IATA-McKinsey study shows imbalanced aviation industry value chain
The International Air Transport Association (IATA) and McKinsey & Company published a study of profitability trends across the aviation value chain showing that profitability varies widely by sector. The study also shows that in aggregate, airlines underperform on the financial return that an investor would normally expect.
While there is no clear path to rapidly re-balance the value chain, the study concludes that there are some key areas—including decarbonization and data-sharing—were working together and burden-sharing will mutually benefit all value chain participants.
Highlights from the Understanding the Pandemic’s impact on the Aviation Value Chain study (pdf) include:
Capital Destruction: Despite delivering consistent operating profits pre-pandemic (2012-2019), airlines collectively did not produce economic returns above the industry’s Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). On average the collective Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) generated by airlines was 2.4% below the WACC, collectively destroying an average of $17.9 billion of capital each year.
Value Creation: Pre-pandemic, all sectors of the value chain except airlines delivered ROIC in excess of the WACC, with airports leading the pack in the absolute value of return by rewarding investors with an average of $4.6 billion annually above the WACC (3% of revenue). When viewed as a percentage of revenue, Global Distribution Systems (GDSs)/Travel Tech firms topped the list with average returns of 8.5% of revenues above the WACC ($700 million annually), followed by ground handlers (5.1% of revenue or $1.5 billion annually), and Air Navigation Service Providers (ANSPs) at 4.4% of revenues ($1.0 billion annually).
Pandemic Changes: Although the pandemic (2020-2021) saw losses across the value chain, in absolute terms airlines’ losses led the pack, with ROIC falling below the WACC by an average of $104.1 billion annually (-20.6% of revenues). Airports saw ROIC fall $34.3 billion below the WACC and generated the largest economic losses as a percentage of revenue (-39.5% of revenues).
This research reaffirms that airlines improved their profitability in the years following the Global Financial Crisis. But it also clearly shows that airlines, on average, were not able to benefit financially to the same degree as their suppliers and infrastructure partners. Rewards across the value chain are also disproportionate to risk. Airlines are the most sensitive to shocks but have limited profits with which to build a financial buffer,” said Willie Walsh, IATA’s Director General.
The pandemic saw all players fall into economic losses. As the industry recovers from the crisis, the study’s most important question is: can a more balanced distribution of economic returns and risk be realized in the post-pandemic world?” said Walsh.
Several changes in the profile of airline economic returns are noted in the study:
While network carriers underperformed the low-cost sector (LCCs) pre-pandemic, average economic returns by network carriers exceeded those of the LCCs during the pandemic. The gap between the two, however, has narrowed as the recovery progressed.
Airlines solely operating cargo flights have a profitable financial performance with an ROI of nearly 10%. Thus, the profitability of all-cargo carriers was the reverse of airlines carrying both passengers and cargo. By comparison, the performance of all cargo carriers is still well below the average ROIC for freight forwarders which began the crisis at nearly 15% of revenues and grew to 40% of revenues by 2021.
Regionally, it was clear that in aggregate North American carriers entered the crisis with the healthiest balance sheets and strongest financial performance. The picture of recovery was less clearcut in 2021, but having fallen the deepest in the crisis, the trajectory of the region’s recovery is also the steepest.
Why do airlines generate insufficient economic returns?
An updated analysis of the forces shaping airline profitability originally done in 2011 with Harvard Business School’s Professor Michael Porter demonstrates there has been little positive change.
Competitive Fragmented Industry: The airline industry is intensely competitive, fragmented, and subject to high barriers to exit with low barriers to entry.
Structure of suppliers, buyers, and channels: A high concentration of powerful suppliers, the emergence of increasingly efficient alternatives to air travel, commoditized product offerings with low switching costs, and a fragmented buyers’ community are characteristics of the operating environment.
“It is difficult to see how these entrenched forces will change significantly in the near term. In most cases, the interests of those in the value chain are simply too divergent to work as partners to drive change that could meaningfully alter the profitability profile across the value chain. That is why IATA will continue to call on governments to better regulate our monopoly or near-monopoly suppliers like airports, ANSPs and GDSs,” said Walsh.
