Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from Airbnb

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Research results show the real threat to the hotel industry from AirbnbAirbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders

Since the entry of Airbnb into the hospitality industry in 2008, media attention has largely focused on the disruptive nature of the service. Industry reports, as well as lively debates at hotel, travel and tourism conferences, have kept the spotlight on Airbnb’s growth and success. But despite all this attention, we still know little about its real impact on hotel sales.

In a recent publication in the International Journal of Hospitality Management, Dr. Manisha Singal (Virginia Tech University) and Dr. Jonathan Templin (University of Kansas) examined how Airbnb supply, price, and perceived quality affect the sales performance of incumbent hotels in the San Francisco market. In particular, they explored the impact of the development of Airbnb supply and users’ satisfaction on hotel sales patterns, and whether different hotel segments have been affected by Airbnb’s entry.

The findings revealed that:

Total Airbnb volume does not impact RevPar

Total Airbnb listings (i.e., total inventory) do not impact the growth trajectory of hotel RevPAR, which confirms the argument that Airbnb’s offering a supplementary service. These results are also consistent with a 2017 report on the Airbnb effect in Boston, and with an STR 2017 study of 13 global markets. However,

The average price of an Airbnb offer can have an impact on RevPAR

And that impact varies across different segments of the industry. Airbnb property prices had a positive effect on hotel RevPAR: the higher the price of the rentals posted on the platform, the higher the RevPAR of the hotels. Also,

  • The increase in the quality of the Airbnb service has a direct adverse impact on hotel performance. The higher the average satisfaction score of an Airbnb property, the lower the RevPAR for the hotels in the sample.  More specifically, every increase in the review score of an Airbnb property had a negative impact of -$25.54 on hotel RevPAR for hotels in the sample. Finally,
  • This last effect varies across segments. Airbnb rental prices had an effect on hotels’ RevPAR in the luxury segment, with an increase in RevPAR of $0.651 for every dollar increase in the average rental price of the Airbnb units.

In conclusion

Not just a supplement: The study reveals that Airbnb’s listings/offers do not merely supplement the lodging market, but rather show substitute characteristics in their long-term effects on hotel sales’ patterns.

Customers make comparisons: The effect of Airbnb on hotels sales is intricate, and appears to be based on customers’ dynamic comparison of the price and value offered by the two products.  The research results imply that guests do consider both products when booking rooms and compare the benefits of each through user reviews.

Signs of disruption: The results provide empirical evidence that Airbnb will disrupt the hotel business, and that the more Airbnb users are satisfied with their experience, the more likely it is that demand for hotel rooms will decrease. Hotel managers therefore need to be aware of the level of service and price offered by Airbnb and other sharing platforms in their market.  Airbnb offers in their locality can no longer be ignored and should be considered when developing revenue management strategies.

Airbnb is slowly disrupting the lodging industry, going beyond the supplemental role claimed by its founders.  The impact of the sharing economy is not related so much to the volume of the offers on the platform, but rather on the pricing and price-to-value proposition as perceived by guests.

Read more at ehotelier.com

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: pixabay.com

 

Tornos
  1. 18/08 20:30

    “Take a picture, not a pebble” campaign to save Lalaria beach on Skiathos island

  2. 18/08 20:26

    CTO: July 2017 – July 2018 best 12 months in history of tourism in Cyprus

  3. 18/08 18:22

    TUI, Fraport, HATTA report positive figures for Greek tourism in 2018

  4. 18/08 17:17

    Greek lighthouses open to the public on Sunday for ILLW weekend 2018

  5. 18/08 16:11

    More than half a million tourists in Cyprus in July 2018

  6. 18/08 15:04

    Greek island of Corfu making strides toward wheelchair-friendly beaches

  7. 18/08 14:00

    E-platform for short-term rentals in Greece ready by end-August: Tax official

  8. 18/08 12:55

    Cyprus monuments and ancient sites open to public on the evening of August 26

  9. 18/08 11:46

    Greek Culture Minister: Film permits for ancient sites to speed up under upcoming law

  10. 18/08 11:36

    Monica Belucci enjoys summer vacation on Greek islands of Mykonos and Paros

  11. 16/08 18:06

    AP: Endangered green and loggerhead turtles make comeback in Cyprus

  12. 16/08 17:58

    New York Euripides Summer Festival presented production of "Suppliants"

