Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Arab student scientific PhD thesis: The earth is flat!The Arab world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion

Last week, a huge scandal rocked the Tunisian and Arab scientific and educational world: a PhD student submitted a thesis declaring Earth to be flat, unmoving, young (only 13,500 years of age), and the centre of the universe.

Going even bolder and further, the student explicitly rejected the physics of Newton and Einstein, the astronomy of Copernicus and Kepler, the cosmology of the Big Bang, the main models of atmospheric and geological activity, and most of modern climatology.

The student submitted her thesis after five years of work; it was then sent to two assessors, thus passing the first stage of approvals. The reports were expected soon, for the thesis defence to be scheduled.

It was at this stage that fate luckily intervened: a copy of the thesis was “leaked” to the former president of the Tunisian Astronomical Association, who checked that it was not a hoax and then quickly rang the alarm by posting on Facebook the general conclusions of the thesis, verbatim.

Gulf News readers may recall that two years ago, I wrote a column lamenting the talk that a Saudi cleric had given in the UAE insisting that Earth does not rotate, neither around itself nor around the Sun; I described the moment as a “debacle” and tried to draw lessons from it.

This new scandal is much worse, because it does not come from a cleric (that was bad enough) but rather from a PhD student in science, her supervisor held the Professor rank (the highest in academia), and they were explicitly rejecting major parts of modern science.

They also went further than just submit a thesis, they published a paper (in an obscure and disreputable journal) presenting “physical and astronomical arguments” for geo-centrism (Earth being central and fixed in the universe).

The paper is available online, and anyone can quickly check that both the paper and the journal are worthless: countless grammatical errors, mediocre references, puny scientific arguments; the journal is classified as “fake and predatory”, one of those “pay and we’ll publish your article quickly, with no reviewing or editing”…

General conclusion

I don’t mean to belabour the point, but it is worth citing a few ideas from the general conclusion given at the end of the thesis, if at least to fully impress upon the reader the size of the calamity that has just occurred — before we analyse its causes.

The “results” of this doctoral thesis include: the Earth is flat and young, and it stands immobile at the centre of the universe, which is made of only one galaxy; the sun’s diameter is 1,135km (not 1.4 million km), the moon is 908 km wide, and they lie 687 and 23 times closer to Earth, respectively; there are 11 planets; stars are “limited” in number and have a diameter of 292 km (not millions of km).

How does one explain such stunning ignorance of basic astronomy, coupled with such brashness and insolence — rejecting Copernicus, Kepler, Newton, Einstein, Hubble, and everything in science?

In this particular case, I believe this was due to an adherence to religious, scriptural literalism, in other words taking the meanings of religious texts literally and blindly, at the cost of rejecting all knowledge that appears to contradict it, no matter how much evidence supports it.

Indeed, we find in the conclusions of the thesis clear indications of this stand and approach, expressions such as: “using physical and religious arguments”, “also proving the world scale of [Noah’s] flood”, “proposed a new kinematic approach that conforms to the verses of the Quran”, “the roles of the stars are: (1) to be ornaments of the sky; (2) to stone the devils; and (3) as signs to guide creatures in the darkness of earth”; and finally “the geo-centric model… accords with the verses of the Quran and the pronouncements of our Prophet.”

Comeback

Flat-Earthism has lately been making a comeback and spreading like bush fire through social media.

Search for “flat earth” on YouTube and you’ll find almost a million videos; “flat earth society” gets 400,000 pages on the web; “flat earth proof” gets you 200,000 pages; etc.

But this social media trend I attribute to people’s inclination toward conspiracy theories: “Nasa has faked the moon-landing”; “Nasa photoshops space images”; “Give us real proofs that these interplanetary spacecraft are factual”; etc.

In 2001, when the internet was still young, and the “moon-landing hoax” was just emerging as a trending meme (without social media to support its spread), I gave several talks titled “Did Nasa fake the moon landing… or are we miserably failing to educate the public?”

But the latest shocking event (the PhD thesis) implies that we are not only failing to educate the public (that is manifest in the trendy “flat earth” and “Nasa lies” memes on social media) but also our brightest students.

It has been reported that the PhD student had previously graduated at the top of her class.

What we are failing to clarify and communicate is how to distinguish between scientific knowledge (facts, models, theories, etc.) and religious knowledge (what verses mean and what they intend to teach us).

I believe the Arab-Muslim world will continue to suffer educational and cultural crises, not to mention a total lack of understanding of science, until it properly digests the different methodologies of science and religion, without diminishing the value of each.

