Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: Good

Α Decrease font Enlarge font
Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: GoodThe Mediterranean Diet can cut risk of heart attacks and strokes by 30 percent in those at high risk

It’s unlikely to surprise people in Greece and on the island of Crete where they’ve been eating fruits, vegetables, nuts and olive oil since ancient times, but a study redone after its methods were found to be flawed has come to the same conclusion: the Mediterranean Diet works.

It took the authors to swallow their pride and acknowledge errors in how the study published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2013 was done but one of the lead researchers,  Dr. Miguel A. Martínez-González of the University of Navarra in Spain, said the result was gratifying.

“After all this long work, I am more convinced than ever” by the study’s data that was redone after some embarrassing moments when the original work was questioned. “Seldom has a trial undergone more scrutiny,” he added.

The results of the retracted, redone study were reported in the New York Times and showed that despite some skepticism that the Mediterranean Diet can cut risk of heart attacks and strokes by 30 percent in those at high risk.

While the research was done in Spain, the diet studied was strikingly similar to that in Greece and other Mediterranean countries and the re-analysis showed essentially what the landmark original did.

Not everyone is convinced. “Nothing they have done in this re-analyzed paper makes me more confident,” said Dr. Barnett Kramer, Director of the Division of Cancer Prevention at the National Cancer Institute told the paper.

The credibility of the study

The flaws threatened to undercut the credibility of the study, especially among doubters and because the assignment of diets into three groups wasn’t as random as it was supposed to be, skewing the first results.

The trial enrolled 7,447 participants aged 55 to 80 who were assigned one of three diets: a Mediterranean diet with at least four tablespoons a day of extra virgin olive oil; the same diet with an ounce of mixed nuts; or a traditional low-fat diet.

The participants were followed for a median of nearly five years. Dr. Martínez-González and his colleagues reported that there were fewer cardiovascular events in the groups consuming olive oil and nuts.

All that came into question last year when Dr. John Carlisle of Torbay Hospital in England challenged the data and a statistician at the New England Journal of Medicine suggested the researchers look at the methods at each center that recruited participants and the not-so-random assignments in some cases.

On re-evaluating their data, the scientists running the new study soon found what Dr. Martínez-González said were “small problems affecting 10 percent of participants.”

Some investigators would assign one person in a household — the wife, for example — to one arm of the study — say, to the group consuming olive oil. Then they would ask other members of the household to share that diet, including them as though they had been randomly assigned to it.

We realized we had never reported that,” Dr. Martínez-González said.It got worse.

Trial in small villages

A researcher at one of the 11 clinical centers in the trial worked in small villages. Participants there complained that some neighbors were receiving free olive oil, while they got only nuts or inexpensive gifts.

So the investigator decided to give everyone in each village the same diet. He never told the leaders of the study what he had done. “He did not think it was important,” Dr. Martínez-González said.

It was because it meant the participants were not randomized and forced the team make another adjustment to data on 652 people in the trial along with 390 others who hadn’t been randomly assigned one of the three diets.

The investigators spent a year working on the re-analysis in collaboration with Dr. Miguel Hernan of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

In the end, they concluded that the original findings were still accurate, but the disbelievers remain unconvinced and excoriated the researchers and the work that created a flawed study in the first place.

“These people were naïve,” said Donald Berry, a statistician at MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston.  “They were sloppy and didn’t know they were being sloppy.”

Cooking with extra virgin olive oil

He said he wants to believe because he loves nuts and has taken to cooking with extra virgin olive oil but doesn’t think the re-analysis solved the study’s problems beyond a doubt that can’t be calculated.

But he remains unconvinced, because the re-analysis did not solve the study’s problems, he said.

Dr. Bradley Efron, a statistics professor at Stanford University, also was skeptical. The revamped results “wouldn’t convince me to be on a Mediterranean diet,” he said.

Dr. Steven Nissen, a cardiologist at the Cleveland Clinic, is persuaded though and said he plans to continue advising patients to go on the Mediterranean Diet and is satisfied with the new findings that were the old findings.

It turned out about 14 percent of the more than 7,400 study participants hadn’t been assigned randomly to either the Mediterranean Diet or a low-fat one.

“This affected only a small part of the trial,” said Martínez González. When the researchers reanalyzed the data excluding the nonrandomized people, the results were the same, he added

Still, because everybody wasn’t randomly assigned to different groups, the study can no longer claim the diet directly caused those health benefits. “We need to tone down the results, but it is just a little bit,” he said, according to NPR.

David Allison, Dean of the School of Public Health at Indiana University in Bloomington told the radio station some logic is needed too, the way he put it.

“I don’t know anybody who would turn around from this and say, ‘Now that this has been revealed, we should all eat cotton candy and turn away from the Mediterranean Diet'”

Read more at thenationalherald.com

RELATED TOPICS: GreeceGreek tourism newsTourism in GreeceGreek islandsHotels in GreeceTravel to GreeceGreek destinations Greek travel marketGreek tourism statisticsGreek tourism report

Photo Source: Wikimedia Commons Copyright: Michael W. Pendergrass License: CC-BY-SA 

 

 

Tornos
  1. 22/06 16:49

    Blueground’s portfolio includes 400 property assets in Athens

  2. 22/06 16:34

    English novelist Anthony Horowitz discovers “most magical” Greek island of Spetses

  3. 22/06 14:26

    BITE 2018: Chinese express strong interest in Greece as a tourist destination

  4. 22/06 14:22

    Emirates Airbus A380 makes first landing in Athens on Friday (video)

