Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the Americas

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the AmericasThe fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers

Among the many theories about which civilization first sailed to the Americas and discovered them, there is also the theory that the ancient Phoenicians were the first.

This theory became popular in the 18th century and is closely connected with the petroglyphs on Dighton Rock which are still of unknown origin. This theory is not quite as popular as the one that says that the Norse made the discovery first, but still, it is worth mentioning.

Back in the 18th century, a lot of scholars started to offer ideas about the true origin of the inscriptions on the rock. Ezra Stiles, a theologian, author, and also the seventh President of Yale College, claimed that the inscriptions are in Hebrew. Antoine Court de Gébelin, who is mainly known for the popularization of the Tarot, had his own idea about the rock. He believed that the inscription was made by Carthaginian sailors who commemorated their journey to the shores of Massachusetts.

In the 19th century, the theory that a group of Israelite people visited the New World was widely adopted in the Mormon community.

Later, Ross T. Christensen, an American archeologist, speculated that the Mulekites, who are mentioned in the Book of Mormon, were probably of Phoenician ethnic origin.

Stone tablet with inscription

The Phoenician theory is also supported in a book written in 1871, by John Denison Baldwin, an American anthropologist. In Ancient America, Baldwin wrote,

“The known enterprise of the Phoenician race, and this ancient knowledge of America, so variously expressed, strongly encourage the hypothesis that the people called Phoenicians came to this continent, established colonies in the region where ruined cities are found, and filled it with civilized life. It is argued that they made voyages on the ‘great exterior ocean,’ and that such navigators must have crossed the Atlantic; and it is added that symbolic devices similar to those of the Phoenicians are found in the American ruins, and that an old tradition of the native Mexicans and Central Americans described the first civilizers as ‘bearded white men,’ who ‘came from the East in ships’.”

A stone tablet with an inscription that was supposed to be of Phoenician origin appeared in Brazil in the 1870s. The tablet was given to Ladislau de Souza Mello Netto, who was the director of the National Museum of Brazil at that time, and he immediately acknowledged the artifact as genuine. The inscription allegedly told the story of some Sidonian Canaanites who visited the shore of Brazil. It was later discovered that the symbols that appear on the tablet were variations of letters that appeared in different periods over a span of 800 years. It was impossible for all the letters to appear on the same tablet at the same time, so the artifact and the inscription were dismissed as fake.

In the 20th century, a few new artifacts appeared that again spiked the theory of Phoenician or Semitic discovery. One of these artifacts was the Bat Creek inscription. Cyrus Herzl Gordon, Near Eastern cultures and ancient languages expert, believed that the inscription of this tablet was in Paleo-Hebrew. Gordon thought that this was proof that Semitic people visited the continent prior to Columbus. Later, the Bat Creek inscription, together with another artifact called the Las Lunas Decalogue Stone, were proven to be forgeries and Gordon’s claim was dismissed.

Phoenician sailors visited the Americas 

In 1996, Mark McMenamin, an American paleontologist, speculated that Phoenician sailors visited the Americas around 350 BC. He based his theory on some gold stater coins that were allegedly made by the state of Carthage. On the back of the coins was a map of the Mediterranean and another land on the west, across the Atlantic. McMenamin interpreted that land as the Americas but later discovered that those coins were actually a modern forgery.

Another form of written evidence that slightly goes in favor of the arrival of Phoenicians in the Americas can be found in Ptolemy’s Geography. Lucio Russo, an Italian physicist, mathematician, and historian of science, analyzed Ptolemy’s book and noticed that he gives the coordinates of the Fortunate Isles.

The fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers. Russo also noticed that the size of the world in Ptolemy’s Geography is smaller than what Eratosthenes measured. After he gave the same coordinates of the Fortunate Islands to the Antilles, the map irregularities in Ptolemy’s descriptions disappeared. According to Russo, Ptolemy could have known about the Antilles from his source, Hipparcos, who lived in Rhodes. It is possible that Hipparcos heard about the Antilles from Phoenicians sailors who controlled the western Mediterranean in those days. This is a far-fetched idea, but still, an interesting one.

Modern-day scholars

Most of the modern-day scholars deny the idea that Phoenicians, Canaanites, or Carthaginians discovered the Americas first.

Ronald H. Fritze, an American historian, says that although it was technically possible for those people to reach the Americas, it probably never happened:

“No archaeological evidence has yet been discovered to prove the contentions of Irwin, Gordon, Bailey, Fell and others. Since even the fleeting Norse presence in Vinland left definite archaeological remains at L’Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland, it seems logical that the allegedly more extensive Phoenician and Carthaginian presence would have left similar evidence. The absence of such remains is strong circumstantial evidence that the Phoenicians and Carthaginians never reached the Americas.”

Until some concrete evidence appears, this theory will remain only a fantasy.

