Trump pressured to put Turkey first and US second in Syria showdown

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Trump pressured to put Turkey first and US second in Syria showdownAnkara may retaliate against the United States if its desire to recapture Raqqa is denied

The United States and its local Arab, Christian and Kurdish allies—the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF)—in northeastern Syria are preparing to attack Raqqa, the reportedly heavily defended last bastion of ISIL. The current plan is that U.S. forces will train, arm, advise and support the SDF, who will then bear the brunt of the direct fighting to liberate and then secure the city. There is an emerging risk, however, that U.S. forces will be drawn more directly into the fight and subsequent pacification of northeastern Syria. Though U.S. spokespersons have made clear their preference for the former, the risk of the latter is growing because Turkey is emphatically opposed to U.S. cooperation with the Kurds. Indeed, Turkey suggests that it should work with its own Syrian allies to liberate and pacify Raqqa. So, it would be a great irony if Donald Trump, who campaigned in part on his opposition to costly direct U.S. interventions into internal conflicts, lead the United States into yet another quagmire, to assuage Turkey’s concerns.

Though the United States has worked assiduously to cultivate the image (and presumably the fact) of a genuinely multiethnic and multi-confessional anti-ISIL SDF coalition, it is apparent that the most reliable fighters are the Kurds. It is not plausible that an attack on Raqqa can succeed without an enthusiastic, large scale Kurdish participation. And given what we know about how hard it is to overcome the prepared defenses that ISIL employs in city fighting, it is necessary to provide the Kurds with meaningful quantities of heavy weapons, including armored fighting vehicles, antitank guided weapons and heavy mortars—even if there is considerable U.S. fire support from artillery and airstrikes. After Raqqa falls, Kurdish forces will also be necessary to consolidate the victory and to pursue ISIL remnants as they try to exfiltrate the battlespace, burrow into smaller villages and organize for revenge. Put simply, if the Kurds are not better armed and do not participate intensively in the battle, Raqqa can probably not be taken without significant and direct U.S. participation at the forefront of the fight. After the fight, these same U.S. forces would be left holding the bag for the pursuit and suppression of ISIL remnants.

It is always difficult to predict how a battle with ISIL may unfold because, for its own reasons, the terror group fights intensely at certain times and places, but not at others. But presuming that there are several thousand fighters in Raqqa and ISIL plans to defend the town as intensely as it has defended Mosul, then it is likely that the United States would need at least a brigade’s worth of combat power—several thousand personnel with tanks and supporting armored fighting vehicles—to break the defenses. This assumes that local allied forces can hold the perimeter around the town and consolidate captured ground. If they cannot, it is entirely plausible that this estimate is too low. The second battle of Fallujah required two brigade-sized units of U.S. Marines, reinforced with two Army heavy-mechanized battalions, to take the city.

High number of U.S. casualties

That 2004 battle resulted in a relatively high number of U.S. casualties—seventy dead and six hundred wounded. U.S. troop numbers in Syria have already risen to nearly one thousand, including special operations forces and a task force of U.S. Marines to provide artillery support. Given the incremental way that U.S. deployments to Iraq unfolded, we are entitled to suspect that additional U.S. forces will be dispatched to Syria even if the United States sticks with the SDF/Kurdish option. Without the Kurds, the United States would need even more troops.

Why would the United States choose to have its own forces bear the brunt of the Raqqa fight? Turkey mistrusts the Syrian Kurds and assumes that there is no difference between the Syrian Kurds and the Turkish Kurds, with whom they are at war. Turkey is a NATO ally, and the first instinct of establishment U.S. security officials, such as Secretary of Defense Mattis, is to protect the alliance as an institution, which includes Turkey’s loyal membership. Turkish officials have delivered increasingly vehement warnings that the United States ought not to rely too heavily on the Syrian Kurds for the Raqqa fight and the subsequent political and security stabilization of northeastern Syria. Turkey proffers vague and seemingly impractical schemes by which their Syrian-Arab allies, whoever they are, accompanied by Turkish troops should lead the Raqqa battle and presumably manage the aftermath. Judging from maps of the fighting, this could only occur if the United States coerced Kurdish forces into stepping out of the way and allow the Turks and their allies to reach Raqqa. Put another way, Turkey is demanding that the United States abandon and betray its Kurdish allies in the hopes that Turkey and its allies can do the job in Raqqa. Thus, the only alternative that ensures a victory in Raqqa, and keeps the Turks onside, is for the United States to bear the brunt of the Raqqa fighting and to remain thereafter to secure the victory.

Clearly, the United States is trying to persuade Turkey to accept the Kurdish role in the preferred U.S. plan. Presumably inducements, fig leaves and promises are on offer and the Turks may, in the end, accept the U.S. position. But if they don’t, President Trump may get a test of his “America First” principle. The U.S. national interest is that the local forces, including the Kurds, bear the brunt of the Raqqa fight and subsequent pacification effort. Turkey has a different interest. It claims a willingness to do the job itself alongside Syrian allies. Though the Turkish army is formidable, their Syrian allies are not, and their ability to deliver Raqqa is doubtful. Moreover it is implausible that the Turks would—or their allies could—stabilize northeastern Syria after Raqqa’s liberation. In the end, if Turkey cannot be assuaged and the Trump administration remains committed to the SDF lead attack on Raqqa, Turkey will need to be ignored, and perhaps even deterred from interference. Turkey presumably has unspecified retaliation in mind against the United States and its allies, in the event that their wishes are ignored. Turkey should be made aware that retaliation goes both ways. Alternatively, the United States can honor Turkey’s concerns, which means that U.S. forces could, by default, end up leading the fight for Raqqa. Turkey first, America second.

