Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!The Arab world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion

Last week, a huge scandal rocked the Tunisian and Arab scientific and educational world: a PhD student submitted a thesis declaring Earth to be flat, unmoving, young (only 13,500 years of age), and the centre of the universe.

Going even bolder and further, the student explicitly rejected the physics of Newton and Einstein, the astronomy of Copernicus and Kepler, the cosmology of the Big Bang, the main models of atmospheric and geological activity, and most of modern climatology.

The student submitted her thesis after five years of work; it was then sent to two assessors, thus passing the first stage of approvals. The reports were expected soon, for the thesis defence to be scheduled.

It was at this stage that fate luckily intervened: a copy of the thesis was “leaked” to the former president of the Tunisian Astronomical Association, who checked that it was not a hoax and then quickly rang the alarm by posting on Facebook the general conclusions of the thesis, verbatim.

Gulf News readers may recall that two years ago, I wrote a column lamenting the talk that a Saudi cleric had given in the UAE insisting that Earth does not rotate, neither around itself nor around the Sun; I described the moment as a “debacle” and tried to draw lessons from it.

This new scandal is much worse, because it does not come from a cleric (that was bad enough) but rather from a PhD student in science, her supervisor held the Professor rank (the highest in academia), and they were explicitly rejecting major parts of modern science.

They also went further than just submit a thesis, they published a paper (in an obscure and disreputable journal) presenting “physical and astronomical arguments” for geo-centrism (Earth being central and fixed in the universe).

The paper is available online, and anyone can quickly check that both the paper and the journal are worthless: countless grammatical errors, mediocre references, puny scientific arguments; the journal is classified as “fake and predatory”, one of those “pay and we’ll publish your article quickly, with no reviewing or editing”…

General conclusion

I don’t mean to belabour the point, but it is worth citing a few ideas from the general conclusion given at the end of the thesis, if at least to fully impress upon the reader the size of the calamity that has just occurred — before we analyse its causes.

The “results” of this doctoral thesis include: the Earth is flat and young, and it stands immobile at the centre of the universe, which is made of only one galaxy; the sun’s diameter is 1,135km (not 1.4 million km), the moon is 908 km wide, and they lie 687 and 23 times closer to Earth, respectively; there are 11 planets; stars are “limited” in number and have a diameter of 292 km (not millions of km).

How does one explain such stunning ignorance of basic astronomy, coupled with such brashness and insolence — rejecting Copernicus, Kepler, Newton, Einstein, Hubble, and everything in science?

In this particular case, I believe this was due to an adherence to religious, scriptural literalism, in other words taking the meanings of religious texts literally and blindly, at the cost of rejecting all knowledge that appears to contradict it, no matter how much evidence supports it.

Indeed, we find in the conclusions of the thesis clear indications of this stand and approach, expressions such as: “using physical and religious arguments”, “also proving the world scale of [Noah’s] flood”, “proposed a new kinematic approach that conforms to the verses of the Quran”, “the roles of the stars are: (1) to be ornaments of the sky; (2) to stone the devils; and (3) as signs to guide creatures in the darkness of earth”; and finally “the geo-centric model… accords with the verses of the Quran and the pronouncements of our Prophet.”

Comeback

Flat-Earthism has lately been making a comeback and spreading like bush fire through social media.

Search for “flat earth” on YouTube and you’ll find almost a million videos; “flat earth society” gets 400,000 pages on the web; “flat earth proof” gets you 200,000 pages; etc.

But this social media trend I attribute to people’s inclination toward conspiracy theories: “Nasa has faked the moon-landing”; “Nasa photoshops space images”; “Give us real proofs that these interplanetary spacecraft are factual”; etc.

In 2001, when the internet was still young, and the “moon-landing hoax” was just emerging as a trending meme (without social media to support its spread), I gave several talks titled “Did Nasa fake the moon landing… or are we miserably failing to educate the public?”

But the latest shocking event (the PhD thesis) implies that we are not only failing to educate the public (that is manifest in the trendy “flat earth” and “Nasa lies” memes on social media) but also our brightest students.

It has been reported that the PhD student had previously graduated at the top of her class.

What we are failing to clarify and communicate is how to distinguish between scientific knowledge (facts, models, theories, etc.) and religious knowledge (what verses mean and what they intend to teach us).

I believe the Arab-Muslim world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises, not to mention a total lack of understanding of science, until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion, without diminishing the value of each.