  13. 16/08 17:52

    New Study: Santorini island volcano erupted after 1600 BC

  14. 16/08 16:24

    Important finds in Amarynthos of Evia In Greece confirm sanctuary belonged to Artemis

  15. 16/08 14:55

    Shipping Ministry triples outlay for port improvements across Greece

  16. 16/08 14:24

    Religious Tourism: How Greece celebrates Dormition of Virgin Mary

  17. 16/08 11:57

    Ancient Pafos Acropolis explored by Cyprus University excavations at citadel in site of Kouklia

  18. 16/08 10:51

    Greek budget records primary surplus of €2.087 billion in January-July

  19. 14/08 20:50

    Beijing municipality delegation to visit Greek port of Patras

  20. 14/08 19:44

    Religious Tourism: Panagia Fidiotissa church in Greek island of Kefalonia

  21. 14/08 17:59

    Travel report: Avoid the crowds on these tranquil Greek islands

  22. 14/08 17:16

    ‘Russian Onassis’ Dmitry Rybolovlev enjoys dinner on Mykonos island (video)

  23. 14/08 17:15

    Greek PM: e-ticket for ancient sites and museums a key change for culture

  24. 14/08 16:08

    Employment flow performance improves in Greece between January-July thanks to tourism

  25. 14/08 15:08

    Freight carriers eye domestic rail network in Greece

  26. 14/08 14:02

    TUI to bring 2.8 million tourists to Greece this year

  27. 14/08 13:59

    New companies in Greece can set up in as little as 18 minutes

  28. 14/08 12:55

    Virtuoso: Greece among top-7 luxury destinations of American tourists in 2018

  29. 13/08 21:52

    More than 300 flights to and from Cyprus' airports on 19th August

  30. 13/08 21:37

    Corfu: 1st International Conference of Diaspora Greeks with Ionian descent

  31. 13/08 21:23

    Perseid meteor shower illuminates skies over Greece

  32. 13/08 20:11

    Greek tennis star Tsitsipas rises to No 15 in world ranking

  33. 13/08 18:57

    Greek tax authorities launch “Receipt, Please” campaign for tourists

  34. 13/08 16:30

    Religious Tourism: Holy Monastery of Panagia Kera in Greek island of Crete

  35. 13/08 14:21

    The 10 countries in the world with the smallest population

  36. 13/08 12:16

    Archaeologists discover sunken Ancient Greek ship in Black Sea

  37. 13/08 10:11

    Real Estate: Building activity rises up 17.6% across Greece in May

  38. 12/08 21:05

    Canada’s biggest Street Festival in Greektown over weekend

  39. 12/08 20:58

    Gambling Tourism: Mont Parnes and Hyatt Regency post improved results in H1 2018

  40. 12/08 20:45

    Greek national film office network in public investment program

  41. 12/08 19:05

    Greek summer season peaks ahead of August 15th celebration

  42. 12/08 15:51

    8th Greek Student Film Festival in Australia seeking new entries

  43. 12/08 11:37

    Turkish lira drops further as President Trump announces United States tariffs

  44. 10/08 22:20

    European Central Bank will revoke waiver for Greek banks

  45. 10/08 22:15

    Pythagoreion Theater on Greek island of Samos hosts Young Artists Festival

  46. 10/08 21:58

    Higher turnover and passenger numbers for Fraport Greece in H1 2018

  47. 10/08 20:03

    Global passenger arrivals in Greek airports up strongly in first seven months of 2018

  48. 10/08 18:35

    Mysterious objects that have intrigued archaeologists for centuries (video)

  49. 10/08 18:24

    Greek exports rise by impressive 24.8% reaching 3 billion euros

  50. 10/08 18:10

    New York Times: Lesser known Greek white wines to savor

  51. 10/08 14:17

    Infographic: Which countries give the most paid vacations in the world

  52. 10/08 12:08

    Thessaloniki firm adds real gold to Greek Olive Oil (video)

