Greek Ministry of Culture reiterates legal claim to artifact vs. Sotheby’s in NY

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Greek Ministry of Culture reiterates legal claim to artifact vs. Sotheby’s in NYClaim of dominion over a bronze sculpture from the 8th century BC

NEW YORK – The Ministry of Culture and Sports of the Hellenic Republic (the “Greek Ministry”) reiterates its claim of dominion over a bronze sculpture from the 8th century BC, an object the Ministry reasonably believes was illegally exported from Greek territory, according to thenationalherald.com.

The Greek Ministry was sued by the heirs of Howard and Saretta Barnet (Barnet Family), and by Sotheby’s Inc., the auction house that was preparing to auction the antiquity on the Barnet Family’s behalf. These parties sued the Greek Ministry in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York seeking to establish valid title to the sculpture.

The Greek Ministry moved to dismiss the case, but on June 21, 2019, the court denied Greece’s motion, finding that the court had subject matter jurisdiction over the case pursuant to the commercial activity exception of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (the “FSIA”). 

The Ministry has appealed this decision to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, as reported in The National Herald. In particular, the Greek State Legal Council in cooperation with the Greek Ministry assigned the case to the law firms of Amineddoleh & Associates LLC and Foley Hoag LLP.

The chronicle

The lawsuit against the Greek Ministry, according to the first publication of the case in the Financial Times, was filed in New York on June 5, 2018. The case is considered the first of its type because this is the first time an auction house has sued a foreign government for taking steps to protect its national heritage. Typically, national governments and their agencies seek to protect cultural heritage by ensuring that looted art and antiquities do not appear on the international art market.

The item in dispute, a bronze horse sculpture dating to the 8th century BC was to be auctioned by Sotheby’s in New York on May 14, 2018, along with other items from the Barnet Collection. (The sculpture was expected to realize an estimated sales price of between $ 150,000 and $ 250,000.) Regarding the provenance of the sculpture, Sotheby’s catalog noted that the work was anonymously consigned to, and then anonymously purchased through, Münzen und Medaillen AG in Basel, Switzerland on May 6, 1967. That is the first appearance of the work in modern times. Sotheby’s catalog stated that British art dealer Robin Symes (a dealer with a criminal record and extensive history of dealing with looted antiquities) “probably” acquired it in the above-mentioned auction. (After withdrawing the sculpture from auction, Sotheby’s revealed that the information provided in the catalog was not true). Howard and Saretta Barnet purchased the item from Symes on November 16, 1973 and held it until their deaths.

The Greek Ministry sent a formal letter to Sotheby’s requesting two actions be taken. First, the Greek Ministry requested the withdrawal of the bronze sculpture from the scheduled auction. This request was based on the lack of documents demonstrating legal export from Greek territory, the suspicious circumstances surrounding the object’s first appearance on the art market in Switzerland, the anonymous nature of the sale in Switzerland, Symes’ involvement, the Ministry’s knowledge that the sculpture most likely was found in an area in Greece that was heavily looted during the decade in which it appeared on the market, and the three photos of the sculpture in the group of confiscated items on the island of Schoinoussa from the 2006 Symes-Michaelides Photographic Archive. Second, the Greek Ministry requested Sotheby’s cooperation in the repatriation of the sculpture as an ancient movable monument belonging exclusively to the Greek State, in accordance with Greek archaeological legislation and international conventions.

Before communicating with Sotheby’s, the Greek Ministry, on May 4, 2018, requested Interpol to investigate all relevant documents regarding the sculpture’s acquisition, focusing on the ownership and export documents relating to its first auction in 1967. Unfortunately, the ongoing investigation is fraught with difficulties because it had been half a century since its first auction, and the Swiss auction house’s documents had been destroyed during the past six decades.

In the meantime, Sotheby’s withdrew the bronze sculpture from the auction. Sotheby’s also sent the Greek Ministry a response letter asserting that the Ministry’s communication had placed a “cloud” over the object which affected its marketability. In the same letter, Sotheby’s demanded specific information about the time and manner of the sculpture’s export. The auction house demanded this information within ten days. Obviously, this was an impossible deadline, and left insufficient time for a full investigation and official translation of the documents to be sent in support of the Greek Ministry’s position.

