 08:07

    Promotion of Sifnos in Cyprus

  55. 10/06 07:17

    The Municipality of Monemvasia is among the top in the country

  56. 10/06 07:11

    Gastronomic Festival “The Treasures of the Corinthian Land”

  57. 10/06 06:20

    Andreas Andreadis: Ikos Kissamos opens in April 2026

  58. 09/06 08:22

    The Elite of Greek Hospitality

  59. 07/06 06:18

    Crete “goes up” to Lycabettus – Honorary concert for Vassilis Skoulas

  60. 06/06 16:21

    New air connection Thessaloniki - Syros with Aegean Airlines flights

  61. 06/06 15:31

    Under the auspices of the GNTO, international golf, jet ski, and road race events

  62. 06/06 15:27

    Creation of a modern Romania-Bulgaria-Greece interconnection axis

  63. 06/06 12:48

    Region of Central Macedonia: 13 million euros to promote cultural heritage

  64. 06/06 12:38

    Silk City Run: Road Races in the Silk City

  65. 06/06 12:34

    The Municipality of Rethymno is on the front lines for environmental protection

  66. 06/06 07:41

    How the Mesolongi Lagoon will evolve into an international sports tourism destination

  67. 06/06 06:44

    Iberia: Flights to Athens to be strengthened in August with Airbus A330

  68. 06/06 06:31

    jet2 Group | Record 4.4 million seats for winter holidays in 2026-2027

  69. 06/06 05:22

    Athens Airport | Passenger traffic up 8.5% in 5 months, + 2.9% in May

  70. 05/06 04:55

    Conference on the primary sector and local products in Kalavrita

  71. 05/06 04:34

    World Environment Day: 50 actions from Evros to the Dodecanese

  72. 05/06 04:30

    Cruise Record in Katakolo in 2025 – 265 Ships Expected

  73. 05/06 04:30

    Ancient Olympia, a culinary destination | From the cotino to the glass

  74. 05/06 04:20

    Jet Raid Amfilochia 2025: Amfilochia at the epicenter of sports tourism

  75. 04/06 23:45

    SiFNaThLoN 2025: Promoting Sifnos as a sports destination

  76. 04/06 20:28

    Rhodes - AEGEAN | Warm welcome to passengers from Istanbul

  77. 04/06 19:51

    Thessaly from above: Premiere of hot air balloon flights

  78. 04/06 19:39

    Thessaly from above: Premiere for hot air balloon flights

  79. 04/06 16:06

    Fotis Fakes takes over as CEO of alltours Greece S.A.

  80. 04/06 15:59

    Europe’s top underrated luxury destinations for 2025 | Paros 6th, Skiathos 14th

  81. 04/06 12:13

    Forbes Global Properties to host its 2026 annual conference in Corfu

  82. 04/06 11:17

    Central Macedonia's dynamic presence at ITB China 2025

  83. 04/06 09:19

    Green light for the modernization of the Amoudara Baths – Boost to health tourism in Argos Orestiko

  84. 04/06 07:25

    Air Mediterranean: New Athens - Damascus connection

  85. 04/06 07:22

    Fam trips bring positive coverage for Santorini

  86. 03/06 18:20

    Porto Carras Pro-Am AEGEAN Mini Tour 2025: An institution for golf tourism with international glamour in Halkidiki

  87. 03/06 17:24

    Santorini Experience returns for its 8th year from 10-12 October 2025

  88. 03/06 12:20

    Political situation in destinations influences Germans' travel choices | Survey

  89. 03/06 11:53

    Europe’s Best Beach for 2025 is in Halkidiki | Glarokavos Beach

  90. 03/06 11:43

    Cultural Routes in Apokoronas, Chania | Conference

  91. 03/06 07:50

    “Landing” of the Indian low-cost carrier IndiGo in Athens

  92. 03/06 07:48

    Promotion of Wine Tourism in Germany by GNTO and the Greek Embassy

  93. 03/06 01:12

    Retro routes in Samos: The Tour de Samos Antique Rally returns for the 5th year

  94. 02/06 11:57

    Bicycle Day in Rethymno with guided tours of the city's monuments

  95. 02/06 11:54

    Gavdos in the frame of sports tourism

  96. 02/06 08:49

    FlixTrain | A new era for high-speed train travel in Europe

  97. 02/06 08:30

    What investors are asking for from hotel brands

  98. 02/06 08:00

    Samos is at the center of international tourism promotion through Skyscanner

  99. 02/06 07:04

    Football, hospitality, and tourism promotion: Chios welcomes a mixed team from Turkey

  100. 02/06 06:45

    Chania | + 20.6% cruise passengers in 5 months - 82,600 visitors to the city