EU fines Google €2.42 billion for abusing dominance as search engine

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
EU fines Google €2.42 billion for abusing dominance as search engineCommission deduces breach of EU antitrust rules over illegal advantages to own comparison shopping service

The European Commission has fined Google €2.42 billion for breaching EU antitrust rules. Google has abused its market dominance as a search engine by giving an illegal advantage to another Google product, its comparison shopping service.

The company must now end the conduct within 90 days or face penalty payments of up to 5% of the average daily worldwide turnover of Alphabet, Google's parent company.

Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: "Google has come up with many innovative products and services that have made a difference to our lives. That's a good thing. But Google's strategy for its comparison shopping service wasn't just about attracting customers by making its product better than those of its rivals. Instead, Google abused its market dominance as a search engine by promoting its own comparison shopping service in its search results, and demoting those of competitors.

What Google has done is illegal under EU antitrust rules. It denied other companies the chance to compete on the merits and to innovate. And most importantly, it denied European consumers a genuine choice of services and the full benefits of innovation."

Google's strategy for its comparison shopping service

Google's flagship product is the Google search engine, which provides search results to consumers, who pay for the service with their data. Almost 90% of Google's revenues stem from adverts, such as those it shows consumers in response to a search query.

In 2004 Google entered the separate market of comparison shopping in Europe, with a product that was initially called "Froogle", re-named "Google Product Search" in 2008 and since 2013 has been called "Google Shopping". It allows consumers to compare products and prices online and find deals from online retailers of all types, including online shops of manufacturers, platforms (such as Amazon and eBay), and other re-sellers.

When Google entered comparison shopping markets with Froogle, there were already a number of established players. Contemporary evidence from Google shows that the company was aware that Froogle's market performance was relatively poor (one internal document from 2006 stated "Froogle simply doesn't work").

Comparison shopping services rely to a large extent on traffic to be competitive. More traffic leads to more clicks and generates revenue. Furthermore, more traffic also attracts more retailers that want to list their products with a comparison shopping service. Given Google's dominance in general internet search, its search engine is an important source of traffic for comparison shopping services.

From 2008, Google began to implement in European markets a fundamental change in strategy to push its comparison shopping service. This strategy relied on Google's dominance in general internet search, instead of competition on the merits in comparison shopping markets:

Google has systematically given prominent placement to its own comparison shopping service: when a consumer enters a query into the Google search engine in relation to which Google's comparison shopping service wants to show results, these are displayed at or near the top of the search results.

Google has demoted rival comparison shopping services in its search results: rival comparison shopping services appear in Google's search results on the basis of Google's generic search algorithms. Google has included a number of criteria in these algorithms, as a result of which rival comparison shopping services are demoted. Evidence shows that even the most highly ranked rival service appears on average only on page four of Google's search results, and others appear even further down. Google's own comparison shopping service is not subject to Google's generic search algorithms, including such demotions.

As a result, Google's comparison shopping service is much more visible to consumers in Google's search results, whilst rival comparison shopping services are much less visible.

The evidence shows that consumers click far more often on results that are more visible, i.e. the results appearing higher up in Google's search results. Even on a desktop, the ten highest-ranking generic search results on page 1 together generally receive approximately 95% of all clicks on generic search results (with the top result receiving about 35% of all the clicks). The first result on page 2 of Google's generic search results receives only about 1% of all clicks. This cannot just be explained by the fact that the first result is more relevant, because evidence also shows that moving the first result to the third rank leads to a reduction in the number of clicks by about 50%. The effects on mobile devices are even more pronounced given the much smaller screen size.

This means that by giving prominent placement only to its own comparison shopping service and by demoting competitors, Google has given its own comparison shopping service a significant advantage compared to rivals.

Breach of EU antitrust rules

Google's practices amount to an abuse of Google's dominant position in general internet search by stifling competition in comparison shopping markets.

