Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: Good
It’s unlikely to surprise people in Greece and on the island of Crete where they’ve been eating fruits, vegetables, nuts and olive oil since ancient times, but a study redone after its methods were found to be flawed has come to the same conclusion: the Mediterranean Diet works.
It took the authors to swallow their pride and acknowledge errors in how the study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2013 was done but one of the lead researchers, Dr. Miguel A. Martínez-González of the University of Navarra in Spain, said the result was gratifying.
“After all this long work, I am more convinced than ever” by the study’s data that was redone after some embarrassing moments when the original work was questioned. “Seldom has a trial undergone more scrutiny,” he added.
The results of the retracted, redone study were reported in the New York Times and showed that despite some skepticism that the Mediterranean Diet can cut risk of heart attacks and strokes by 30 percent in those at high risk.
While the research was done in Spain, the diet studied was strikingly similar to that in Greece and other Mediterranean countries and the re-analysis showed essentially what the landmark original did.
Not everyone is convinced. “Nothing they have done in this re-analyzed paper makes me more confident,” said Dr. Barnett Kramer, Director of the Division of Cancer Prevention at the National Cancer Institute told the paper.
The credibility of the study
The flaws threatened to undercut the credibility of the study, especially among doubters and because the assignment of diets into three groups wasn’t as random as it was supposed to be, skewing the first results.
The trial enrolled 7,447 participants aged 55 to 80 who were assigned one of three diets: a Mediterranean diet with at least four tablespoons a day of extra virgin olive oil; the same diet with an ounce of mixed nuts; or a traditional low-fat diet.
The participants were followed for a median of nearly five years. Dr. Martínez-González and his colleagues reported that there were fewer cardiovascular events in the groups consuming olive oil and nuts.
All that came into question last year when Dr. John Carlisle of Torbay Hospital in England challenged the data and a statistician at the New England Journal of Medicine suggested the researchers look at the methods at each center that recruited participants and the not-so-random assignments in some cases.
On re-evaluating their data, the scientists running the new study soon found what Dr. Martínez-González said were “small problems affecting 10 percent of participants.”
Some investigators would assign one person in a household — the wife, for example — to one arm of the study — say, to the group consuming olive oil. Then they would ask other members of the household to share that diet, including them as though they had been randomly assigned to it.
We realized we had never reported that,” Dr. Martínez-González said.It got worse.
Trial in small villages
A researcher at one of the 11 clinical centers in the trial worked in small villages. Participants there complained that some neighbors were receiving free olive oil, while they got only nuts or inexpensive gifts.
So the investigator decided to give everyone in each village the same diet. He never told the leaders of the study what he had done. “He did not think it was important,” Dr. Martínez-González said.
It was because it meant the participants were not randomized and forced the team make another adjustment to data on 652 people in the trial along with 390 others who hadn’t been randomly assigned one of the three diets.
The investigators spent a year working on the re-analysis in collaboration with Dr. Miguel Hernan of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
In the end, they concluded that the original findings were still accurate, but the disbelievers remain unconvinced and excoriated the researchers and the work that created a flawed study in the first place.
“These people were naïve,” said Donald Berry, a statistician at MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston. “They were sloppy and didn’t know they were being sloppy.”
Cooking with extra virgin olive oil
He said he wants to believe because he loves nuts and has taken to cooking with extra virgin olive oil but doesn’t think the re-analysis solved the study’s problems beyond a doubt that can’t be calculated.
But he remains unconvinced, because the re-analysis did not solve the study’s problems, he said.
Dr. Bradley Efron, a statistics professor at Stanford University, also was skeptical. The revamped results “wouldn’t convince me to be on a Mediterranean diet,” he said.
Dr. Steven Nissen, a cardiologist at the Cleveland Clinic, is persuaded though and said he plans to continue advising patients to go on the Mediterranean Diet and is satisfied with the new findings that were the old findings.