Recent IATA polling shows a public understanding of the need to regulate monopoly suppliers. Some 85% of consumers polled in an 11-country survey agreed that the prices that airports charge should be independently regulated, like utilities.
Cooperation
The value chain study also revealed some areas of common interest where greater cooperation would deliver benefits for all. Two of the examples noted in the study include:
Data-driven efficiency gains: Aviation generates vast amounts of data. At the operational level, sharing data to build a more complete picture of how day-to-day decisions impact customers, airport terminals, airline schedules/crew movements, and runway utilization is already helping to drive efficiencies for all industry players at some airports. This same principle can be applied across the industry to make better long-term decisions in areas including infrastructure development, process improvements, and skills development.
Decarbonization: Achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2050 cannot be done by airlines alone. Fuel suppliers need to make sustainable aviation fuels available in sufficient quantities at affordable prices. ANSPs need to provide optimal routings that minimize emissions. Engine and aircraft manufacturers must bring to market aircraft that are more fuel efficient and take advantage of low or zero-carbon propulsion means such as hydrogen or electricity. Those offering services in the airport environment will need to convert to electric vehicles.
There is no magic solution to rebalance the value chain. But it is clear that the interests of governments, travelers, and other value chain participants are best served by financially healthy participants—and particularly airlines. A combination of better regulation and cooperation in areas of mutual interest could move the needle. And there are at least two areas ripe for collaboration and burden sharing—pursuing data-driven efficiency gains and decarbonization,” said Walsh.
We are proud to have partnered with IATA since 2005 on understanding the value created across the aviation value chain. Over that time, the aviation industry has seen several crises and comebacks. But never has the aviation value chain overall returned its cost of capital. Airlines have consistently been the weakest element, even in their best years not quite returning the cost of capital. But there are win-wins, and companies across the value chain can work better together to serve customers, and improve value,” said Nina Wittkamp, Partner at McKinsey.
RELATED TOPICS: Greece, Greek tourism news, Tourism in Greece, Greek islands, Hotels in Greece, Travel to Greece, Greek destinations, Greek travel market, Greek tourism statistics, Greek tourism report
Photo Source: pixabay.com
- 1) Aegean and Olympic Air to fly 'Holy Light' from Athens to the rest of Greece
- 2) Aegean Airlines to distribute dividend for the first time after four years
- 3) Athens Airport voted as the best in marketing strategy at European awards in Denmark
- 4) Direct flight from Shanghai to Athens offers access to key tourism market for Greece
23/05 23:30
New Evinos bridge in Central Greece inaugurated by Transport Minister
23/05 21:34
Greece hosting meeting of International Organization of Securities Commissions May 26-29
23/05 20:37
Greek Deputy Foreign Minister highlights efforts to counter brain drain
23/05 20:24
Greek government to improve ties with Diaspora and consular services by AI
23/05 13:15
Climate Perception: Greece most resilient to global warming among Med destinations
22/05 23:17
Commander of French land forces visits Greece to promote military ties
22/05 20:06
Greek presence at 77th Cannes Film Festival includes Lanthimos film
22/05 18:55
Greece's Kalamata Dance Festival opens July 12 featuring 19 productions
22/05 18:11
Over 630 schools participate in 'Greek PISA' assessment tests on Wednesday
22/05 16:52
22/05 12:32
Porto Carras Pro-Am Aegean Mini Tour with participants from 12 countries
21/05 18:30
The President of the Hellenic Republic to visit Florence in Italy on May 23
21/05 17:24
'Greece through the Art of the Tourist Poster' exhibition in Chengdu of China
21/05 17:21