Source: gulfnews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 23/11 02:01

    Dutch Spar to return to Greek super market sector after deal with Asteras

  2. 23/11 01:53

    German police: Flights from Greece scrutinized like arrivals from Turkey and Egypt

  3. 23/11 01:44

    8 Greek airspace violations by 4 Turkish jets intercepted by Hellenic Air Force

  4. 23/11 01:37

    88,7% of exporters face problems at Thessaloniki port from night shift cancellation

  5. 23/11 01:32

    Greek PM’s request to postpone Saudi defense deal discussion causes furor

  6. 23/11 01:11

    Ancient Macedonian Kasta Tomb in Greece's Amphipolis set to open to public after excavation

  7. 23/11 01:00

    Average spending per tourist on Greek holiday in 2017 confined to 536.3€

  8. 23/11 00:56

    Thomas Cook: Bookings for summer holidays in Greece up

  9. 23/11 00:46

    Report: The new reality in the international tourist industry is... virtual

  10. 23/11 00:39

    Bollywood takes Greek island of Naxos by storm and goes viral

  11. 23/11 00:24

    19-year-old Greek model arrested in Hong Kong with cocaine worth $300K (video)

  12. 23/11 00:18

    “Van Gogh Alive” multimedia exhibition at Music Megaron in Athens

  13. 23/11 00:11

    Italy to take part in Cyprus-Greece-Egypt 2018 summit on Crete island

  14. 23/11 00:03

    Canadian kayaks solo from Norway to Greece in paddle for peace (video)

  15. 22/11 23:57

    Roman Emperor Hadrian and drowned Greek lover Antinous revisit Athens

  16. 22/11 23:49

    Iconic Greek Orthodox Church in Istanbul opens after three years of restorations

  17. 22/11 23:44

    European Union funds Greece for border control operations

  18. 22/11 23:43

    24-hour strike on Chios and Samos islands to protest planned VAT hike

  19. 22/11 23:22

    Europarliament committee to discuss Greek floods and EU aid on Thursday

  20. 22/11 23:16

    Greek-American family offers turkey dinners to 14,000 people

  21. 22/11 22:49

    Report: World’s best hotel bar located in Greece

  22. 22/11 22:43

    US embassy closed on Thursday for Thanksgiving celebration

  23. 22/11 22:35

    Matinee and midnight screenings at historic Astor movie theater in Athens

  24. 22/11 22:19

    Report: 6 reasons to stay in luxury homes in Greece

  25. 22/11 22:06

    Hellenic Management Association presents 2017 Marketing Excellence Awards

  26. 22/11 20:15

    Bank of Cyprus staff protest against debt collection outsourcing

  27. 22/11 14:56

    Greek Feta cheese exporters to gain from EU-Canada trade agreement

  28. 22/11 14:28

    Hozoviotissa: One of oldest and most important monasteries in the Aegean

  29. 22/11 12:47

    ECB head says overall situation in Greece has significantly improved

  30. 22/11 10:19

    Alpha Bank organises Fintech Challenge ’17 on November 24-26

  31. 21/11 19:53

    Latest trend: Hollywood hotel to sell cannabis in lobby

  32. 21/11 19:46

    Booking.com: #BookingHero global social media competition with €25,000 prize

  33. 21/11 19:34

    Greek Australian doctors unite to promote better health for the community

  34. 21/11 19:29

    European Investment Bank approves €48 million for Greek gas network

  35. 21/11 19:22

    A bread recipe to bake with the Ancient Greek Zea grain

  36. 21/11 19:14

    Athens lost to Amsterdam for relocation of European Medicines Agency (EMA)

  37. 21/11 19:06

    20 Greek and Cypriot companies in Spielwarenmesse toy fair

  38. 21/11 18:56

    Albanian PM: We have spoiled Greece and will no longer be silent (video)