Market dominance is, as such, not illegal under EU antitrust rules. However, dominant companies have a special responsibility not to abuse their powerful market position by restricting competition, either in the market where they are dominant or in separate markets.

Today's Decision concludes that Google is dominant in general internet search markets throughout the European Economic Area (EEA), i.e. in all 31 EEA countries. It found Google to have been dominant in general internet search markets in all EEA countries since 2008, except in the Czech Republic where the Decision has established dominance since 2011. This assessment is based on the fact that Google's search engine has held very high market shares in all EEA countries, exceeding 90% in most. It has done so consistently since at least 2008, which is the period investigated by the Commission. There are also high barriers to entry in these markets, in part because of network effects: the more consumers use a search engine, the more attractive it becomes to advertisers. The profits generated can then be used to attract even more consumers. Similarly, the data a search engine gathers about consumers can in turn be used to improve results.

Google has abused this market dominance by giving its own comparison shopping service an illegal advantage. It gave prominent placement in its search results only to its own comparison shopping service, whilst demoting rival services. It stifled competition on the merits in comparison shopping markets. 

Google introduced this practice in all 13 EEA countries where Google has rolled out its comparison shopping service, starting in January 2008 in Germany and the United Kingdom. It subsequently extended the practice to France in October 2010, Italy, the Netherlands, and Spain in May 2011, the Czech Republic in February 2013 and Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, Poland and Sweden in November 2013.

The effect of Google's illegal practices

Google's illegal practices have had a significant impact on competition between Google's own comparison shopping service and rival services. They allowed Google's comparison shopping service to make significant gains in traffic at the expense of its rivals and to the detriment of European consumers.

Given Google's dominance in general internet search, its search engine is an important source of traffic. As a result of Google's illegal practices, traffic to Google's comparison shopping service increased significantly, whilst rivals have suffered very substantial losses of traffic on a lasting basis.

Since the beginning of each abuse, Google's comparison shopping service has increased its traffic 45-fold in the United Kingdom, 35-fold in Germany, 19-fold in France, 29-fold in the Netherlands, 17-fold in Spain and 14-fold in Italy.

Following the demotions applied by Google, traffic to rival comparison shopping services on the other hand dropped significantly. For example, the Commission found specific evidence of sudden drops of traffic to certain rival websites of 85% in the United Kingdom, up to 92% in Germany and 80% in France. These sudden drops could also not be explained by other factors. Some competitors have adapted and managed to recover some traffic but never in full.

In combination with the Commission's other findings, this shows that Google's practices have stifled competition on the merits in comparison shopping markets, depriving European consumers of genuine choice and innovation.

Evidence gathered

In reaching its Decision, the Commission has gathered and comprehensively analysed a broad range of evidence, including:

1)    contemporary documents from both Google and other market players;

2)    very significant quantities of real-world data including 5.2 Terabytes of actual search results from Google (around 1.7 billion search queries);

3)    experiments and surveys, analysing in particular the impact of visibility in search results on consumer behaviour and click-through rates;

4)    financial and traffic data which outline the commercial importance of visibility in Google's search results and the impact of being demoted; and

5)    an extensive market investigation of customers and competitors in the markets concerned (the Commission addressed questionnaires to several hundred companies).

Consequences of the Decision

The Commission's fine of €2 424 495 000 takes account of the duration and gravity of the infringement. In accordance with the Commission's 2006 Guidelines on fines (see press release and MEMO), the fine has been calculated on the basis of the value of Google's revenue from its comparison shopping service in the 13 EEA countries concerned.

The Commission Decision requires Google to stop its illegal conduct within 90 days of the Decision and refrain from any measure that has the same or an equivalent object or effect. In particular, the Decision orders Google to comply with the simple principle of giving equal treatment to rival comparison shopping services and its own service:

Google has to apply the same processes and methods to position and display rival comparison shopping services in Google's search results pages as it gives to its own comparison shopping service.