  53. 10/08 10:55

    Precious 2,200 year-old gold earring from Hellenistic era discovered in Israel

  54. 09/08 19:44

    Pebble mosaic dating to 4th century BC discovered in Greek city of Arta

  55. 09/08 19:28

    Religious Tourism: Panagia Episkopi, the oldest church on Santorini island

  56. 09/08 18:57

    Greek scientist and researchers discover cause of Santorini volcano eruption

  57. 09/08 18:37

    Greek Epirus Village of Lia memorialized by Gage gets Art museum

  58. 09/08 17:04

    Turkey to extend Booking.com ban to Airbnb, Expedia, Skyscanner and more

  59. 09/08 16:37

    Concert for Manos Eleftheriou on August 29 to benefit wildfire victims

  60. 09/08 13:19

    Greek ferry company Minoan Lines drops plastic straws

  61. 09/08 12:08

    Gateway to Greek Olive Oil celebrates 2nd anniversary

  62. 09/08 11:47

    Report: Wild party for the rich and famous on Greek island of Mykonos

  63. 09/08 10:00

    TUI Group expects double-digit earnings growth also for 2018

  64. 08/08 20:26

    Russian tourist arrivals to Greece to grow by more than 5% this year

  65. 08/08 20:02

    Ryanair cancels 250 flights to/from Germany on August 10 due to strike

  66. 08/08 19:51

    Tax inspections on Mykonos lead to local businesses' shutdowns

  67. 08/08 19:07

    First private naval high school to open on Greek island of Chios in September

  68. 08/08 19:06

    US ambassador Geoffrey Pyatt tours and lauds Greek island of Hios

  69. 08/08 18:20

    Travel guide: Six top reasons to visit Greek city of Thessaloniki this summer

  70. 08/08 17:47

    Creative workshops for children at Athens and Epidaurus festival

  71. 08/08 17:11

    #Greece is the most popular hashtag on Instagram

  72. 08/08 16:05

    Religious Tourism: Miraculous Monastery of Panagia Malevi in Peloponnese, Greece

  73. 08/08 15:21

    New flight to link Greek island of Lesvos with Turkish port of Izmir

  74. 08/08 14:48

    Two Greek museums compete for Europe’s Best in Short Film Awards (video)

  75. 08/08 12:42

    Emirates Airlines marks 10th anniversary of A380 operations

  76. 08/08 10:25

    Report: The top-5 aphrodisiac foods preferred by Ancient Greeks

  77. 07/08 22:43

    Canvas Holidays: Nissi Beach In Cyprus among world’s best beaches

  78. 07/08 22:35

    Cretans share funny trailer to entice tourists to run in Half Marathon 2018 (video)

  79. 07/08 21:59

    Real estate companies invest in Greek tourism property market

  80. 07/08 21:11

    Russian Embassy in Athens: Greece among top choices for Russian tourists

  81. 07/08 20:36

    Greek tax inspectors move on to Paros, Santorini and Rhodes after Mykonos

  82. 07/08 15:09

    Formula 1 star Lewis Hamilton enjoys Mykonos holidays (video)

  83. 07/08 14:47

    Little Mix’s Thirlwall, Edwards and Pinnock vacation in Mykonos island

  84. 07/08 12:20

    Trivago: Athens hotel prices remain low among major European capitals in August

  85. 07/08 11:29

    Archaic building found at Despotiko island's Apollo sanctuary in Greece

  86. 07/08 10:54

    Religious Tourism guide: 10 must-see monasteries in Greece

  87. 06/08 22:44

    Greek officials crack down on tax-evasion on cosmopolitan island of Mykonos

  88. 06/08 20:56

    Passenger traffic in Cyprus airports up by 8% in January – July 2018

  89. 06/08 19:38

    145 new scholarships for 2018 by Onassis Foundation

  90. 06/08 18:35

    Greek Minister thanks Diaspora for aid to Attica fire survivors

  91. 06/08 17:31

    Travel & Leisure: Oia in Santorini one of the most charming villages in Europe

  92. 06/08 16:18

    Travel report: Delos island, where Greek myths, cults and history come alive

  93. 06/08 16:14

    ESM releases fifth and final €15 billion tranche to Greece

  94. 06/08 16:01

    Funny footage of tourist busting moves in Greek island of Ios goes viral (video)

  95. 06/08 15:07

    Piraeus port sports facilities improved in time for September

  96. 06/08 12:41

    Golden Visa program draws Chinese investors to Greece

  97. 06/08 10:33

    Religious Tourism: Panagia Pantanassa church in Monastiraki of Athens

  98. 05/08 19:43

    Greek tennis star Sakkari continues dream run to Silicon Valley final

  99. 05/08 18:50

    Religious Tourism: Church of Panagia on Greek island of Folegandros

  100. 05/08 17:38

    Lisbon breaks record for maximum temperature reaching 44 C (111.2 F)