Source:thevintagenews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

 

Tornos
  1. 24/10 00:34

    Tourism: Mediterranean top destination in the world with 420 million visitors by 2020

  2. 24/10 00:20

    Melina Mercouri celebrated in theater at Hellenic Cultural Center of Astoria

  3. 24/10 00:14

    Greek Economy Minister: Investors trust our development plan

  4. 24/10 00:12

    Report: Greece losing businesses to Bulgaria and freelancers to Cyprus

  5. 24/10 00:09

    Greek Foreign Minister to visit Ankara on Tuesday

  6. 24/10 00:05

    Changing tune, Schaeuble now sees Greece’s market return

  7. 23/10 23:54

    Greece's Green Cola implements ambitious expansion strategy

  8. 23/10 23:50

    US Treasury Secretary Munchin to push debt relief for Greece

  9. 23/10 23:46

    Greek Shipping Minister orders the recovery of Sea Diamond’ in Santorini

  10. 23/10 23:40

    Piraeus Bank to hold online auction for properties in Greece

  11. 23/10 21:04

    Grecotel Group farm company exports to the United States market

  12. 23/10 20:51

    Zorba’s Oscar-winning cinematographer Walter Lassally dies on Greek island of Crete

  13. 23/10 18:55

    Opposition leader resubmits proposed legislation for Greek expatriates' vote

  14. 23/10 18:45

    Greek tourism revenues increase during August 2017

  15. 23/10 18:20

    Website: Interest in Greek real estate by foreign investors steadily rising

  16. 23/10 17:01

    Athens Benaki Toy Museum opens its doors to the public (video)

  17. 23/10 16:39

    Weather report: Heavy rain, hail and thunderstorms in Greece after Monday

  18. 23/10 16:35

    Greek - South Korean business forum to be held on Monday

  19. 23/10 16:24

    Greek PM receives S. Korean counterpart for wide-ranging talks

  20. 23/10 16:21

    French-Greek innovation network's Mazinnov forum to be held next month in Athens

  21. 23/10 14:26

    Extension of one-day Greek visas into 2018 dominates meeting at foreign ministry

  22. 23/10 12:28

    Brussels Airways flights to Kalamata to commence in April 2018

  23. 23/10 10:16

    TUI's Ellerbeck sees new momentum in Greece and announces investment plans

  24. 22/10 21:53

    Australian Embassy in Greece supports women’s rugby in Athens

  25. 22/10 21:50

    South Korean PM to address Athens business forum on Monday

  26. 22/10 21:42

    Greek cultural center to open in Gelendzhik of Russia's Krasnodar

  27. 22/10 21:31

    First crematorium in Greece set to be built in the inner city of Athens

  28. 22/10 20:59

    Report: Australia’s Hellenic Initiative Campaign raises more than $1.1 million

  29. 22/10 20:55

    Pyatt: US-Greece bilateral relationship based on deep and mutual appreciation

  30. 22/10 20:37

    Alpha Bank announces securitization of shipping loans in Greece

  31. 22/10 18:23

    Revealing the great Greek Sicilian city of Ortygia

  32. 22/10 16:51

    Greek tradition and western influence come to a harmonious marriage in Syros

  33. 22/10 14:23

    Greek Minister: Tourism is a government priority

  34. 22/10 12:13

    The ultimate collection of funny Greek expressions in English

  35. 22/10 10:08

    Registered unemployment down 3.33% in Greece in September

  36. 21/10 22:00

    Greek tourism: 89% of H1 2017 travel receipts from five regions

  37. 21/10 21:56

    Chinese investor buys 100 apartments in Athens’s Exarchia district

  38. 21/10 21:51

    Traffic restrictions in downtown Athens on Sunday for 31st Athens Run

  39. 21/10 21:39

    A Greek-American among Forbes’ 100 Greatest Living Business Minds (video)

  40. 21/10 21:00

    Oxi Day exhibition opens at the Greek Consulate in New York

  41. 21/10 20:45

    Ancient Greek theater of Thouria uncovered in 'excellent condition'

