Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: Good

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: GoodThe Mediterranean Diet can cut risk of heart attacks and strokes by 30 percent in those at high risk

It’s unlikely to surprise people in Greece and on the island of Crete where they’ve been eating fruits, vegetables, nuts and olive oil since ancient times, but a study redone after its methods were found to be flawed has come to the same conclusion: the Mediterranean Diet works.

It took the authors to swallow their pride and acknowledge errors in how the study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2013 was done but one of the lead researchers,  Dr. Miguel A. Martínez-González of the University of Navarra in Spain, said the result was gratifying.

“After all this long work, I am more convinced than ever” by the study’s data that was redone after some embarrassing moments when the original work was questioned. “Seldom has a trial undergone more scrutiny,” he added.

The results of the retracted, redone study were reported in the New York Times and showed that despite some skepticism that the Mediterranean Diet can cut risk of heart attacks and strokes by 30 percent in those at high risk.

While the research was done in Spain, the diet studied was strikingly similar to that in Greece and other Mediterranean countries and the re-analysis showed essentially what the landmark original did.

Not everyone is convinced. “Nothing they have done in this re-analyzed paper makes me more confident,” said Dr. Barnett Kramer, Director of the Division of Cancer Prevention at the National Cancer Institute told the paper.

The credibility of the study

The flaws threatened to undercut the credibility of the study, especially among doubters and because the assignment of diets into three groups wasn’t as random as it was supposed to be, skewing the first results.

The trial enrolled 7,447 participants aged 55 to 80 who were assigned one of three diets: a Mediterranean diet with at least four tablespoons a day of extra virgin olive oil; the same diet with an ounce of mixed nuts; or a traditional low-fat diet.

The participants were followed for a median of nearly five years. Dr. Martínez-González and his colleagues reported that there were fewer cardiovascular events in the groups consuming olive oil and nuts.

All that came into question last year when Dr. John Carlisle of Torbay Hospital in England challenged the data and a statistician at the New England Journal of Medicine suggested the researchers look at the methods at each center that recruited participants and the not-so-random assignments in some cases.

On re-evaluating their data, the scientists running the new study soon found what Dr. Martínez-González said were “small problems affecting 10 percent of participants.”

Some investigators would assign one person in a household — the wife, for example — to one arm of the study — say, to the group consuming olive oil. Then they would ask other members of the household to share that diet, including them as though they had been randomly assigned to it.

We realized we had never reported that,” Dr. Martínez-González said.It got worse.

Trial in small villages

A researcher at one of the 11 clinical centers in the trial worked in small villages. Participants there complained that some neighbors were receiving free olive oil, while they got only nuts or inexpensive gifts.

So the investigator decided to give everyone in each village the same diet. He never told the leaders of the study what he had done. “He did not think it was important,” Dr. Martínez-González said.

It was because it meant the participants were not randomized and forced the team make another adjustment to data on 652 people in the trial along with 390 others who hadn’t been randomly assigned one of the three diets.

The investigators spent a year working on the re-analysis in collaboration with Dr. Miguel Hernan of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

In the end, they concluded that the original findings were still accurate, but the disbelievers remain unconvinced and excoriated the researchers and the work that created a flawed study in the first place.

“These people were naïve,” said Donald Berry, a statistician at MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston.  “They were sloppy and didn’t know they were being sloppy.”

Cooking with extra virgin olive oil

He said he wants to believe because he loves nuts and has taken to cooking with extra virgin olive oil but doesn’t think the re-analysis solved the study’s problems beyond a doubt that can’t be calculated.

But he remains unconvinced, because the re-analysis did not solve the study’s problems, he said.

Dr. Bradley Efron, a statistics professor at Stanford University, also was skeptical. The revamped results “wouldn’t convince me to be on a Mediterranean diet,” he said.

Dr. Steven Nissen, a cardiologist at the Cleveland Clinic, is persuaded though and said he plans to continue advising patients to go on the Mediterranean Diet and is satisfied with the new findings that were the old findings.

It turned out about 14 percent of the more than 7,400 study participants hadn’t been assigned randomly to either the Mediterranean Diet or a low-fat one.

“This affected only a small part of the trial,” said Martínez González. When the researchers reanalyzed the data excluding the nonrandomized people, the results were the same, he added

Still, because everybody wasn’t randomly assigned to different groups, the study can no longer claim the diet directly caused those health benefits. “We need to tone down the results, but it is just a little bit,” he said, according to NPR.

David Allison, Dean of the School of Public Health at Indiana University in Bloomington told the radio station some logic is needed too, the way he put it.