The Greek Ministry was informed by an article in the Financial Times on June 5, 2018 that it was being sued in the United States. The Plaintiffs asked the court to: (1) to recognize the Barnet Family (not the Greek State) as the owner of the item, to hold that no property rights for the sculpture vested in the Greek State, and to find no basis for the object’s repatriation to Greece under U.S. or international law; and (2) to allow Sotheby’s to proceed with selling the sculpture on behalf of the Barnet Family.

The Greek Ministry, in cooperation with the Legal Council of State, assigned the case to the American law firm of Amineddoleh & Associates LLC to defend the rights of the Greek Ministry based on the provisions of the archaeological law, according to which ancient movable monuments belong exclusively to the Greek State, are not privately held, and are prohibited from trade on the international art market.

The American law firm filed a Motion to Dismiss on behalf of the Greek Ministry for lack of subject matter jurisdiction under the FSIA. Sotheby’s responded to the Motion to Dismiss, arguing that the Greek Ministry’s letter was commercial activity, and thus left the Greek Ministry vulnerable to suit in the United States. By order dated June 21, 2019, the District Court denied the Greek Ministry’s Motion to Dismiss, finding that it had subject matter jurisdiction over the case pursuant to the commercial activity exception of the FSIA. 

The Greek Ministry has appealed this decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, and added Foley Hoag LLP, which has extensive experience with the FSIA, to its legal team. Unfortunately, the Greek State is forced to spend resources defending itself in a foreign court. This case stems from the Greek Ministry fulfilling its constitutional mandate to protect the nation’s heritage by diligently examining the marketplace for antiquities that were looted, or potentially looted, from within its borders. The bronze sculpture undeniably originates from Greece, and it lacks a developed provenance or documentation attesting to its lawful removal from Greece. Greek law mandates that ancient property is exclusively owned by the Greek State and its people, and prohibits the export of certain types of property from Greek territory without permission. This principle has been protected by legislation since the early years of the Hellenic Republic. The first Greek archaeological legislation was enacted in 1834, and has since been updated to sufficiently protect against looting. But rather than working with the Greek Ministry to resolve this matter through a cooperative approach, Sotheby’s and its consignor sued to haul the Greek Ministry into a foreign court.

Parties interested in the lawsuit should be aware of the differences between fine art and the cultural heritage of a country. Antiquities deemed cultural heritage in Greece are protected by the sovereign for its people, and for all of humanity. The very survival of valuable treasures dating back to antiquity relies on sovereign protection and the intervention of a functioning cultural ministry. To silence the Greek Ministry in its efforts to protect against the sale of potentially looted items is to silence and stifle the very purpose of the Greek Ministry. And most dangerous is that this case could have long-standing consequences for other cultural agencies aiming to protect human heritage. These principles should be understood by members of the public interested in respecting and protecting cultural heritage.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinationsGreek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: Wikimedia Commons License: CC-BY-SA Copyright: Antilock

Tornos
  1. 14/11 02:40

    First Greek-German Innovation Forum at SNFCC in Athens on November 18

  2. 14/11 02:35

    Greek and Saudi Arabian Foreign Ministers meet in Athens for investments

  3. 14/11 02:25

    Greek American actor John Stamos featured in ‘The Little Mermaid Live!’ (video)

  4. 14/11 02:16

    “Maria before Callas. Her childhood years” at Mikro Pallas theater in Athens

  5. 14/11 01:16

    Athens-based brand design agency wins Red Dot Award in Berlin

  6. 14/11 00:33

    Reuters: Total credit contraction recorded in Greece during September

  7. 14/11 00:27

    Ecumenical Patriarch accuses Russian Orthodox Church of playing politics

  8. 14/11 00:21

    Aegean Airlines increases flights from Cyprus to Athens and Beirut

  9. 14/11 00:06

    Greek-American actress Jennifer Aniston wins People’s Icon Award (video)

  10. 13/11 23:58

    Austrian Airlines to connect directly Vienna to Kavala and Samos in Greece

  11. 13/11 22:28

    AP: Greek government withdraws plan to criminalize blasphemy

  12. 13/11 22:15

    Victoria weather front to bring intense storms while moving eastward across Greece