  42. 21/10 16:10

    WTTC calls on tourism sector to embrace sustainability reporting

  43. 21/10 14:05

    Theresa May: Britain wants the Greeks now living there to stay

  44. 21/10 10:54

    Greek and Bulgarian PMs present deal for Sea To Sea rail link to Juncker

  45. 20/10 21:48

    Greek main opposition head Mitsotakis visits eHealth Forum 2017

  46. 20/10 18:32

    Orionid meteor shower will reach its peak in Greece on Friday night

  47. 20/10 16:09

    Religious tourism: Òssios Loukás best preserved monastery in Greece

  48. 20/10 16:06

    Opposition head discusses needed reforms in Greece with European Commissioners

  49. 20/10 15:59

    Greek Reporter: Guide on the wines of Crete

  50. 20/10 15:56

    Cosmote rapidly expands its fibre optics network across Greece

  51. 20/10 15:45

    Presentation of Attica as tourist destination for the Scandinavian market

  52. 20/10 14:28

    Sundair charter flights from Germany to Halkidiki

  53. 20/10 13:55

    50,000 winter tourists in Crete

  54. 20/10 13:43

    8-year-old’s message in bottle out to sea discovered 29 years later

  55. 20/10 13:34

    Trapped wildcat released back into the wild on Crete island

  56. 20/10 13:19

    Greek President Pavlopoulos visits island of Samothrace

  57. 20/10 11:23

    Travel report: Best traditional destinations in Chania of Crete

  58. 19/10 18:09

    Prime Minister thanks Greek-American community for its warm welcome

  59. 19/10 18:02

    Two Greek researchers earn L'Oreal-Unesco 'Women in Science' Scholarships

  60. 19/10 17:48

    First Cyprus, Greece and Armenia meeting on diaspora issues on Friday in Nicosia

  61. 19/10 17:44

    Air Berlin pilots suspended after “dignified goodbye” with fly-by (video)

  62. 19/10 17:39

    European Union: Directives don’t apply to Parthenon Marbles return after Brexit

  63. 19/10 17:35

    Grivalia completed acquisition of 48.500 m2 portfolio of 16 assets

  64. 19/10 17:31

    Two beaches in Piraiki coast delivered to the public after cleaning

  65. 19/10 17:24

    Olympic Brewery continues investment program in Greece

  66. 19/10 17:13

    Ancient Greek grains pave way for nutritious and healthy modern lifestyle

  67. 19/10 16:29

    Mediterranean Resort & Hotel Real Estate Forum 2018 to be hosted by Athens

  68. 19/10 16:19

    Visit Greece: The small gems of Argosaronic Gulf islands

  69. 19/10 15:40

    Santorini island excavation unearths Bronze Age settlement

  70. 19/10 15:34

    HELINA: 'Guardian' article on Epidaurus failed to cross-check the science

  71. 19/10 15:02

    Hellenic American Union's conference on 'The Quest for Reforms' in Greece

  72. 19/10 14:57

    Survey: 4 out of 10 Greeks spend 40% of income on housing

  73. 19/10 14:54

    ELSTAT: 1.4% rise in Greek merchant fleet for August

  74. 19/10 14:48

    Greek language taught in Australian preschools

  75. 19/10 14:43

    Intelen CEO: First Greek 'smart' battery for homes ready to hit the stores

  76. 19/10 13:37

    Athens University opens the doors to its research labs on October 20-21

  77. 19/10 12:38

    Visit Nafplio, the wonderful first capital of Greece

  78. 19/10 10:32

    Pavlopoulos and Stournaras briefed on online platform for investors

  79. 18/10 23:48

    40 bloggers present their travel experiences in Greece

  80. 18/10 23:45

    New case of a privatization project stuck in Greece's logjam

  81. 18/10 23:42

    Greek Marinas Association wins bid to host ICOMIA World Marinas Conference in 2018

  82. 18/10 23:33

    Swedish tourism: Crete and Rhodes most popular destinations for Apollo in 2017

  83. 18/10 23:08

    Top-10 hotels in Greece at Conde Nast Traveler's Readers' Choice Awards 2017

  84. 18/10 22:51

    Large fish-shaped fossil discovered at Samaria Gorge on Crete island in Greece

  85. 18/10 22:46

    Intrakat firm leases historic Athens building for boutique hotel

  86. 18/10 22:37

    Sources: US Congress recognizes Greece's importance for American interests

  87. 18/10 22:27

    Report: Following the trail of Egyptian connections in Athens

  88. 18/10 21:50

    Nine Greeks on the Forbes 400 Wealthiest People in America list

  89. 18/10 21:41

    2017 to mark a new historic high in tourist arrivals to Cyprus

  90. 18/10 21:23

    US President Trump: We have great confidence in Greece

  91. 18/10 17:33

    58th Thessaloniki International Film Festival between 2-12 November

  92. 18/10 17:20

    US VP Pence reiterates support for credible debt relief for Greece

  93. 18/10 15:03

    Large travel organisations reps visit Messolongi area in Western Greece

  94. 18/10 11:38

    Greek astronomer discovers rare cigar-shaped galaxies (video)

  95. 17/10 16:14

    Greek Tourism Confederation’s head Yiannis Retsos: SETE alongside local communities

  96. 17/10 16:02

    Greek state to sell 30% stake in Athens airport holding company

  97. 17/10 15:57

    Greek banks accelerate actions against strategic bad debtors

  98. 17/10 15:51

    Impressive “Jews of Greece’’ exhibition opens in Sydney, Australia

  99. 17/10 15:42

    Greek yogurt conquers India with Epigamia brand (video)

  100. 17/10 15:38

    Tender winner has tabled required paperwork for Thessaloniki port sale