Source: gulfnews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 23/04 23:49

    Sailboat full of migrants intercepted off western Greece

  2. 23/04 23:47

    Greek banks aspire to begin online asset auctions within June

  3. 23/04 23:45

    Olympiakos football champions of Greece for 7th time in a row

  4. 23/04 23:40

    Culture Minister: Greece’s contribution to civilization is introducing dialog as a foundation of democracy

  5. 23/04 23:38

    New self-employed professionals fund in Greece debuts with €201 million deficit

  6. 23/04 23:36

    Revenues from properties in steady nosedive in Greece

  7. 23/04 23:35

    IMF Communications Director Rice denies reports on split approach to Greek issue

  8. 23/04 23:27

    Amazing blind pianist cries in concert for Japan’s tsunami victims (video)

  9. 23/04 23:22

    U.S. ambassador: Greece is key NATO ally in a strategically crucial region

  10. 23/04 23:11

    Barca legend Puyol meets refugees in Greece ahead of El Clasico derby

  11. 23/04 23:09

    Greek and Iranian FMs discuss bilateral cooperation and regional developments

  12. 23/04 21:19

    Greece's creditors to meet May 22 date for concluding second review

  13. 23/04 21:17

    Use and production of medical cannabis may be legalized in Greece

  14. 23/04 21:04

    French elections poll: Macron and LePen to face off in second round

  15. 23/04 19:16

    French Elections live streaming: First round too close to call (video)

  16. 23/04 17:13

    Kyriakos Mitsotakis: Macron’s win is a response to left and right-wing populism

  17. 23/04 13:06

    Institutions due to return in Greece for conclusion of review

  18. 23/04 11:01

    Greece and China aim for closer cooperation through Ancient Civilizations Forum

  19. 22/04 23:30

    Maryland Film Festival first look at Stavros Niarchos Foundation Parkway

  20. 22/04 23:27

    France’s overseas territories kick off critical presidential vote

  21. 22/04 23:24

    Greek Tourism Minister and US Ambassador discuss policies to attract American tourists and investment

  22. 22/04 23:18

    Turkey continues actions in Cyprus' Economic Exclusive Zone with new NAVTEX

  23. 22/04 23:16

    2016 marks best primary budget surplus in Greek State since 1995

  24. 22/04 23:13

    Ex-chiefs of Athens 984 municipal radio to stand trial for financial mismanagement

  25. 22/04 23:07

    Real vs. Barcelona and Ronaldo vs. Messi in “El Clasico” football derby (video)

  26. 22/04 23:02

    Cypriots in UK could see no status change in Brexit arrangements

  27. 22/04 22:59

    Basque NGO to leave Chios island after municipality opposes plan for refugee clinic

  28. 22/04 22:44

    Cyprus president: Good climate in talks "not enough"

  29. 22/04 22:39

    Greek police await forensic and CCTV data in terror probe

  30. 22/04 22:32

    At least 19 children killed by South Africa bus crash

  31. 22/04 22:29

    Higher taxes and pensions prevent improvement in Greek job market

  32. 22/04 22:26

    Russian Foreign Minister discusses Syria chemical attacks with US Secretary of State

  33. 22/04 22:19

    23 countries to be represented by 180 athletes at the Rhodes’ UCI Gran Fondo

  34. 22/04 21:20

    North Aegean Region launches new tourism campaign in Lesvos island

  35. 22/04 21:17

    Greek President: Europe is in danger of being cut off from its roots

  36. 22/04 20:14

    Comet hit earth in southern Turkey 13,000 years ago according to ancient carvings

  37. 22/04 19:11

    The National Symphony Orchestra at the Piraeus Municipal Theater on Monday

  38. 22/04 17:04

    Venezuela: 12 killed in riots while opposition calls for more protests

  39. 22/04 15:57

    Greek opposition leader Mitsotakis: Tsipras offering “stale Chavez” policies

  40. 22/04 14:52

    Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew to give open lecture in Geneva on April 24

  41. 22/04 13:49

    Greek champion Petrounias wins gold in European Gymnastics Championships (video)

  42. 22/04 11:17

    Greek privatization fund searches for financial advisors to sell 30% stake in Athens Airport

  43. 22/04 00:20

    IMF admits to misjudging economic performance in Greece

  44. 22/04 00:18

    Greek opposition leader to visit cities of Naousa and Veria on Sunday

  45. 22/04 00:13

    Research: Skinny people more prone to depression

  46. 22/04 00:05

    Drop in travel receipts and visitor numbers to Greece in January-February

  47. 22/04 00:02

    New guide book on the fascinating art and history of Athens’s First Cemetery

  48. 21/04 23:59

    Greek wineries travel to London on April 25 for wine tasting event

  49. 21/04 23:55

    Athens eyes fresh rise in visitor numbers this season

  50. 21/04 23:53

    Ruussia: St. Petersburg metro bomber funded by “international terrorists” in Turkey

  51. 21/04 23:51

    Canadian travel site: Three Greek destinations among best economical honeymoon list

