Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the Americas

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the AmericasThe fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers

Among the many theories about which civilization first sailed to the Americas and discovered them, there is also the theory that the ancient Phoenicians were the first.

This theory became popular in the 18th century and is closely connected with the petroglyphs on Dighton Rock which are still of unknown origin. This theory is not quite as popular as the one that says that the Norse made the discovery first, but still, it is worth mentioning.

Back in the 18th century, a lot of scholars started to offer ideas about the true origin of the inscriptions on the rock. Ezra Stiles, a theologian, author, and also the seventh President of Yale College, claimed that the inscriptions are in Hebrew. Antoine Court de Gébelin, who is mainly known for the popularization of the Tarot, had his own idea about the rock. He believed that the inscription was made by Carthaginian sailors who commemorated their journey to the shores of Massachusetts.

In the 19th century, the theory that a group of Israelite people visited the New World was widely adopted in the Mormon community.

Later, Ross T. Christensen, an American archeologist, speculated that the Mulekites, who are mentioned in the Book of Mormon, were probably of Phoenician ethnic origin.

Stone tablet with inscription

The Phoenician theory is also supported in a book written in 1871, by John Denison Baldwin, an American anthropologist. In Ancient America, Baldwin wrote,

“The known enterprise of the Phoenician race, and this ancient knowledge of America, so variously expressed, strongly encourage the hypothesis that the people called Phoenicians came to this continent, established colonies in the region where ruined cities are found, and filled it with civilized life. It is argued that they made voyages on the ‘great exterior ocean,’ and that such navigators must have crossed the Atlantic; and it is added that symbolic devices similar to those of the Phoenicians are found in the American ruins, and that an old tradition of the native Mexicans and Central Americans described the first civilizers as ‘bearded white men,’ who ‘came from the East in ships’.”

A stone tablet with an inscription that was supposed to be of Phoenician origin appeared in Brazil in the 1870s. The tablet was given to Ladislau de Souza Mello Netto, who was the director of the National Museum of Brazil at that time, and he immediately acknowledged the artifact as genuine. The inscription allegedly told the story of some Sidonian Canaanites who visited the shore of Brazil. It was later discovered that the symbols that appear on the tablet were variations of letters that appeared in different periods over a span of 800 years. It was impossible for all the letters to appear on the same tablet at the same time, so the artifact and the inscription were dismissed as fake.

In the 20th century, a few new artifacts appeared that again spiked the theory of Phoenician or Semitic discovery. One of these artifacts was the Bat Creek inscription. Cyrus Herzl Gordon, Near Eastern cultures and ancient languages expert, believed that the inscription of this tablet was in Paleo-Hebrew. Gordon thought that this was proof that Semitic people visited the continent prior to Columbus. Later, the Bat Creek inscription, together with another artifact called the Las Lunas Decalogue Stone, were proven to be forgeries and Gordon’s claim was dismissed.

Phoenician sailors visited the Americas 

In 1996, Mark McMenamin, an American paleontologist, speculated that Phoenician sailors visited the Americas around 350 BC. He based his theory on some gold stater coins that were allegedly made by the state of Carthage. On the back of the coins was a map of the Mediterranean and another land on the west, across the Atlantic. McMenamin interpreted that land as the Americas but later discovered that those coins were actually a modern forgery.

Another form of written evidence that slightly goes in favor of the arrival of Phoenicians in the Americas can be found in Ptolemy’s Geography. Lucio Russo, an Italian physicist, mathematician, and historian of science, analyzed Ptolemy’s book and noticed that he gives the coordinates of the Fortunate Isles.

The fortunate Islands were a group of legendary islands mentioned by various ancient Greek writers. Russo also noticed that the size of the world in Ptolemy’s Geography is smaller than what Eratosthenes measured. After he gave the same coordinates of the Fortunate Islands to the Antilles, the map irregularities in Ptolemy’s descriptions disappeared. According to Russo, Ptolemy could have known about the Antilles from his source, Hipparcos, who lived in Rhodes. It is possible that Hipparcos heard about the Antilles from Phoenicians sailors who controlled the western Mediterranean in those days. This is a far-fetched idea, but still, an interesting one.

Modern-day scholars

Most of the modern-day scholars deny the idea that Phoenicians, Canaanites, or Carthaginians discovered the Americas first.

Ronald H. Fritze, an American historian, says that although it was technically possible for those people to reach the Americas, it probably never happened:

“No archaeological evidence has yet been discovered to prove the contentions of Irwin, Gordon, Bailey, Fell and others. Since even the fleeting Norse presence in Vinland left definite archaeological remains at L’Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland, it seems logical that the allegedly more extensive Phoenician and Carthaginian presence would have left similar evidence. The absence of such remains is strong circumstantial evidence that the Phoenicians and Carthaginians never reached the Americas.”