It turned out about 14 percent of the more than 7,400 study participants hadn’t been assigned randomly to either the Mediterranean Diet or a low-fat one.
“This affected only a small part of the trial,” said Martínez González. When the researchers reanalyzed the data excluding the nonrandomized people, the results were the same, he added
Still, because everybody wasn’t randomly assigned to different groups, the study can no longer claim the diet directly caused those health benefits. “We need to tone down the results, but it is just a little bit,” he said, according to NPR.
David Allison, Dean of the School of Public Health at Indiana University in Bloomington told the radio station some logic is needed too, the way he put it.
“I don’t know anybody who would turn around from this and say, ‘Now that this has been revealed, we should all eat cotton candy and turn away from the Mediterranean Diet'”
Read more at thenationalherald.com
RELATED TOPICS: Greece, Greek tourism news, Tourism in Greece, Greek islands, Hotels in Greece, Travel to Greece, Greek destinations , Greek travel market, Greek tourism statistics, Greek tourism report
Photo Source: Wikimedia Commons Copyright: Michael W. Pendergrass License: CC-BY-SA
16/03 13:01
Greek Deputy Foreign Μinister meets her Slovenian counterpart in Athens
16/03 12:56
Greek-Canadian Diaspora to welcome Greek Prime Minister to Toronto
16/03 11:28
Greek Migration Minister visits refugee hosting facilities in Kavala, Drama and Serres
15/03 21:50
Greek Minister announces conference on defence ecosystem in Athens from Lithuania
15/03 13:45
PM: More than 80 hospitals and 156 health centres being upgraded in Greece
15/03 12:55
Piraeus Port and Genoa Chambers of Commerce ink memorandum of cooperation
14/03 23:43
President of Hellenic Republic meets Prime Minister of Slovakia in Bratislava
14/03 22:58
American Express report highlights Global Travel Trends during 2024
14/03 22:52
Four hospitals in Attica Region already organizing afternoon surgical procedures
14/03 22:49
US Ambassador to Athens: More flights from the United States to Greece and Thessaloniki
14/03 22:43
Greek archaeologists discover ten ancient shipwrecks off Aegean island of Kasos
14/03 19:32
No new intubations for Covid-19 recorded in Greece for the first time
14/03 18:36
Extra road safety measures adopted for Greek pre-lent carnival and Clean Monday
14/03 14:48
14/03 12:54
Electric buses to be deployed on the streets of Athens and Thessaloniki by May
13/03 22:23
13/03 20:11
Prices of basic lenten products either lower or equal to last year's in Greece
13/03 19:15
US Ambassador to Athens: Greece secures NATO readiness via Alexandroupolis
13/03 17:19
13/03 12:26
Greece shows new costumes for revamped Olympic Flame-lighting ceremony
12/03 22:46
Epirotes Society of Philadelphia ‘Omonia’ organized 16th Annual ‘Tsipourovradia’
12/03 21:38
The President of the Hellenic Republic to visit Slovakia on March 13-15
12/03 20:29
First afternoon surgeries in Greece kick off at Papageorgiou Hospital in Thessaloniki
11/03 23:58
Greek Foreign Minister: We stand behind Montenegro's European perspective
11/03 23:47
Visa Express for Turkish citizens to commence on five Greek islands in March
11/03 19:40
11/03 18:49
Microsoft Data Center construction kicks off in Spata next to Athens Airport
11/03 17:53
Dodecanese Federation marked 76th Anniversary of Unification with Greece
09/03 22:23
08/03 14:27
Prime Minister: Radical change in Greek education and a brave reform for growth
08/03 14:24
Traffic restrictions expected in Athens mid-morning to evening on Friday due to protests
08/03 14:24
Applications to out-of-court settlement more than doubled in Greece in February
08/03 13:18
Metro station 'Maniatika' near Piraeus Port to be closed on Saturday and Sunday