American Hellenic Institute honors Anniversary of the Pontic Greek Genocide
21/05 15:17
Arrivals and nights in Greek tourist accommodation rise 3.5% and 4.9% in March
21/05 14:12
Greek Tourism Minister receives ambassadors of Iraq and Slovakia
20/05 01:51
First Ramada by Wyndham Hotel in Fethiye opens in Ölüdeniz of Turkey
17/05 01:25
Mayors of Athens and Rome discuss city challenges and cooperation
16/05 23:20
Tsakopoulos Collection & Hellenic Studies Program marked their 20th anniversary
16/05 21:17
Greek Culture Minister hosts Turkish counterpart for ‘Romeo and Juliet’ premiere
16/05 20:12
Greek Finance Minister advocates green transition and Recovery Fund II
16/05 15:27
Higher global temperatures causing Caretta turtles to lay eggs sooner in Greece
15/05 20:32
BoG urges progress on harmonizing national systems of bank deposit guarantees
15/05 19:22
Islands Decarbonization Fund signing in Greek island of Naxos on May 27
15/05 14:15
EU Commission forecasts Greece's growth rate at 2.2% in 2024 and 2.3% in 2025
14/05 22:27
Syracuse show on Mycenaean influence on Sicily includes golden cup of Dendra
14/05 20:34
Greek Health Minister attends World Health Congress in Abu Dhabi
14/05 19:23
Greece and Santorini clinch top honors at American Leisure Lifestyle Awards 2024
14/05 18:31
20th Thessaloniki International Book Fair opens from May 16-19 at Helexpo
13/05 20:16
Greek Prime Minister meets with Turkish President in Ankara (video)
13/05 20:11
Greek Council of State to mull relocation of Mt Parnas casino to Maroussi again
13/05 15:48
13/05 09:53
Discover Kerasia Petrified Forest in northern Evia near the Greek Capital
11/05 01:30
Greek Foreign Minister congratulated new Serbian counterpart on assumption of duties
10/05 22:45
The 52nd Oakland Greek Festival to take place this year on May 17-19
10/05 22:33
Thessaloniki Port pier extension expected to be given the green light in the fall
10/05 19:42
Hellenic President visits Greek community's premises and Cavafy's tomb in Alexandria
10/05 19:27
Greek and Swiss ministers meet in Athens on investments and cooperation
09/05 17:22
Red Arrows aerobatic team to perform in Athens suburb of Paleo Faliro on May 18
05/05 19:40
International Tourism | WTTC: Travel sector set to break all records during 2024
04/05 17:56
Minister launches dynamic plan to boost Greece's relations with other countries
04/05 17:44
Greece opens another five Aegean Islands to Turkish visitors fast-track visas
03/05 23:04
03/05 18:00
03/05 17:42
Aegean and Olympic Air to fly 'Holy Light' from Athens to the rest of Greece
03/05 17:39
Athens transportation schedules over 2024 Greek Easter holidays announced
03/05 01:26
01/05 11:45
Euro 2004 Legends play FootGolf at Porto Carras Pro-Am Aegean Mini Tour
30/04 22:36
Visa entry express now available on five more Greek islands for Turkish citizens
30/04 20:44
Hellenic Police launches 10201, a 24-hour hotline for protection of minors in Greece
30/04 19:42
Aegean Airlines to distribute dividend for the first time after four years
30/04 18:39
May Day strikes in Greece: Public transportation disruptions and Syntagma Metro station closure
25/04 22:00
Greek FM talks with Kuwaiti counterpart on bilateral relations, regional cooperation
25/04 14:49
Prices of products in Easter Basket the same or lower in Greece than in 2023
25/04 13:57
25/04 12:44
Greece and China to ink cooperation protocols in the fisheries sector
25/04 09:53
Extended shop opening hours for Easter in Greece start on Thursday
25/04 02:19
Athens Airport voted as the best in marketing strategy at European awards in Denmark
25/04 02:10
President of Hellenic Republic visits La Chascona Museum in visit to Chile
24/04 21:31
Thirty-one Greek political parties to take part in European Parliament elections
24/04 21:25
Payment by bank cards now accepted on Athens Airport Express bus lines
24/04 14:12
Herculaneum papyri unveil more than location of Plato's tomb in Athens
23/04 23:52
Greece’s New Ambassador to the United States visits Queens in New York
23/04 21:49
Traffic regulations in Athens due to the Olympic Torch Relay on Thursday-Friday
23/04 20:59
President of Hellenic Republic wraps up visit to Uruguay at parliament
23/04 15:44