  39. 21/11 18:41

    Athens’ iconic King George Hotel bought by Greek company Lampsa

  40. 21/11 18:31

    First snow of the season falls on Parnitha Mountain near Athens

  41. 21/11 18:25

    Two more hot springs recognized as thermal spas in mainland Greece

  42. 21/11 18:18

    Top-5 cocktails of the year with Greek flavors

  43. 21/11 18:01

    EU: Stringent checking of Greek travelers in German airports to be discussed

  44. 21/11 17:54

    Hellenic News of America celebrates its 30th anniversary

  45. 21/11 17:37

    New poll shows battered SYRIZA trailing New Democracy by 12%

  46. 21/11 17:30

    Greek VP: Tourism can play a major role in the reconstruction of the economy

  47. 21/11 17:30

    Greek VP: Tourism can play a major role in the reconstruction of the economy

  48. 21/11 17:18

    Cyprus 2017 Tourism smashes records and pushes recovery

  49. 21/11 17:10

    Morgan Stanley: Growth of Airbnb slowing in U.S and Europe

  50. 21/11 16:26

    Christmas shows for the whole family at the Greek National Opera in Athens

  51. 21/11 14:21

    Twenty six antiquities to be repatriated from Austria to Greece

  52. 21/11 12:06

    Minister: Tourism policy has been extremely successful in Greece

  53. 21/11 10:47

    Leaders of Cyprus, Egypt, Greece pledge closer cooperation after Summit

  54. 21/11 02:14

    Russian Circus on Ice in Athens between December 15-23

  55. 21/11 02:06

    FVW workshop: Greece faces uphill race to extend tourist season

  56. 21/11 02:01

    Mitsis Norida Beach the most popular Greek hotel in Germany in November

  57. 21/11 01:46

    SunExpress: New Leipzig-Heraklion connection in 2018

  58. 21/11 01:36

    + 17% traffic to Greek museums and sites during July 2017

  59. 21/11 01:31

    Ryanair launched new Thessaloniki to Nuremberg route

  60. 21/11 01:23

    Germania Flug: New connections to Corfu, Samos and Zakynthos in 2018

  61. 21/11 01:13

    Three Greek hotels win European Hospitality Awards

  62. 21/11 01:07

    Most Germans will travel to Mallorca, New York and London for New Year's Eve

  63. 21/11 01:03

    SAS: New flights to Athens and Chania in 2018

  64. 21/11 00:55

    TUI Airlines: New connections to Greece from Belgium in 2018

  65. 21/11 00:39

    Greek current account balance in surplus between January-September

  66. 21/11 00:10

    Report: Four in 10 children in Greece at risk of poverty

  67. 21/11 00:02

    Six refugees on Chios island arrested for breaking into greenhouse

  68. 20/11 23:58

    US consulate in Zurich evacuated due to suspect "anti-American" package

  69. 20/11 23:52

    EU Greece to recover €55 million from Hellenic Defence Systems

  70. 20/11 23:49

    International health-oriented and medical tourism survey: What do customers want

  71. 20/11 23:35

    The magic of Meteora, Agrafa, Lake Plastira, Elati and Pertouli

  72. 20/11 23:29

    Moody's: Greek bond swap plan credit positive

  73. 20/11 22:48

    Marketing Greece: Impressive international tributes in the Publicity Report for October 2017

  74. 20/11 21:47

    Greek police presence in flood-hit areas strengthened against looting

  75. 20/11 21:43

    New electronic fare system put to test in four Athens Metro stations

  76. 20/11 21:35

    Fofi Gennimata is the leader of the new center-left party in Greece

  77. 20/11 21:16

    100% Hotel Show concludes with Hotel Design Awards, VIP guests and a surprise entrance (videos)

  78. 20/11 21:05

    Greece’s Motor Oil signs supply agreement with Russia’s Rosneft

  79. 20/11 20:54

    Greek banks eye auctions of up to 10,000 foreclosed properties by end of year

  80. 20/11 20:48

    Record September for Greek tourism with double-digit increase in arrivals

  81. 20/11 20:39

    Greek government announces relief measures for flood victims

  82. 20/11 19:41

    EU: Schengen border code for entrance-exit system to be amended

  83. 20/11 19:26

    New hotels improving Omonia and Metaxourgio axis in central Athens

  84. 20/11 18:54

    Greek merchant shipping grows ships and capacity in September

  85. 20/11 18:52

    Health Tourism in Greece conference to be held in Melbourne

  86. 20/11 18:17

    American meteorologist explains flash storm that flooded Greek towns

  87. 20/11 17:55

    Discovery of new bodies raises death toll from west Attica flash floods

  88. 20/11 17:43

    Guide maps of the most dangerous countries in the world for tourists

  89. 20/11 17:33

    Report: Skopje to get rid of unhistorical kitsch landmarks

  90. 20/11 17:25

    Greek Parliament approves its 2018 budget with 0.75% rise in expenditures

  91. 20/11 16:26

    Visit Kastoria city lake in Greece: The lady of Macedonia

  92. 20/11 16:09

    Anti-Trump “liberal activism” hotel to open in Washington D.C

  93. 20/11 16:02

    Lesvos island holds strike on Monday to protest overcrowding of refugees

  94. 20/11 15:23

    Woman injured in Exarchia rioting in 'stable but still serious condition'

  95. 20/11 13:19

    Greek privatization fund issues two new tenders for state-owned marinas in Alimos and Chios

  96. 20/11 11:08

    Registered unemployment up 3.07% in Greece during October

  97. 20/11 01:54

    Ryanair launches massive sale for Black Friday 2017 flight offers

  98. 20/11 00:21

    SingularityU Athens Chapter launch event at Benaki Museum on Monday

  99. 19/11 17:12

    Oxford South East European Studies project mapping the Greek diaspora

  100. 18/11 15:02

    Greek anarchist group storms into National Defense ministry (video)