It is Google's sole responsibility to ensure compliance and it is for Google to explain how it intends to do so. Regardless of which option Google chooses, the Commission will monitor Google's compliance closely and Google is under an obligation to keep the Commission informed of its actions (initially within 60 days of the Decision, followed by periodic reports).

If Google fails to comply with the Commission's Decision, it would be liable for non-compliance payments of up to 5% of the average daily worldwide turnover of Alphabet, Google's parent company. The Commission would have to determine such non-compliance in a separate decision, with any payment backdated to when the non-compliance started.

Finally, Google is also liable to face civil actions for damages that can be brought before the courts of the Member States by any person or business affected by its anti-competitive behaviour. The new EU Antitrust Damages Directive makes it easier for victims of anti-competitive practices to obtain damages.

Other Google cases

The Commission has already come to the preliminary conclusion that Google has abused a dominant position in two other cases, which are still being investigated. These concern:

1)    the Android operating system, where the Commission is concerned that Google has stifled choice and innovation in a range of mobile apps and services by pursuing an overall strategy on mobile devices to protect and expand its dominant position in general internet search; and

2)    AdSense, where the Commission is concerned that Google has reduced choice by preventing third-party websites from sourcing search ads from Google's competitors.

The Commission also continues to examine Google's treatment in its search results of other specialised Google search services. Today's Decision is a precedent which establishes the framework for the assessment of the legality of this type of conduct. At the same time, it does not replace the need for a case-specific analysis to account for the specific characteristics of each market.

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 10/07 22:53

    Greek-American congressmen meet Greek Prime Minister in Washington DC

  2. 10/07 22:50

    Greek National Gallery's 'Democracy' looks at Southern European history and art

  3. 10/07 21:56

    Greek parliament approves upgrade of Academy of Athens

  4. 10/07 19:59

    Cypriot President visits Athens for event on 50th anniversary of Turkish invasion

  5. 10/07 15:44

    24-hour taxi strike in Athens on Thursday

  6. 09/07 22:28

    The SFGFF comes to Athens in cooperation with Feelgood Entertainment

  7. 09/07 20:34

    Prolonged heatwave forecast in Greece during July

  8. 09/07 18:30

    Deal for development of Sani-Kassandra property in Chalkidiki is inked

  9. 09/07 14:57

    Golf & Maritime for a Good Cause at the 10th Greek Maritime Golf Event

  10. 09/07 11:56

    The Ultimate Sports Event of Santorini Experience Coming to Santorini on October 3-6

  11. 08/07 22:53

    Capital Link Invest in Greece webinar series continues on July 9 and 16

  12. 08/07 22:25

    Summer sales to last in Greece until August 31

  13. 08/07 20:43

    New data on the burial site of Lord Byron's illegitimate daughter Allegra

  14. 08/07 15:37

    German ambassador: 'To live and work in Greece has always been my dream'

  15. 05/07 22:14

    Greek port of Piraeus approves distribution of highest dividend in its history

  16. 04/07 23:09

    Culture Minister inaugurates renovated theater at Dion in Central Macedonia

  17. 04/07 19:17

    The 43rd Thessaloniki Book Festival opens at the waterfront Friday until July 21

  18. 04/07 17:20

    Piraeus Port greenlights distribution of highest dividend in its history

  19. 03/07 00:24

    Olympic Festival Paris 2024 held at the SNFCC

  20. 03/07 00:02

    Hotrec reveals digital trends in tourism: Hotels, Booking.com and DMA

  21. 01/07 19:28

    Higher June temperatures in Greece compared to 2010–2019 average

  22. 01/07 19:13

    More firefighting aircraft to reinforce firefighting efforts in Greek island of Kos

  23. 01/07 17:26

    SNF extends support for the Greek National Opera in Athens with an €11 million grant

  24. 01/07 12:31

    Amendment extending duration of measures against high prices tabled in Greek Parliament