Until some concrete evidence appears, this theory will remain only a fantasy.

Source:thevintagenews.com

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

 

Tornos
  1. 19/06 00:27

    Harvard Library acquires archive of iconic Greek poet Nikos Gatsos

  2. 19/06 00:21

    Media: DG Comp delay doubles offer for 20-year concession of Athens Airport

  3. 19/06 00:13

    Cyprus’ residents trips abroad rise by 1.7% during May 2018

  4. 19/06 00:06

    Land developer confident Helleniko project can commence construction in early 2019

  5. 18/06 23:58

    Tatler Travel Guide 2018: Two Greek hotels among the 101 best in the world

  6. 18/06 23:42

    Ryanair flight attendant dancing to Britney Spears' Toxic goes viral

  7. 18/06 22:45

    Report: The mystery of the Sleeping Giant in the Greek island of Naxos

  8. 18/06 21:17

    Indian President Ram Nath Kovind visits Greek capital of Athens

  9. 18/06 21:12

    Space Agrobox: Greek students find way to feed astronauts

  10. 18/06 21:03

    New York Times laud Athens as a rising cultural capital of Europe

  11. 18/06 20:06

    4th Annual Loukoumi Dance Party and Make A Difference Awards in New York

  12. 18/06 20:01

    Tourist arrivals in Cyprus up by 7.6% during May

  13. 18/06 19:55

    Summer Nostos Festival returns in Athens between June 17-24 (video)

  14. 18/06 19:40

    Arab resorts try to copycat Greece’s Cycladic island beauty

  15. 18/06 19:35

    Greek Investment Roadshow in the USA to take place between June 19-22

  16. 18/06 18:27

    Food-For-Good Festival in Kalamaria Thessaloniki a big hit

  17. 18/06 16:23

    Ancient Theatre of Aptera in Crete to reopen after 17 centuries of silence

  18. 18/06 14:19

    TUI report: Scaling positive change through sustainable tourism

  19. 18/06 12:09

    Olympic champion Stefanidi to participate in Athens Street Pole Vault event

  20. 18/06 10:02

    ABTA: 1 in 3 Brits travel abroad without checking advice about their holiday destination

  21. 15/06 21:19

    Religious Tourism: Exploring ancient Christian churches in Turkey

  22. 15/06 21:08

    Poll: 99% of women hate their partner wearing tight Speedos

  23. 15/06 20:37

    Alexandria’s Greek graves in Egypt form moving monument to Diaspora

  24. 15/06 20:30

    Cavo Paradiso club in Mykonos island celebrates 25th anniversary

  25. 15/06 18:26

    Bus work stoppages in Athens on Tuesday and Thursday

  26. 15/06 16:22

    New objective tax rates for property in Greece approved by finance ministry

  27. 15/06 14:17

    First run for trimaran Superspeed linking Thessaloniki with Sporades islands

  28. 15/06 12:06

    Rainy weather front to affect parts of Greece until Tuesday

  29. 15/06 10:00

    New Mykonos Art festival aims to redefine the popular island destination

  30. 15/06 00:04

    ESM approves 1 billion euros disbursement to Greece

  31. 14/06 23:49

    Nine of the most incredible insurance claims in the history of travel experiences