Source:nationalinterest.org

Read more here.

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Tornos
  1. 28/03 22:39

    Lindsay Lohan's photo with Islamic headscarf and white t-shirt on bed

  2. 28/03 22:35

    Greek research team's discovery spark new hope for Parkinson's cure

  3. 28/03 22:30

    Theory: Ancient Phoenicians were the first to discover the Americas

  4. 28/03 17:41

    Greek prosecutor brings charges Artemis Sorras and seven associates

  5. 28/03 15:27

    Greek PM discusses plan for Holocaust Museum with Boutaris and Saltiel

  6. 28/03 14:23

    Apple makes historic change to iPhones and iPads with few in the know

  7. 28/03 13:37

    Greek Minister of Culture: No delays to the Beyazit mosque’s repairs

  8. 28/03 12:20

    Government official: Staff-level agreement could be reached by April 7

  9. 28/03 11:17

    EU Federica Mogherini calls on Turkey to respect neighbours

  10. 28/03 10:12

    Thomas Cook records 40% increase in bookings for Greece

  11. 28/03 04:17

    European Union states urged to meet refugee relocation pledge

  12. 28/03 04:14

    Study: Undeclared income by self-employed in Greece between 57%-58.6%

  13. 28/03 04:12

    Thessaloniki pharmacist chief warns of medicine shortages

  14. 28/03 04:11

    Prosecutors send ‘Henry Dunant’ hospital file to Greek Parliament

  15. 28/03 04:09

    Anastasiades and Akinci to meet again on Sunday

  16. 28/03 04:07

    Greek President: Real reform essential for overcoming the crisis

  17. 28/03 04:04

    Greek PM meets Western Greece region local authority officials

  18. 28/03 04:02

    Greek railroad holding company examines user fee increases

  19. 28/03 04:01

    Contraction of credit continues unabated in Greece

  20. 28/03 03:58

    Athens Trade Association: Opening hours for shops in run-up to Easter

  21. 28/03 03:56

    Bank of Greece head: Delays in review questions targets for 2017

  22. 28/03 03:55

    Greek government: Declaration of Rome is a positive outcome

  23. 28/03 03:52

    Greek PPC announces strikes against sale of power production units

  24. 28/03 03:50

    10 former Attica bank officials charged with breach of duty over loans

  25. 28/03 03:48

    First Greek microsatellite UPSat launched into space

  26. 28/03 03:42

    Turkish CN-235 violates Greek airspace 16 times in one day

  27. 28/03 03:39

    Carl Sagan: How ancient Greeks figured out the Earth isn’t flat over 2,000 years ago (video)

  28. 27/03 23:35

    Chinese companies in Greece present plans to Economy minister

  29. 27/03 22:32

    Turkish journalist: Ankara's secret services increase operations in Greece

  30. 27/03 19:30

    Fraport Greece signs €1 billion loan agreement for 14 regional airports

  31. 27/03 17:26

    400% recorded rise in Russian tourists' early bookings for Greece and Cyprus for 2017

  32. 27/03 13:24

    CEO Geoff Ballotti: Wyndham Hotel Group to expand presence in Greece

  33. 27/03 11:21

    Greek government tables proposals for constitutional reforms in Parliament

  34. 27/03 03:19

    Fun and fact-filled month at Athens Observatory Visitors' Centre in April

  35. 27/03 03:16

    Turkish man arrested by Greek police in northern city of Komotini

  36. 26/03 18:52

    Europarliament S&D head Pitella declared Honorary Citizen of Athens

  37. 26/03 18:50

    Three bidders for majority stake of Thessaloniki port in Greece

  38. 26/03 18:46

    World Cup: Greece draws 1-1 to Belgium and remains second in group

  39. 26/03 18:43

    Greek FM: Struggle for a viable Cyprus solution requires unity

  40. 26/03 18:39

    Cycladic Art Museum: Educational programs for children aged 2-12

  41. 26/03 18:36

    Bank of Greece head: Weak institutions the reason Greece remains in bailout

  42. 26/03 18:30

    Fascinating ‘Pompeii and the Greeks’ exhibition opens its doors in Italy

  43. 26/03 18:22

    Ernst & Young report: The profile of the Greek tax-evader

  44. 26/03 18:20

    Greek cyber-crime unit arrests 17-year-old for child pornography

  45. 26/03 18:14

    15 shot and 1 killed at Cincinnati Nightclub by gunman (video)