  25. 28/06 19:18

    Mount Pelion steam tourist train resumes daily service beginning July 1

  26. 26/06 22:56

    Significance of OECD anti-bribery report for Greece's good image highlighted

  27. 25/06 19:08

    FTI insolvency: Operational business of hotels remains unaffected

  28. 25/06 16:19

    FinMin urges Greek banks to emulate European counterparts regarding commission charges

  29. 25/06 12:12

    AEGEAN elected "Best Regional Airline in Europe" at the World Airline Awards 2024

  30. 25/06 10:16

    Platform for Greece's 'Thessaly & Evros Pass 2024' opens on Tuesday

  31. 22/06 22:49

    Bank of Greece: Travel receipts increased by 22.0% during January-April 2024

  32. 22/06 18:11

    Greek Tourism Ministry and embassies cooperate to address sector issues

  33. 22/06 18:05

    Wyndham inked deal with Oikos for the first Ramada Residences in Greece

  34. 21/06 17:57

    Event organized to present 'The Ilisian' - the new name of the former Athens Hilton

  35. 19/06 23:47

    Greek state ten-year bond auction concluded with yield at 3.56%

  36. 19/06 23:41

    Shipping Minister: Greece supports EU's efforts to modernise maritime safety rules

  37. 19/06 22:32

    Culture minister reviews NSRF projects on the Greek island of Lesvos

  38. 19/06 19:41

    US Ambassador to Athens applauds Greece’s comeback and investors interest

  39. 19/06 11:44

    Minister: Reforms must follow investments to boost regional competitiveness

  40. 18/06 18:15

    ARF 2024: US Ambassador to Athens on Greece's economic miracle

  41. 18/06 16:33

    Capital Region AHEPA organizes 5th Annual Golf Outing in New York

  42. 18/06 14:58

    Wellness, Longevity, Gastronomy at Navarino Challenge 2024 | The multi-sport event presented its activities for this year

  43. 18/06 14:24

    Greek Minister refers to multiple benefits from the restoration of the Athens Riviera

  44. 18/06 13:35

    Regional Governor of Attica: Greeks living abroad are the most important ambassadors

  45. 17/06 19:02

    Conference focuses on Sifnos and sustainable development on Greek islands

  46. 17/06 18:56

    Council of State discusses relocation of Mount Parnitha casino to Marousi again

  47. 17/06 18:56

    Ministers and Super League chief talk digital tickets for upcoming soccer matches

  48. 17/06 15:59

    Forecast: Very high risk of fire in two Greek regions including Attica

  49. 17/06 13:42

    Passenger traffic in Greek ports records an increase of 11.1% during Q4 2023

  50. 14/06 22:58

    Greek port of Preveza attracts visitors from Serbia

  51. 14/06 22:03

    Temperature drop expected in Greece on Saturday

  52. 14/06 17:58

    Athens and Thessaloniki added 250 new electric buses to their urban transport networks

  53. 13/06 22:43

    National Theater to perform Aristophanes at ancient Greek theaters over the summer

  54. 12/06 11:48

    Athens Acropolis site closed down from 12:00 to 17:00 due to high temperatures

  55. 12/06 00:01

    'Poor Things' costumes exhbition at Benaki Museum in downtown Athens

  56. 11/06 15:53

    Schools in Athens to stay closed on Wednesday and Thursday due to heatwave

  57. 11/06 00:10

    Greek Port Authority to acquire 11 boats for transfer of patients from remote islands

  58. 11/06 00:03

    Greece's Interior Ministry issues directions for remote work during heatwave

  59. 10/06 23:45

    Digital app for travellers to Greece 'mAIGreece' goes live on Monday

  60. 10/06 22:28

    Greek Interior Ministry issues directions for remote work during heatwave on Tuesday-Thursday

  61. 10/06 19:38

    Traffic restored on new Greek national highway leading to Corinth after truck explosion

  62. 10/06 14:42

    Very high temperatures in Greece during the following days

  63. 09/06 22:47

    High prices of consumer goods in Greek supermarkets are on a downward trend

  64. 09/06 11:18

    UK Tourism 2024: Greece named top destination in the world with best value for money