  13. 13/11 22:02

    Web addresses ending in .eu must migrate to Greek extension by November 14, 2022

  14. 13/11 20:52

    Greek basketball player blasted in Turkey for not holding Kemal Ataturk banner

  15. 13/11 18:33

    Tourist show 'Greek Panorama' opens at Zappeion Hall in central Athens on Friday

  16. 13/11 16:15

    Cyprus church to return money if fugitive financier donor’s passport is revoked

  17. 13/11 14:56

    "The Trip to Greece" movie comedy set to be released in summer 2020

  18. 13/11 14:48

    Frontex records drop in migrant flows to Greek islands during October

  19. 13/11 12:41

    Second thoughts over demand that Greek taxpayers spend 30% online

  20. 13/11 10:39

    Turkish President threatens to release Jihadi prisoners after Cyprus sanctions

  21. 13/11 02:49

    “Dance with My Own Shadow” show on Manos Hadjidakis’ music (video)

  22. 13/11 02:44

    Arrivals of travelers to Cyprus rise by 1.6% during September

  23. 13/11 02:38

    International Air Transport Association: Four priorities for African aviation

  24. 13/11 02:31

    Revenue from tourism rises slightly in Cyprus during August 2019

  25. 13/11 01:48

    EU Commissioner: Greek government's recent law on migration 'in the right direction'

  26. 13/11 01:22

    Greek government: Schools returned to students, neighbourhoods to residents

  27. 13/11 01:18

    EU approves majority purchase of MediaMarkt's operations in Greece

  28. 13/11 00:50

    EU sanctions for illegal Turkish drilling in the eastern Mediterranean

  29. 13/11 00:42

    Greek saffron and kiwifruit get green light for export to Chinese market

  30. 12/11 22:02

    Jewish Museum in the northern Greek city of Thessaloniki launches new wing

  31. 12/11 22:01

    Greek fisheries show growth in exports

  32. 12/11 21:11

    FM: Economic diplomacy a core component of foreign relations in Greece

  33. 12/11 20:57

    Chinese president: I agree that the Parthenon Sculptures should return to Greece

  34. 12/11 16:38

    RINA and Athens Polytechnic agree to train graduating Greek naval engineers

  35. 12/11 16:31

    Greek PM refers to government’s initiative to reunite Elgin Marbles

  36. 12/11 14:10

    Novel about Greek poet Cavafy wins 2019 National Translation Award

  37. 12/11 12:32

    Rainstorms and strong winds in Greece on Wednesday

  38. 12/11 10:51

    Chinese interest in assisting Greek banking sector to reduce exposure to NPLs

  39. 12/11 00:21

    AP: Greek tennis star Tsitsipas earns 1st win over Medvedev at ATP Finals

  40. 12/11 00:15

    Study on direct flights between China and Cyprus to be conducted

  41. 12/11 00:04

    Central Macedonia organic foods at Eco Life Scandinavia fair

  42. 11/11 23:47

    Plans for road between Helliniko and Athens Airport through Argyroupolis tunnel

  43. 11/11 23:42

    Greece’s rival parties receive Diaspora vote bill with skepticism

  44. 11/11 23:35

    Stavros Niarchos Foundation Cultural Center: A park for all seasons

  45. 11/11 23:27

    Greek PM and Chinese President tour Cosco’s facilities in Piraeus Port

  46. 11/11 23:19

    Greece and China to sign another 16 bilateral deals to promote investment and trade

  47. 11/11 23:11

    Prime Minister: Greece will officially adopt IHRA definition of anti-semitism

  48. 11/11 23:00

    The 60th Thessaloniki Film Festival announces its awards (video)