  46. 26/03 18:07

    Greek Community of Melbourne pays tribute to late director Nikos Koundouros

  47. 26/03 18:02

    One injured in sailboat collision with freighter off Patras in Greece

  48. 26/03 18:00

    AP: US probes Manafort’s financial transactions in Cyprus

  49. 26/03 17:54

    AHC: Boycott ‘The Ottoman Lieutenant’ film for denying Greek genocide

  50. 26/03 17:51

    Greek Minister to Spiegel: We cannot host a single additional refugee

  51. 26/03 17:47

    Historic report: The heroines of the Greek War of Independence

  52. 26/03 17:41

    Cyprus rebuffs Turkey and won’t stop oil and gas exploration off coast

  53. 26/03 17:28

    Georgios Karaiskakis, a great hero of the Greek War of Independence

  54. 26/03 17:24

    Greece vs Hellas: The semantics behind the country with many names (video)

  55. 26/03 17:13

    An Australian Evzone in New York

  56. 26/03 16:05

    Greece establishes archaeological lines for Helleniko €7.9 bn development project

  57. 26/03 15:03

    Trump, Demetrios and Priebus mark Greek Independence Day (videos)

  58. 26/03 14:58

    Donald Trump’s proclamation for Greek Independence Day on March 25th

  59. 26/03 12:56

    Greek police arrest 2 truck drivers smuggling in 20 migrants

  60. 26/03 10:36

    Greek Defense Minister seeks stronger ties with the United States

  61. 26/03 10:29

    NYT review: “A World of Emotions” in Greek art unmasks the Stony Faces

  62. 25/03 20:55

    Greek PM to meet Georgian counterpart next Tuesday

  63. 25/03 20:54

    ND leader Mitsotakis: Our generation must bring about a new start for Greece

  64. 25/03 20:50

    Devastating floods in Peru kill 84 and scatter bones from cemetery (video)

  65. 25/03 20:46

    Reuters: Dijsselbloem’s possible Eurogroup fall's impact on Greece

  66. 25/03 20:44

    School parade held in downtown Athens for March 25 anniversary

  67. 25/03 20:37

    Messi faces heavy penalty after swearing at assistant referee (video)

  68. 25/03 20:35

    ESM: Some progress in talks to conclude Greek 2nd review

  69. 25/03 20:32

    Clocks advance one hour to Daylight Saving Time in Greece on Sunday

  70. 25/03 20:29

    Tusk: Social protection and labor best practices upheld 'across Europe'

  71. 25/03 20:26

    March 25 anniversary: Greece outside Europe ‘inconceivable’ says President

  72. 25/03 20:23

    Jean Claude Juncker to PM: EU acquis already in effect in Greece

  73. 25/03 20:21

    Naked Polish activists kill sheep in front of Auschwitz gate

  74. 25/03 20:17

    German FM: Failing to continue Greek program "irresponsible"

  75. 25/03 20:02

    European Union 27 sign Rome Summit declaration

  76. 25/03 19:57

    Pope Francis thanks Greek Prime Minister for aiding poor

  77. 25/03 19:50

    Greek Prime Minister: We must fight to change Europe from within

  78. 25/03 19:30

    Hollywood star Gwyneth Paltrow’s publishes guide to sex and more

  79. 25/03 18:14

    Greek Defence minister meets U.S. counterpart James Mattis

  80. 25/03 16:07

    Military parade in Athens marks 1821 War of Independence anniversary

  81. 25/03 13:59

    Greek FM at Nicosia’s March 25 parade: We must all protect Cyprus

  82. 25/03 11:56

    Google doodle celebrates Greece National Day 2017

  83. 25/03 11:44

    Conspiracy theory by Swedish Facebook personality: Australia doesn’t exist!

  84. 25/03 10:55

    Greek travel industry winners at 4th Tourism Awards 2017

  85. 25/03 04:10

    Donald Trump in White House: "Oh, do I love the Greeks"

  86. 24/03 19:58

    Airplane’s door opens moments before take off (video)

  87. 24/03 19:52

    Greek flag raised to Independence Day in Lynn, Massachusetts in USA

  88. 24/03 19:47

    Putin to Le Pen: Russia reserves right to meet any French politician (video)

  89. 24/03 19:44

    US President honors Greek Independence Day March 25 (video)

  90. 24/03 19:33

    Erdogan's Turkey: A Sunni Iran in the making

  91. 24/03 19:30

    President Anastasiades hopes UK FM will give Ankara message on Cyprus

  92. 24/03 19:28

    German Fin Min: Greece will remain in Eurozone only with competitive economy

  93. 24/03 19:26

    Greek Ministers to visit Cyprus in coming days

  94. 24/03 19:24

    Juncker warns Trump on new Balkan war if US President urges break up of EU

  95. 24/03 19:21

    Cypriot Minister Kadis: Education issues require pan-European approach

  96. 24/03 19:17

    UK Police release new recent photo of London terrorist

  97. 24/03 19:14

    EU President response to Greek PM's letter on EU social acquis

  98. 24/03 19:12

    12 migrants drown in Aegean Sea off Turkish coast with 7 rescued and 4 missing

  99. 24/03 19:09

    Fin Min: Last issues in review to be concluded in 'next few days'

  100. 24/03 19:04

    Turkey threatens again to take actions regarding Cyprus’ natural gas