07/03 14:12
Athens wins World Travel Award 2024 as the top city-break destination in Europe
06/03 22:51
WTTC data show Greece and Portugal lead league for growth in tourist arrivals
06/03 20:28
Greek Tourism Minister at ITB: 2024 will be another excellent year for sector
06/03 19:47
Greek Foreign Minister to meet UAE Minister of Industry and Technology on Friday
06/03 18:43
European Union actions of 274m euros to support cultural heritage in Greece
06/03 16:37
'Odontotos' rack railway temporarily stopped until landslides issue is resolved
06/03 14:40
Minister: Bringing about the return of Greeks abroad 'a moral duty'
05/03 14:28
Archdiocese of America Eparchial Synod to meet on March 14-17 in Florida
05/03 14:21
05/03 14:11
ITB BERLIN 2024 opens with excellent bookings after global rise in travel in 2023
05/03 12:24
Greek PM at Athens supermarket: Consumers 'can already see lower prices on the shelf'
04/03 22:02
Greek Health Minister: Afternoon surgeries at state hospitals to begin shortly
04/03 21:47
Holy Cross Greek Orthodox Whitestone Community marks 49th Anniversary
04/03 20:27
Labor chief: Greece to train 500,000 workers in digital, green skills by 2025
04/03 19:44
Foreign Ministry to organize event on 'Women, Peace, and Security' on Friday
04/03 15:12
Athens Riviera | The summer experience with Athens as a background
29/02 22:54
Consumers to see price cuts up to 18.1% in 3,000 Greek supermarket products as of Friday
29/02 21:44
Greece and Germany set up Working Group on shipping cooperation
29/02 21:30
Wyndham Rewards’ Member Month offers 5 weeks of deals, discounts, and bonus points
29/02 21:03
Temple of Poseidon at Sounion near Athens to get new lighting system
29/02 21:02
29/02 20:47
Greece is represented by 60 firms at GULFOOD 2024 exhibition
29/02 19:58
Greek government gives 1+1 month extension for cash register-integrated POS terminals
29/02 19:49
Archangel Michael Church Dance Program shines at Folk Dance Festival in SF
29/02 15:39
'Renovate-rent' programme to be launched, Minister tells Greek Parliament
29/02 12:39
Rio-Antirrio ferry line in central Greece closed due to strong winds
28/02 21:34
Weather with heavy rain and storms in Greece as of Sunday night
28/02 17:31
CEO: The goal is for PPC to become a leading player in Southeast Europe
28/02 17:04
New Wyndham Hotels Market Managing Director of Central and Eastern Europe
28/02 12:21
Minister: Transactions with the Greek State will be further simplified in 2024
28/02 11:57
27/02 17:25
UN Tourism hails Saudi Arabia's historic milestone of 100 million tourists
27/02 15:00
Greek Prime Minister: Relations with Armenia can become even more productive
27/02 14:26
Wyndham: New growth cycle in Greece for the largest hotel chain franchise in the world
27/02 13:15
Price cuts of up to 15% in important product categories in Greece after March 1
27/02 12:46
Athens taxi drivers' protest rally in progress from Athinon avenue to Messogion
26/02 18:30
Annual Summit of Women Political Leaders (WPL) to be held in Athens in April
26/02 18:27
Culture Ministry: Schwartz Mansion in Ampelakia near Larisa to get new lighting
26/02 17:25
Greek president organizes reception for diplomats at Presidential Mansion
26/02 16:33
Trapped rack-railway passengers returned safely to Diakopto in Peloponnese
26/02 16:21
Public transport, ferry and taxi strikes in Athens on Wednesday
25/02 12:30
Greek island of Ikaria among the Blue Zones for Health Eating and Longevity
24/02 20:39
Greek PM meets Qatar Emir: Focus on bilateral cooperation and investments
24/02 18:25
Prescription cannabis for medicinal use legally available in Greece for the first time
24/02 17:19
MInister: The aim is to make fishing and fish-farming a key pillar of the economy
23/02 23:36