  65. 08/06 00:22

    Insolvency: FTI Touristik GmbH cancels all trips up to and including 05 July 2024

  66. 07/06 02:54

    ERTFLIX International takes part in the Los Angeles Greek Film Festival

  67. 07/06 02:42

    NBG: Greek tourism to break record in 2024 with 35 million arrivals and €22 billion in revenue

  68. 06/06 20:50

    Greece elected to UN Security Council for 2025-26 in a 'historic day'

  69. 06/06 13:57

    Hellenic National Archaeological Museum presents "The last Aphrodites" exhibition

  70. 05/06 22:00

    FTI provisional insolvency admin strives for fastest possible solutions for clients

  71. 05/06 00:13

    Turkey denies allowing Lord Elgin take Parthenon Marbles off Athens Acropolis

  72. 04/06 20:04

    Migration & Asylum Ministry greenlights extra funding for 5 Greek island municipalities

  73. 04/06 14:55

    Greek wine promotion event in London held under the auspices of GNTO

  74. 04/06 09:33

    Firms of the FTI GROUP file for insolvency

  75. 01/06 23:59

    Regalia of King Otto on display in the Greek parliament in Athens until 2073

  76. 30/05 22:04

    Eight groups submit expression of interest for Greek port of Lavrio

  77. 30/05 21:01

    Traffic restrictions in Athens on Sunday morning for Cancer Survivors Day event

  78. 30/05 20:19

    Conference and Summit of Global Archons conclides with dinner at Zappeion

  79. 30/05 18:15

    Posidonia 2024: Minister wants more ships and related firms registered in Greece

  80. 30/05 15:23

    Greek government spokesperson announces launch of new Entrepreneurship Fund

  81. 29/05 23:31

    National Opera adds fifth performance of 'Tosca' due to high demand in Athens

  82. 29/05 21:24

    Japan's Princess Kako tours Greece and visits National Foundation for the Deaf in Corfu

  83. 29/05 19:20

    Attica Region governor talks synergies with firms, agencies at Shanghai conference

  84. 29/05 18:16

    ATTICA GREEN EXPO 2024: Deputy Tourism Minister promotes sustainable tourism

  85. 29/05 15:11

    Greek Prime Minister meets Emir of Qatar and two bilateral agreements are signed

  86. 29/05 14:47

    Registrations Open for Navarino Challenge 2024

  87. 28/05 22:58

    Greek PM: We will continue to work hard to curb rising prices

  88. 28/05 22:54

    Greek FinMin utilizes Recovery Fund, NSRF to be in vanguard of green transition

  89. 28/05 19:46

    'The Enigma of Keros' clinches Audience Favorite prize at International Festival in Oregon

  90. 28/05 17:49

    Former US Secretary of State Pompeo addresses Archon Conference in Athens

  91. 28/05 17:41

    European report confirms 95.8% of bathing waters in Greece have 'excellent quality'

  92. 27/05 23:05

    Türkiye's Ambassador to Athens on boosting economic, commercial, and cultural relations

  93. 27/05 21:11

    4th International Conference on Religious Freedom of Archons commences in Athens

  94. 27/05 20:19

    Delegation from the Saudi Arabia visits ONEX shipyards in Elefsis near Athens

  95. 27/05 18:15

    Princess Kako takes part in 125th anniversary of Greek-Japanese diplomatic relations

  96. 27/05 14:07

    National Opera offers free tickets to the dress rehearsal of 'Tosca' for the jobless

  97. 23/05 23:30

    New Evinos bridge in Central Greece inaugurated by Transport Minister

  98. 23/05 21:34

    Greece hosting meeting of International Organization of Securities Commissions May 26-29

  99. 23/05 20:37

    Greek Deputy Foreign Minister highlights efforts to counter brain drain

  100. 23/05 20:24

    Greek government to improve ties with Diaspora and consular services by AI