  49. 11/11 20:49

    Pomegranate: The golden Greek elixir the world can't get enough of

  50. 11/11 20:38

    ESM chief and EBRD report: Positive prospects for the Greek economy

  51. 11/11 19:09

    Greece offering tax relief and incentives to enterprises to attract investment

  52. 11/11 18:33

    Draft law on voting rights of Greeks abroad presented for public consultation

  53. 11/11 18:00

    Xi Jinping on Greek-Chinese relations: Cooperation of two great civilisations

  54. 11/11 16:16

    Greek President Pavlopoulos: Significant upgrade of relations with China

  55. 11/11 14:44

    China to host year of culture and tourism with Greece in 2021

  56. 11/11 01:54

    Israel-Hellenic Forum organizes first meeting in Jerusalem on November 12-14

  57. 10/11 19:50

    Greek FM: Turkey’s insistence on distorting history unbecoming of a modern state

  58. 10/11 19:39

    Prime Minister notes Greece’s 200th Independence event time to reflect

  59. 10/11 19:32

    Greek police conclude search of Economic University premises in Athens

  60. 10/11 19:23

    Greek competition commission makes surprise inspection at banks' HQs

  61. 10/11 19:12

    Greek Foreign Minister: Time for the 'Nicosia Wall' to come down as well

  62. 10/11 14:44

    Prime Minister: Slowly but surely, security and order restored in Greece

  63. 10/11 14:21

    Receipts demand is not for all categories of citizens in Greece as of 2020

  64. 10/11 14:07

    Winning streak of Kenyan runners at Athens Authentic Marathon continues

  65. 10/11 12:29

    Chinese President Xi Jinping visiting Greece from November 10-12

  66. 10/11 01:40

    Presentation of the Greek Diaspora Fellowship Program in Athens

  67. 10/11 00:10

    Cosco subsidiary purchases 60% of the share capital of Greece-based Pearl

  68. 09/11 21:01

    American basketball coach Rick Pitino to coach the Greek national team

  69. 09/11 20:57

    Greek and Turkish FM meeting focuses on bilateral and regional issues

  70. 09/11 20:51

    New Greek film “Few Hours in Athens” wins prestigious Hollywood awards

  71. 09/11 20:46

    New credit upgrades show Greece is gradually closing investment-grade gap

  72. 09/11 20:38

    Trump’s tariffs aggravate Greek fruit producers

  73. 09/11 14:40

    Greek Shipping Minister meets with Cosco and Piraeus Port Authority leadership

  74. 09/11 14:14

    Greek Minister: Hollywood subsidiary to build filming studio near Thessaloniki

  75. 09/11 14:01

    Short film marks Greece’s eternal connection with olive trees

  76. 09/11 11:44

    Proastiakos suburban railway scheduled to change on Sunday and Monday

  77. 08/11 17:51

    Greek Prime Minister meets with chiefs of CDP and TERNA SpA

  78. 08/11 17:41

    Debt settlement scheme for pension funds shows impressive results in Greece

  79. 08/11 17:31

    American B-52 bomber airplane deployed in Greece for the first time

  80. 08/11 17:15

    Political debate over pork-and-booze fest plan near Greece refugee camp

  81. 08/11 16:38

    Tourism Minister: Greece has a strong tourist product that generates interest

  82. 08/11 16:07

    Greece's borrowing cost falls lower than Italy’s for first time since 2008

  83. 08/11 14:46

    Greek and Russian Foreign Ministers shake hands on renewing relations

  84. 08/11 14:39

    Cyprus signs agreement for offshore gas concession with triple consortium

  85. 08/11 14:32

    Travel through Homer’s Odyssey in northern Greek city of Thessaloniki

  86. 08/11 12:23

    Tax relief for businesses, investors and households in Greece

  87. 08/11 10:55

    Authentic Marathon and smaller races to affect traffic in Athens on Nov. 9-10

  88. 07/11 23:52

    New defense cooperation deals signed between Greece, Cyprus and Egypt

  89. 07/11 23:45

    Cypriot Finance Minister admits golden visa gaps and mistakes

  90. 07/11 23:29

    Rabih Mroué presents two dance pieces at the Onassis Stegi in Athens

  91. 07/11 23:22

    Greek telecom OTE Group reports improved results for Q3 2019

  92. 07/11 23:10

    Reuters: Presidents Trump and Xi may sign US-China trade agreement in Greece

  93. 07/11 23:09

    FM spokesperson: Greece remains a pioneer of Western Balkans' EU accession

  94. 07/11 22:44

    Turkey awaits court ruling to turn museums of Aghia Sophia into mosques

  95. 07/11 21:26

    2019 to be top wine production year in a decade for Northern Greece

  96. 07/11 21:04

    Commissioner Moscovici: Greece cannot keep achieving 3.5% surpluses forever

  97. 07/11 20:44

    New UNWTO report: Tourism leading other global sectors in promoting gender equality

  98. 07/11 20:26

    Presentations on lost ancient statue of Athena Parthenos at Acropolis Museum

  99. 07/11 18:16

    IATA: Air passenger demand continues on moderate upward path

  100. 07/11 16:45

    Education Tourism: Greek students win first prize at MIT global competition