Greek government will pass legislation halving commission paid for POS transactions
23/04 15:03
Precise location of Plato's burial site unveiled by ancient papyrus
22/04 22:33
'Nature Positive' peport highlights new collaborative era in travel & tourism
22/04 21:25
22/04 20:37
Greek and Turkish delegations discuss Confidence Building Measures for 2024
22/04 18:29
Over 114,000 Greek Diaspora citizens register to vote by post in the European elections
22/04 13:40
19/04 01:29
Athens State Orchestra presents 'St. Matthew's Passion' by Bach on April 30th
18/04 21:49
Greek Climate Change Minister signs memorandum for Attica fire protection zones
18/04 20:32
'Easter Basket' and 'Godparents basket' to be put into effect next week in Greece
18/04 20:17
18/04 17:40
17/04 21:06
Thessaloniki Port: Performance growth for 2023 with record container throughput
17/04 20:57
Traffic regulations imposed in Athens for the 41st Peace Marathon on Sunday
17/04 20:52
17/04 18:15
Greek Foreign Minister addresses the 9th Our Ocean Conference in Athens
17/04 17:12
16/04 21:02
NHM hosts the Trial of Pericles at the Harris Theater in Chicago on April 17
16/04 20:17
Greece will invest $830 million to protect marine biodiversity
16/04 01:46
New York Greek Independence Parade honors 1821 and solemn Cyprus Anniversary
16/04 01:35
Olympic Games Paris 2024: Olympic Flame to be lit at Ancient Olympia in Greece
16/04 00:29
European Committee of Regions and UN release study on Rural Tourism
15/04 20:41
15/04 19:58
Minister: Greece is transforming into a hub for exporting quality agri-food products
15/04 18:51
Greek Environment Minister meets Chinese Deputy Minister of Natural Resources
13/04 00:13
UN Tourism and Croatia to launch Research Centre for Sustainable Tourism
12/04 00:03
2024 marks a critical year in the enduring strength of Greek-German relations
12/04 00:00
11/04 22:07
Ambassador: US committed to upgrade of Greek military and support NATO's SE flank
11/04 19:40
Hellenic Pride on display at rainy Chicago Greek Independence Day Parade
11/04 02:06
Delphi Economic Forum IX: Energy collaboration a 'key' in Greek-Bulgarian relations
11/04 01:58
UN Tourism launches investment guidelines for Albania sector
10/04 19:01
Greek FinMin: New package of economic measures in 2025 to lower taxes, raise pensions
10/04 18:25
Greek city of Nafplion hosts Mediterranean Yacht Show for ninth year running
09/04 23:57
Greek PM on Tilos: Innovative projects for a cyclical economy are of key significance
Climate Perception: Greece most resilient to global warming among Med destinations
Greek government to improve ties with Diaspora and consular services by AI
Greece's Kalamata Dance Festival opens July 12 featuring 19 productions
Commander of French land forces visits Greece to promote military ties
Greek presence at 77th Cannes Film Festival includes Lanthimos film
New Evinos bridge in Central Greece inaugurated by Transport Minister
Over 630 schools participate in 'Greek PISA' assessment tests on Wednesday
Greece hosting meeting of International Organization of Securities Commissions May 26-29
Greek Deputy Foreign Minister highlights efforts to counter brain drain
Greek Deputy Transport Minister flies in first test seaplane flight from Lavrio port
Greek parliament greenilights postal ballot for Europarliament elections
Athens traffic changes on Sunday due to Greece Race for the Cure
16 Greek firms showcase at international fashion exhibitions in London
IPTO announces framework agreement tender for undersea power cables in Greece
'Greece through the Art of the Tourist Poster' exhibition in Chengdu of China
Four hospitals in Attica Region already organizing afternoon surgical procedures
Greek Tourism Minister in Belgrade for International Exhibition
Greek Prime Minister arrives in Doha to be received by Sultan bin Saad Al Muraikhi
Precise location of Plato's burial site unveiled by ancient papyrus
Greek Foreign Minister congratulated new Serbian counterpart on assumption of duties
First Ramada by Wyndham Hotel in Fethiye opens in Ölüdeniz of Turkey
Temporary residence for displaced Ukrainians extended in Greece to March 2025
Greek goverment launches new Portfolio Fund to support SMEs and startups