“I don’t know anybody who would turn around from this and say, ‘Now that this has been revealed, we should all eat cotton candy and turn away from the Mediterranean Diet'”

Read more at thenationalherald.com

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: Wikimedia Commons Copyright: Michael W. Pendergrass License: CC-BY-SA 

 

 

Tornos
  1. 14/12 18:13

    Schubert, stories and workshops in Athens Archaeological Museum for Christmas

  2. 14/12 17:54

    Berliner Zeitung: Persecuted Turks in Thessaloniki reveal that the Greeks saved them

  3. 14/12 17:44

    Building activity up on the rise across Greece during September 2018

  4. 14/12 17:36

    Religious Tourism: Repairing churches and mosques in Cyprus for 10 years

  5. 14/12 17:28

    Winter Tourism in Greece: Christmas in the picturesque city of Kastoria

  6. 14/12 17:13

    Lloyd’s List on Cosco: Operator of Greek Piraeus port is the global leader

  7. 14/12 16:01

    "Survival guide" to Exarcheia, Athens' most bohemian neighbourhood

  8. 14/12 14:48

    Greek Coast Guard storms Syrian drug-carrying vessel off Crete (video)

  9. 14/12 12:03

    WWF: 9 in 10 Greeks call for stricter environmental protection laws

  10. 14/12 10:36

    Cultural Tourism: Watch Greek theatre with English subtitles in Athens

  11. 13/12 23:21

    PhocusWire: How Voice Command Technology will change tourism in 2019

  12. 13/12 23:07

    Passenger traffic at Greek airports soars 10.1% in January-November 2018

  13. 13/12 22:44

    Public and private partnership projects in Greece already surpass 1.2 billion

  14. 13/12 22:19

    ‘Little Foot’ excavation skeleton unveils mysterious 3.67 million human relative

  15. 13/12 21:42

    Opera based on ancient Greek tragedy Oedipus Rex at BAM 201

  16. 13/12 19:26

    Chinese envoy to Greece details ambitious Belt & Road initiative

  17. 13/12 18:09

    Breathing new life into ancient toys to generate children’s interest

  18. 13/12 16:58

    Giannis Antetokounmpo to Toronto Diaspora: “Long Live Greece”

  19. 13/12 16:54

    Lloyd’s List Greek Shipping Awards for 2018 at central Athens event

  20. 13/12 16:12

    SETE: Synergies and moderate optimism for 2019

  21. 13/12 16:04

    Crete from 6,000 BC to the Byzantine era at a fabulous exhibition in Greece

  22. 13/12 12:36

    IATA launches platform enabling carriers to share turbulence data

  23. 13/12 11:58

    Geminids meteor shower to be most visible in Greece at dawn on Friday

  24. 13/12 10:27

    Foreign investors show interest for Renewable Energy Sources in Greece

  25. 12/12 23:48

    ΙΑΤΑ: Cautious οptimism for airlines extends into 2019

  26. 12/12 23:41

    Emergency central bank funding to Greek banks drops still in November

  27. 12/12 23:36

    Daily Mail: Mykonos- London flight route most disrupted in Europe

  28. 12/12 23:24

    Tourist from India tries to steal brick from Rome’s Colosseum and escapes

  29. 12/12 23:06

    Greek queer cinema tribute starts tomorrow at the Film Archive in Athens

  30. 12/12 22:59

    Clay tablet with Homer’s verses among top-10 discoveries of 2018

  31. 12/12 22:55

    European Union approves extension of Athens airport concession

  32. 12/12 22:48

    Heavy snowfall in northern Greece by the end of the week (video)

  33. 12/12 20:36

    2019 Greek Festival of Sydney awarded $75,000 grant by Australian Ministry

  34. 12/12 20:31

    One year extension of out-of-court settlement for businesses' arrears in Greece

  35. 12/12 20:12

    Athens mayor lights Christmas tree in the heart of the city (video)

  36. 12/12 18:42

    US News: Two Greek islands among 20 most romantic global destinations

  37. 12/12 16:34

    Tourism Minister rings the NYSE closing bell on day dedicated to Greece

  38. 12/12 15:47

    Survey: American travelers desire more room for sex during their vacations

  39. 12/12 14:35

    Cyprus companies using high speed internet double during 2018

  40. 12/12 13:08

    Prospective buyer cited for Hellenic Steel in northern Greece

  41. 12/12 12:01

    The stunning Byzantine fortress town of Monemvasia in Greece

  42. 12/12 11:47

    SNF temporarily freezes submission of new grant requests for projects in Greece

  43. 12/12 10:32

    Greek-inspired architecture makes Ancient city of Petra in Jordan a top site

  44. 11/12 20:02

    Survey: Greeks rank as the 4th most religious people in Europe

  45. 11/12 19:54

    Students from Panama learn Greek language and plan to visit Greece

  46. 11/12 19:42

    First Greek lending library opens with huge success in London

  47. 11/12 19:29

    "Women in Diplomacy and Public Life" event organized in Athens

  48. 11/12 19:23

    Religious Tourism: Nativity Church renovation lifts Christmas spirit in Bethlehem

  49. 11/12 19:14

    Chinese buyers leading Greek real estate boom

  50. 11/12 19:05

    Building permits value soars due to large-scale projects in Cyprus

  51. 11/12 18:14

    Internationally famed Greek dancer at Thessaloniki’s Vassiliko Theater (video)