  32. 14/06 23:38

    Hellenic Heritage Foundation of Toronto celebrates 22nd Annual Gala

  33. 14/06 23:32

    Piraeus to receive €2 million in countervailing benefit from Cosco-run port

  34. 14/06 23:27

    Rich Indians turn to Cyprus for coveted European Union passports

  35. 14/06 20:56

    Bank of Greece: Apartment values down by 40% in the country since 2007

  36. 14/06 20:49

    Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: Good

  37. 14/06 20:47

    Athens city council and Mastercard to promote Greek capital abroad

  38. 14/06 20:18

    Sky Express starts flights to and from Chania in Crete and Athens

  39. 14/06 18:34

    Greek Tourism Minister highlights country's attractions for Russians

  40. 14/06 18:32

    Media report: Celebrities making their way to Greece for Summer 2018

  41. 14/06 16:03

    Manasis School in Australia dances “Zorba the Greek” at rugby game

  42. 14/06 14:56

    The Tiger Lillies tour Greece between June 19-24

  43. 14/06 10:33

    Airlines’ ‘hidden’ fees report: Better know before you go

  44. 14/06 01:49

    Guardian: Mykonos and Santorini among 10 classic European islands on a budget

  45. 14/06 01:40

    The essential guide to drinking Ouzo

  46. 14/06 01:34

    Andros island museum hosts tribute to expressionist Dimitris Mytaras

  47. 14/06 01:27

    Tourism, food and beverage sectors boost new hirings in May

  48. 14/06 01:18

    The full agreement between Greece and FYROM on name dispute in English

  49. 14/06 00:55

    The six best toilets in the 2018 International Toilet Tourism Awards

  50. 14/06 00:24

    Work stoppages to affect most transport means in Athens on Thursday

  51. 14/06 00:08

    All-night performance at Temple of Epicurean Apollo in Peloponnese

  52. 13/06 23:13

    Supplementary tax hike on Greek islands and Athens city center

  53. 13/06 22:07

    Tickets to travel to four European countries to 315 young Greeks

  54. 13/06 20:48

    Dior launches pop up store in Mykonos with exclusive Myconian collection

  55. 13/06 20:02

    Athens Taxi owners go again on strike over Uber return fears

  56. 13/06 19:42

    Expert presentation: The color and design of the Parthenon frieze

  57. 13/06 16:24

    Report: Tiffany Trump and Lindsay Lohan planning Mykonos trip together

  58. 13/06 12:52

    Russian Foreign Minister: Economic ties with Greece growing strongly

  59. 13/06 12:11

    Ryanair adds new route between Southend Airport and Corfu in Greece

  60. 13/06 01:43

    Ancient music experts accompany Ovid readings at National Museum in Athens

  61. 12/06 23:36

    96th Annual Kytherian Debutante Ball in Australia

  62. 12/06 22:32

    New high speed ferry to link Crete with Cyclades on daily basis

  63. 12/06 22:26

    Aristotle Menu: Eating like the Ancient Greek philosopher

  64. 12/06 19:23

    Acropolis Museum in Athens celebrates 9th year by embracing digital era

  65. 12/06 18:14

    Greece’s select wines return to Australia

  66. 12/06 16:10

    Unemployment in Greece drops to 20.1% in March thanks to tourism

  67. 12/06 14:59

    Media report: More upscale hotel additions across Greece

  68. 12/06 12:53

    Minister: New law puts Greece at forefront of EU green energy

  69. 12/06 01:18

    International Investment Awards to take place in Cyprus on 19 June

  70. 12/06 01:15

    New deals announced during Posidonia 2018 exhibition in Athens

  71. 12/06 01:11

    Athens tram terminal moves from SEF to Kallithea temporarily

  72. 12/06 00:57

    Cretan wedding with 69 Best Men and Maids of Honour and 3500 guests

  73. 12/06 00:50

    Tourism sees jobs data post a new record in Greece during May

  74. 12/06 00:50

    Summer fun for kids at the National Archaeological Museum in Athens

  75. 12/06 00:39

    No buses 12:00-17:00 in Athens on Thursday including airport service

  76. 12/06 00:33

    Two Greek island hotels among the Leading Hotels of the World

  77. 11/06 22:58

    Property tax hikes due to the new objective values in Greece

  78. 11/06 22:24

    Dozens of shiny Ferraris on show at Greek island of Corfu

  79. 11/06 20:54

    Sharp rise in numbers of visitors to ancient site of Knossos in Crete

  80. 11/06 20:14

    Annual Report: Most beaches in Attica are in excellent condition

  81. 11/06 16:18

    Participants in 11th Naked Bike Ride Thessaloniki paint their bodies (videos)

  82. 11/06 14:11

    Greek Tourism Minister Secretary General: Foreign arrivals to exceed 32 million in 2018

  83. 11/06 10:51

    Ambassador: Greece can become Qatar's gateway to Europe

  84. 11/06 00:42

    Luxury holiday homes have booming year across Greece

  85. 11/06 00:02

    Yacht owner on Greek island of Lefkada rents it as a luxury home

  86. 10/06 23:40

    TAP pipeline plants 400,000 trees and shrubs in northern Greece

  87. 10/06 23:14

    Greek firefighters find looted Classical antiquities in Locris area

  88. 10/06 22:58

    TRAINOSE improves buyout offer on Greek railway maintenance firm

  89. 10/06 20:51

    Cyprus President lays foundation for Europe’s largest Casino Resort (video)

  90. 10/06 18:42

    Greek Transport Ministry signs MoU with European Aviation Safety Agency

  91. 10/06 16:23

    City of Athens provides watering stations for stray animals as heat rises

  92. 10/06 12:15

    Greek breweries open to public with series of events on beers

  93. 10/06 00:50

    Fraport Greece: International arrivals at 14 regional airports in May take off

  94. 08/06 23:33

    Under-construction Thessaloniki metro opens two stations for visits

  95. 08/06 23:27

    Possible stopover of Air Force One at Souda Bay in Crete on weekend

  96. 08/06 23:22

    Athens Pride Parade to be held at Syntagma Square on Saturday

  97. 08/06 23:21

    Surrey savors 10-day Greek Food Festival

  98. 08/06 22:04

    Travel report: Top things to do in Delphi and surrounding area

  99. 08/06 20:55

    ‘Smart benches’ set to pop up in public places across Athens

  100. 08/06 18:50

    Stars walk the red carpet at the 12th Los Angeles Greek Film Festival