Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from Airbnb

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from AirbnbAirbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders

Since the entry of Airbnb into the hospitality industry in 2008, media attention has largely focused on the disruptive nature of the service. Industry reports, as well as lively debates at hotel, travel and tourism conferences, have kept the spotlight on Airbnb’s growth and success. But despite all this attention, we still know little about its real impact on hotel sales.

In a recent publication in the International Journal of Hospitality Management, Dr. Manisha Singal (Virginia Tech University) and Dr. Jonathan Templin (University of Kansas) examined how Airbnb supply, price, and perceived quality affect the sales performance of incumbent hotels in the San Francisco market. In particular, they explored the impact of the development of Airbnb supply and users’ satisfaction on hotel sales patterns, and whether different hotel segments have been affected by Airbnb’s entry.

The findings revealed that:

Total Airbnb volume does not impact RevPar

Total Airbnb listings (i.e., total inventory) do not impact the growth trajectory of hotel RevPAR, which confirms the argument that Airbnb’s offering a supplementary service. These results are also consistent with a 2017 report on the Airbnb effect in Boston, and with an STR 2017 study of 13 global markets. However,

The average price of an Airbnb offer can have an impact on RevPAR

And that impact varies across different segments of the industry. Airbnb property prices had a positive effect on hotel RevPAR: the higher the price of the rentals posted on the platform, the higher the RevPAR of the hotels. Also,

  • The increase in the quality of the Airbnb service has a direct adverse impact on hotel performance. The higher the average satisfaction score of an Airbnb property, the lower the RevPAR for the hotels in the sample.  More specifically, every increase in the review score of an Airbnb property had a negative impact of -$25.54 on hotel RevPAR for hotels in the sample. Finally,
  • This last effect varies across segments. Airbnb rental prices had an effect on hotels’ RevPAR in the luxury segment, with an increase in RevPAR of $0.651 for every dollar increase in the average rental price of the Airbnb units.

In conclusion

Not just a supplement: The study reveals that Airbnb’s listings/offers do not merely supplement the lodging market, but rather show substitute characteristics in their long-term effects on hotel sales’ patterns.

Customers make comparisons: The effect of Airbnb on hotels sales is intricate, and appears to be based on customers’ dynamic comparison of the price and value offered by the two products.  The research results imply that guests do consider both products when booking rooms and compare the benefits of each through user reviews.

Signs of disruption: The results provide empirical evidence that Airbnb will disrupt the hotel business, and that the more Airbnb users are satisfied with their experience, the more likely it is that demand for hotel rooms will decrease. Hotel managers therefore need to be aware of the level of service and price offered by Airbnb and other sharing platforms in their market.  Airbnb offers in their locality can no longer be ignored and should be considered when developing revenue management strategies.

Airbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders.  The impact of the sharing economy is not related so much to the volume of the offers on the platform, but rather on the pricing and price-to-value proposition as perceived by guests.

Read more at ehotelier.com

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: pixabay.com

 

Tornos
  1. 23/10 22:23

    Education Tourism: 16 Greek Academics among world’s highly cited researchers

  2. 23/10 22:20

    "Body Politics" festival to take place in Onassis Cultural Centre on October 26-30

  3. 23/10 22:10

    Hotel boom pushes Cyprus to restrict Airbnb and short-term rentals

  4. 23/10 22:06

    Head of Global Tourism Resilience Centre

  5. 23/10 22:00

    Expedia study: American vacation deprivation levels reach five-year high in 2018

  6. 23/10 21:54

    Athens among six cities championing for 2018 European Capital of Innovation Award