  52. 11/12 18:03

    Greek literary masterpiece “My Mother’s Sin” presented for first time in English

  53. 11/12 17:54

    Greek delegation pursues FDIs and planned bond buyers at Capital Link forum

  54. 11/12 15:55

    Υellow vests: Tourists cancel Paris hotel Christmas bookings due to violent protests

  55. 11/12 15:13

    Historic Tourism: Bactria, the Ancient Greek State in Afghanistan

  56. 11/12 15:04

    Greek academics call for private universities to be recognized in country

  57. 11/12 14:58

    Greek airports among Europe's top-7 in passenger traffic

  58. 11/12 14:33

    Greek farmers from Thessaly exhibit a sexy side in new calendar

  59. 11/12 13:52

    Athens University of Agriculture gives EU Commissioner honorary doctorate

  60. 11/12 13:42

    10 finalists in 1st UNWTO-Globalia Tourism Startup Competition announced

  61. 11/12 13:21

    Funding approved for four new Ionian island water airports in Greece

  62. 11/12 11:16

    Corporate bonds put on hold in Greece until market turmoil eases off

  63. 11/12 01:53

    Christmas celebrations at the National Observatory of Athens

  64. 11/12 01:47

    Anti-fascist film festival commences at Studio cinema in Athens today

  65. 10/12 23:49

    Greek trade deficit declines in October as exports continue to grow

  66. 10/12 22:36

    Greek architects present "smart" hotel room at 5th Athens International Tourism Expo

  67. 10/12 22:31

    Magical night of Broadway classics at the SNFCC in Athens

  68. 10/12 20:26

    Greek President inaugurates Athena Center for Science and Technology

  69. 10/12 18:36

    Infrastructure investment: ERGOSE's new-generation railway projects in Greece

  70. 10/12 17:26

    Winter tourism: Arachova, Greece’s top skiing destination

  71. 10/12 16:19

    Welt: One in every two new LNG ship orders by Greek companies

  72. 10/12 15:09

    EU Commission's Costello urges Greece to conclude privatizations and reforms

  73. 10/12 14:10

    Last Greeks of Alexandria strive to keep their historic community alive

  74. 10/12 13:58

    Prime Minister at NY Forum: Greece is a safe investment destination

  75. 09/12 13:35

    Unique experiences at Athens Museum of Illusions on central Ermou Street

  76. 09/12 13:32

    2018 Global Migration Film Festival in Cyprus honouring migrants

  77. 09/12 13:19

    Greek island of Kea pays tribute to American archaeologist Miriam Caskey

  78. 09/12 13:11

    Cosco eyes separating draft master plan for Piraeus port to speed up process

  79. 09/12 13:05

    Nicosia advises Cyprus citizens on 'yellow vests' riots across France

  80. 09/12 12:55

    'Right-of-use' extending into decades for illegally built structures in Greek forests

  81. 09/12 12:45

    EBRD: TAP pipeline a great opportunity to give up use of coal in Greece

  82. 09/12 12:36

    New York City taxi board sets minimum pay for app-based drivers

  83. 09/12 12:36

    Greek top-500 companies generated impressive profits in 2017

  84. 09/12 10:10

    Greek doctors and hospital staff on work stoppage between 11:00-15:00 on Monday

  85. 08/12 13:45

    Island of Corfu to host International Open Chess Festival at Easter

  86. 08/12 13:37

    Holiday season festivities guide: Celebrating Christmas in Athens

  87. 08/12 12:51

    Daily Mail dream job report: Get paid 90,000 euros to travel

  88. 08/12 12:45

    Foreign Minister Lavrov: New starting point in Greek-Russian relations

  89. 08/12 12:34

    Three Greek hotels voted best in the world at Small Luxury Hotels (SLH) competition

  90. 08/12 12:25

    Draft law on thematic tourism approved in Greek parliament

  91. 08/12 12:04

    President Putin: Record one million Russian tourists to visit Greece in 2019 (video)

  92. 08/12 11:56

    Ryanair launches new Thessaloniki – Krakow route in summer 2019

  93. 08/12 11:02

    Alitalia accepts purchase offer from Italian State Railways (FS)

  94. 08/12 10:54

    Bronze age finds from excavations at Agios Sozomenos- Ampelia and Nikolides sites

  95. 07/12 18:04

    Duke and Duchess of Cambridge visit Cyprus to spread Christmas spirit

  96. 07/12 17:57

    Construction works for Kasteli Airport in Crete to commence in January 2019

  97. 07/12 17:50

    First e-charging of commercial vessel at Greek port of Kyllini this month

  98. 07/12 17:45

    Commercial property prices grow by 3.5% in Greece during H1 of 2018

  99. 07/12 17:13

    Media report: Thousands of Turks flee Erdogan’s purge by seeking asylum in Greece

  100. 07/12 16:24

    Large-scale infrastructure projects to be delivered across Greece by 2021