  52. 21/04 23:46

    Greek government condemns latest terror attack in Paris

  53. 21/04 23:43

    Turkey to engage in new diplomatic approach by May

  54. 21/04 23:38

    Greek meteorological service EMY forecasts bad weather for Saturday

  55. 21/04 23:22

    Popular Greek actor Stathis Psaltis dies at 66 after long battle with cancer

  56. 21/04 21:40

    Three companies submit improved bids for Thessaloniki Port stake in Greece

  57. 21/04 19:36

    IMF's Thomsen: Greece, institutions are close to a staff-level agreement

  58. 21/04 17:30

    Bloomberg: Turkey’s urbanites resist giving Erdogan more power (infographics)

  59. 21/04 15:27

    Greek FM: Aim of Ancient Civilizations Forum to turn it into institution

  60. 21/04 13:20

    Greek Finance Minister: Meeting with Lagarde went very well

  61. 21/04 11:17

    Time: Crete island in Greece among top 10 economical destination for Americans in Europe

  62. 21/04 00:41

    FM: Cyprus reserves the right to respond to Turkish NAVTEX

  63. 21/04 00:38

    Concern in Athens over IMF forecasts: 'Fiscal gap' specter emerges again

  64. 21/04 00:36

    Incredible 10-year-old drummer wins in “Denmark’s Got Talent” (video)

  65. 21/04 00:33

    Greek Enterprises Federation: Economic recovery could lead to rise in wages

  66. 21/04 00:30

    ESM head: Greece may return to the markets before end of bailout program

  67. 21/04 00:27

    Inside a 17.5 million dollar private nuclear bunker in the US

  68. 21/04 00:25

    Ongoing investigations after bomb explosion in central Athens

  69. 21/04 00:23

    Ancient Greek Amphora discovered in private home on island of Kalymnos

  70. 21/04 00:22

    World Bank President Kim: 'No immiment' plans for loan to Greece

  71. 21/04 00:19

    Report: Facebook wants to read your mind

  72. 21/04 00:17

    Greek industrial turnover index up by 20.9% during February

  73. 21/04 00:15

    PM Theresa May to block free movement of EU citizens to UK

  74. 21/04 00:13

    NGOs financing to be discussed in Greek Parliament over the next days

  75. 21/04 00:09

    Cosco Shipping to cooperate with Skyserv SA in Greece

  76. 21/04 00:05

    Hot Greek actress Athina Oikonomakou posts clip of Maldives trip (video)

  77. 21/04 00:01

    Niarchos Foundation donates 143 ambulances to the Greek State

  78. 20/04 23:57

    Eurogroup chief: 1.9 billion from tax free threshold in 2019 if targets not met

  79. 20/04 23:52

    Felony charges against former central banker and Piraeus Bank head in Greece

  80. 20/04 23:46

    Turkish President Erdogan: Barack Obama deceived us over PKK

  81. 20/04 23:40

    China offers military contracts worth billions of yuan to private companies

  82. 20/04 23:37

    Eurobank launches tax-free calucation services to customers in Greece

  83. 20/04 23:32

    Rex Tillerson declares end to ‘strategic patience’ with Iran

  84. 20/04 22:25

    Jews of Greece event in New York highlights historic presence (video)

  85. 20/04 20:21

    Scientists discover alien planet as best candidate for life as we know it

  86. 20/04 17:18

    Greek-Russian and American astronauts at International Space Station (video)

  87. 20/04 16:03

    Disney to launch a ‘Star Wars’ starship luxury resort

  88. 20/04 15:01

    ‘Safe-deposit box gang’ blamed for Avlona warehouse robbery in Attica

  89. 20/04 13:58

    Russian ship sinks Turkish Coast Guard vessel in Bosporus by accident (video)

  90. 20/04 12:56

    Mykonos island in Greece: A top vacation choice

  91. 20/04 11:54

    Erdogan to meet President Trump on NATO May Summit for first time

  92. 20/04 10:29

    Athens among top-50 tourist destinations for milennials in the world

  93. 20/04 02:36

    Emirates trims US flights after Trump government curbs

  94. 20/04 02:33

    Actress Tina Fey on Andrea Martin as Greek heritage meets Armenian

  95. 20/04 02:30

    High occupancy rates in Zagori, Epirus in Greece over Easter Period

  96. 20/04 02:26

    Inflation drops in 17 EU member-states to 1.5% average - Greece at 1.7%

  97. 20/04 02:24

    Aegean and Olympic Air record 5% increase in passenger traffic in Q1 of 2017

  98. 20/04 02:22

    Brazilian therapist uses snake massage to “help” clients cure depression (video)

  99. 20/04 02:20

    Greek court to re-examine Turkey's new extradition request for 8 officers

  100. 20/04 02:17

    Surveys: How do the refugees see Athens and how do Athenians see the refugees