  7. 23/10 20:58

    WTTC: The world’s best performing cities for tourism

  8. 23/10 20:51

    Greek Tourism 2018: Germans and Americans made the difference in first 8 months

  9. 23/10 19:40

    Spain's tourist numbers drop 0,8% but spending grows by 2.8% in 2018

  10. 23/10 18:50

    BBC: Philotimo, a Greek word with so much meaning that it can’t be defined

  11. 23/10 18:39

    Greece 5th top exhibitor in World Food Fair in Paris

  12. 23/10 18:26

    Piraeus competitiveness enhanced after VAT elimination on services and goods

  13. 23/10 17:35

    Majority of Britons book 2019 summer breaks to Europe

  14. 23/10 15:28

    Ryanair winter seat sale with flights for €5 each-way

  15. 23/10 15:21

    Ryanair: + 6% passenger traffic but 7% profit loss in H1 2018

  16. 23/10 14:35

    Lectures on WWII cultural politics in Greece at Athens National Museum on Friday

  17. 23/10 11:46

    Greek courts and land registry close down on Thursday due to 24-hour strike

  18. 23/10 10:01

    €1.6 million road contracts signed for Greek island of Crete

  19. 22/10 22:42

    Culture Tourism: VAT rate on concerts in Greece to be cut to 6% from 24%

  20. 22/10 21:26

    Restoring ferry route between Greece and Cyprus needs €5 million EU subsidy

  21. 22/10 17:56

    Greek nationals permanently included in United States visa waiver program

  22. 22/10 17:21

    Three-in-one Leonardo da Vinci show to open in Athens on November 30

  23. 22/10 16:51

    Fun Tourism: Athens night life where you most and least expect it

  24. 22/10 16:06

    City Break report: Exploring the beautiful Greek city of Nafplio in autumn

  25. 22/10 16:02

    Infographic: The world’s most competitive economies are in Europe

  26. 22/10 15:57

    Piraeus Bank the major lender behind €200 million Thriassio transit center

  27. 22/10 15:30

    Chinese babies “Made in Greece”: Bilateral deal to boost fertility tourism from China

  28. 22/10 13:24

    New manager at TUI Group’s premium club provider

  29. 22/10 13:03

    Minister: Greece to attract over 32 mil. tourists in 2018

  30. 22/10 12:37

    MSC Cruises and Fincantieri agreement for 4 new cruise ships

  31. 22/10 11:43

    OECD to actively support Greece in repairing damage from austerity

  32. 22/10 11:15

    Region of Attica excels in this year's 6th Travel Trade Athens

  33. 22/10 10:48

    Greek ship, first of its kind in the planet to use wind power

  34. 22/10 09:12

    Culture Tourism: 6-year-old Stelios to perform at New York’s Carnegie Hall (video)

  35. 21/10 13:59

    Special committee to review vote for Greeks abroad in national elections

  36. 20/10 20:18

    Athens suburbs of Halandri and Aghia Paraskevi want new bus line to metro

  37. 20/10 20:10

    Piraeus Bank and Thomas Cook sign €40 million deal for expansion in Greece

  38. 20/10 19:49

    Short-term rental owners must finalize registry profile in Greece by end November