Greek Prime Minister arrives in Doha to be received by Sultan bin Saad Al Muraikhi
23/02 23:26
The Festival of Greek Dances takes place in the Metropolis of San Francisco
23/02 21:32
Revealing "70 Years of Friendship: Greece's photo journey through the Korean War"
23/02 17:15
16 Greek firms showcase at international fashion exhibitions in London
23/02 14:09
Flights to and from Heraklion airport in Crete resume on Saturday
22/02 18:15
Bill for non-state, non-profit universities being tabled in Greek Parliament on Thursday
22/02 18:13
Temporary residence for displaced Ukrainians extended in Greece to March 2025
22/02 18:10
American Hellenic Institute Golden Jubilee celebration Includes concert on April 12
22/02 18:09
Tourism Minister stresses importance of strong relationship of Greece with Serbia
22/02 17:58
Education protest rally ends and traffic resumes in Athens city center
21/02 19:47
Twistic and WeavAIR startups clinch the UN Tourism Hospitality Challenge
21/02 18:34
21/02 18:13
Traffic in Athens returning to normal after tractors depart from the Greek capital
21/02 13:01
Greek Tourism Minister in Belgrade for International Exhibition
21/02 00:55
Resilience through diversity and investments the aim of UN Tourism visit to Jamaica
20/02 23:38
Rally concludes with farmer tractors leaving Athens on Wednesday morning
20/02 20:43
Greek Prime Minister on official visit to India as of Wednesday
20/02 16:51
Minister: Greece wants to become India's gateway to the European Union
19/02 21:19
DEFEA Conference to be held at Stavros Niarchos Foundation in Athens on May 15
19/02 19:06
Traffic restrictions for farmers' rally in central Athens on Tuesday
19/02 18:11
Greece wins top tourist destination award at Grand Travel Awards in Sweden
19/02 14:23
Health Minister: Option of afternoon surgeries at public hospitals start in Greece
Greek-Canadian Diaspora to welcome Greek Prime Minister to Toronto
Greek Migration Minister visits refugee hosting facilities in Kavala, Drama and Serres
Greek Deputy Foreign Μinister meets her Slovenian counterpart in Athens
Greek Minister announces conference on defence ecosystem in Athens from Lithuania
US Ambassador to Athens: More flights from the United States to Greece and Thessaloniki
Piraeus Port and Genoa Chambers of Commerce ink memorandum of cooperation
American Express report highlights Global Travel Trends during 2024
PM: More than 80 hospitals and 156 health centres being upgraded in Greece
Four hospitals in Attica Region already organizing afternoon surgical procedures
President of Hellenic Republic meets Prime Minister of Slovakia in Bratislava
Epirotes Society of Philadelphia ‘Omonia’ organized 16th Annual ‘Tsipourovradia’
Saint Thomas Hellenic School organizes Parent Teacher Organization Fundraiser
Report: School of St. Nectarios of Roslindale, a Beacon of Greek language and heritage
Greek Prime Minister to meet Bulgarian counterpart at Maximos Mansion
IOBE forecasts 2.4% growth and 10.5% unemployment in Greece during 2024
Greek retail sector turnover exceeds last year's figures with €4 billion in December
Rally concludes with farmer tractors leaving Athens on Wednesday morning
3-year stay and work permits approved for 30,000 undocumented migrants in Greece
Construction of Greece-Cyprus-Israel interconnection cable commences
Golden Visa bonus for foreigners buying luxury homes at Ellinikon in Athens
Development Minister: Supermarket food prices will start dropping in Greece in March
European Commission: Greece assumes command of Red Sea maritime operation
Education protest rally ends and traffic resumes in Athens city center
Greek president organizes reception for diplomats at Presidential Mansion
CEO: The goal is for PPC to become a leading player in Southeast Europe