  39. 20/10 19:43

    7th New Music Festival to be held in Cyrpus from 5 to 9 November 2018

  40. 20/10 18:58

    EU greenlights funding from Greek state for construction of motorway

  41. 20/10 18:38

    New York City Greek Film Festival 2018 held between October 18-23

  42. 20/10 14:32

    Greek-German Synergy Literary Congress takes place in Berlin

  43. 20/10 12:27

    Free admission for press card holders to Cyprus museums and archaeological sites

  44. 20/10 10:17

    Diving and Culture Tourism: Exploring a Byzantine shipwreck

  45. 20/10 03:11

    Olive tree piece found on Thirasia alters Santorini volcano explosion dates

  46. 19/10 21:32

    Grotesque art exhibition in Thessaloniki Teloglion until November 25

  47. 19/10 18:47

    Cyprus Ministry of Transport statement on the cease of operations of Cobaltair

  48. 19/10 17:22

    Thessaloniki’s historic Aristotelous Square

  49. 19/10 15:44

    AEGEAN and Olympic Air schedule extra flights for Cobalt Air passengers

  50. 19/10 13:14

    Cyprus' residents travelling abroad drop by 0.4% in September 2018

  51. 19/10 11:07

    Medical Tourism: At least 3 binding offers for Athens' Henry Dunant hospital

  52. 19/10 09:02

    “Hysteron, Proteron, Us” show at Archaeological Museum of Lemesos in Cyprus

  53. 19/10 07:52

    Capitalist Realism show in Thessaloniki PhotoBiennale 2018 to January 27

  54. 19/10 07:38

    Myconian Collection wins three Condé Nast Traveler Readers’ Choice Awards

  55. 19/10 05:33

    Medical Tourism: Greek start-up wins top award by EIT Health

  56. 19/10 03:38

    Cyprus Airline Cobalt stops flights amid lack of investment

  57. 19/10 03:28

    Cosco urges stepped up process to approve Port of Piraeus master plan

  58. 19/10 01:11

    Spring Torrents show in Thessaloniki until February 24

  59. 18/10 19:53

    National Hellenic Student Association holds 20th Convention: Tomorrow is Now

  60. 17/10 22:58

    Greek "fakes" and "fasolada" among superfoods of the world

  61. 17/10 22:51

    Free entrance to Athens Acropolis Museum on October 28 national holiday

  62. 17/10 22:31

    Tourist arrivals in Cyprus hit record high in September and first nine months

  63. 17/10 21:23

    Friendship and eros at Aristotle's Lyceum in Athens on October 21

  64. 17/10 20:13

    Special events and free entrance to 63 Greek museums and sites on October 18-21

  65. 17/10 18:04

    More containers moving through Greek port of Piraeus in 2018

  66. 17/10 17:25

    Athens Metro work stoppages very early and late on Friday

  67. 17/10 16:54

    5G network introduced in Kalamata city of Peloponnese next year

  68. 17/10 15:20

    Alexandros Iolas exhibition in Thessaloniki until January 20

  69. 17/10 14:59

    German woman returns ancient mosaic fragments taken from Greece in the sixties

  70. 17/10 13:37

    OECD blacklists Cyprus’ Golden Visas for affluent foreigners

  71. 17/10 12:44

    Scientists: Illegal trade placing Pindos mountain range wild orchids at risk

  72. 17/10 10:33

    "Beyond the Event" exhibition in Thessaloniki until October 25

  73. 16/10 23:03

    First female president of Athens Attica & Argosaronic Hotel Association

  74. 16/10 23:00

    Travelport: Greece among top-5 fastest-growing destinations for Italian travellers

  75. 16/10 22:48

    US Embassy commercial officer stresses USA’s keen financial interest in Greece

  76. 16/10 21:16

    Athens mayor announces improvement projects for iconic Lycabettus Hill

  77. 16/10 20:54

    SETE president Yiannis Retsos: Greece needs a digital strategy urgently

  78. 16/10 20:51

    New round of mergers and acquisitions in Greece's coastal shipping sector

  79. 16/10 17:08

    Foreign archaeological schools honored at Acropolis Museum on October 18-19

  80. 16/10 16:55

    Culture Tourism report: Interesting facts about the Acropolis of Athens

  81. 16/10 15:16

    More ancient wrecks and pottery discovered in Greek ships’ graveyard

  82. 16/10 14:12

    Arrivals and departures of travellers soar in Cyprus during August

  83. 16/10 12:39

    Greek shipping minister meets with Chinese transport minister

  84. 16/10 10:06

    Tranio-MR&H survey: Cyclades islands top hoice for hotel investment in Greece

  85. 16/10 01:03

    Aegean Wines tastings in Athens on October 21

  86. 15/10 23:07

    Lampsa Hotels acquires 50% of remaining stake in Touristika Theretra

  87. 15/10 22:44

    Cyprus Airways announced that it has become member of IATA

  88. 15/10 22:44

    International Space Summit on Mars with top scientists in Cyprus

  89. 15/10 22:08

    Kassiopi privatization finally ready to begin on Greek island of Corfu

  90. 15/10 21:36

    New record: 53 million passengers at Greek airports in first nine months

  91. 15/10 19:28

    Foreign Direct Investment forum gearing up for second event in Greece

  92. 15/10 17:25

    Boston Public TV Station hosts top Spanakopita Contest

  93. 15/10 15:18

    Visit Greece: Grab your camera and capture beauty

  94. 15/10 13:03

    4th Santorini Experience attracts 6,000 visitors from 45 countries

  95. 15/10 12:47

    Conde Nast readers name Greece's Aegean 5th best airline in the world

  96. 15/10 11:33

    4th Panhellenic Congress of Thermal Medicine: Greece among Europe's largest spa centres

  97. 15/10 10:21

    Greek tourism 2018: Regions of South Aegean and Attica dominate receipts in H1

  98. 14/10 12:20

    Travelers can now publish online their sketches and drawings of Greece

  99. 13/10 18:39

    Pink Martini concerts in Athens on December 15 and 16

  100. 13/10 18:31

    Five ways to experience Athens like a local