  5. 22/06 14:17

    Greek island vacation for American media tycoon Barry Diller

  6. 22/06 14:17

    Greek National Theatre offers cheaper tickets for Ancient Theater of Epidaurus

  7. 22/06 14:02

    Travelbook.de presents its "Top 10" Greek beaches list for 2018

  8. 22/06 13:49

    Kate Hudson’ son Ryder, 14, looks like grandpa Kurt Russell on Greek vacation

  9. 22/06 13:46

    Chalkidiki’s olives lauded in Russian travel magazine

  10. 22/06 12:37

    Report: Hotel rooms on popular Greek islands booked during 2018 season

  11. 22/06 12:23

    “Disruption” at 7th SNF International Conference on philanthropy in Athens (videos)

  12. 22/06 10:53

    Archaeologists discover villa and mosaic of Ancient Greek fisherman Phainos in Turkey

  13. 21/06 19:34

    Balance of travel services in Greece: Arrivals grow but spending drops in Q1

  14. 21/06 19:20

    Athens Stock Exchange: 7th Hellenic Investment Forum in New York winds up

  15. 21/06 18:42

    Summer Nostos Festival draws crowds to the SNFCC in Athens

  16. 21/06 18:32

    Saving 1 million turtles worldwide by new global TUI Turtle Aid programme

  17. 21/06 16:24

    TUI: Greece second most popular destination in 2018 - the tourists who prefer it

  18. 21/06 14:35

    Marriott International Hotels gear up as water savvy Cape Town bounces back

  19. 21/06 14:31

    Ferrari celebrates 70th anniversary in Greek city of Ioannina in Epirus (video)

  20. 21/06 13:20

    3rd Ministerial Conference for Security and Stability on Greek island of Rhodes

  21. 21/06 12:22

    Air Traffic Controllers strikes destroy aviation and economies across Europe

  22. 21/06 10:05

    Travel report: Astypalaia, a Greek island that steals your heart

  23. 19/06 22:27

    Aegean Cuisine network ‘the ambassador of Cycladic islands gastronomy’

  24. 19/06 22:22

    Refugee Food Festival is coming to restaurants in Athens and Mytilene island

  25. 19/06 22:17

    Ambassador Pyatt: Strong support by the US for Greece's economic recovery

  26. 19/06 22:05

    Popular Greek singers performing across the country for summer 2018

  27. 19/06 21:51

    Art Athina 2018 opens at the Athens Conservatory on June 21

  28. 19/06 21:45

    Five applications for freight rail transport and logistics to Greece

  29. 19/06 21:32

    China showing great interest in Greek audiovisual sector and film tourism

  30. 19/06 21:22

    The Athens Acropolis Museum celebrates nine years of existence

  31. 19/06 18:51

    Lesvos island marks World Refugee Day with concerts by refugee children

  32. 19/06 18:44

    Greek island of Sifnos: A place filled with tasty memories

  33. 19/06 18:39

    President Kovind: Greece and India can boost bilateral trade to more than 1 billion

  34. 19/06 18:32

    Legendary Onassis yacht Christina O docks at Greece’s Piraeus port (video)

  35. 19/06 18:20

    Minister: Culture adds value to Greece's tourist product (video)

  36. 19/06 17:48

    Report: Symbolism of Greek statues in Beyoncé and Jay-Z Apesh*t clip (video)

  37. 19/06 17:37

    Prospect for strengthening tourist flows from India to Greece very high

  38. 19/06 17:04

    Four Seasons Astir Palace Hotel Athens redevelopment in full swing

  39. 19/06 16:59

    Singapore Airlines’ new Boeing 787-10 to serve Bali after July 2, 2018

  40. 19/06 14:49

    The top-5 countries with the highest demand for Greek golden visas

  41. 19/06 12:36

    ACI Europe: Traffic at Athens, Kefalonia and Corfu airports takes off

  42. 19/06 10:26

    Reuters: Dromeus Capital fund looking to invest in Greek commercial property

  43. 19/06 00:27

    Harvard Library acquires archive of iconic Greek poet Nikos Gatsos

  44. 19/06 00:21

    Media: DG Comp delay doubles offer for 20-year concession of Athens Airport

  45. 19/06 00:13

    Cyprus’ residents trips abroad rise by 1.7% during May 2018

  46. 19/06 00:06

    Land developer confident Helleniko project can commence construction in early 2019

  47. 18/06 23:58

    Tatler Travel Guide 2018: Two Greek hotels among the 101 best in the world

  48. 18/06 23:42

    Ryanair flight attendant dancing to Britney Spears' Toxic goes viral

  49. 18/06 22:45

    Report: The mystery of the Sleeping Giant in the Greek island of Naxos

  50. 18/06 21:17

    Indian President Ram Nath Kovind visits Greek capital of Athens

  51. 18/06 21:12

    Space Agrobox: Greek students find way to feed astronauts

  52. 18/06 21:03

    New York Times laud Athens as a rising cultural capital of Europe

  53. 18/06 20:06

    4th Annual Loukoumi Dance Party and Make A Difference Awards in New York

  54. 18/06 20:01

    Tourist arrivals in Cyprus up by 7.6% during May

  55. 18/06 19:55

    Summer Nostos Festival returns in Athens between June 17-24 (video)

  56. 18/06 19:40

    Arab resorts try to copycat Greece’s Cycladic island beauty

  57. 18/06 19:35

    Greek Investment Roadshow in the USA to take place between June 19-22

  58. 18/06 18:27

    Food-For-Good Festival in Kalamaria Thessaloniki a big hit

  59. 18/06 16:23

    Ancient Theatre of Aptera in Crete to reopen after 17 centuries of silence

  60. 18/06 14:19

    TUI report: Scaling positive change through sustainable tourism

  61. 18/06 12:09

    Olympic champion Stefanidi to participate in Athens Street Pole Vault event

  62. 18/06 10:02

    ABTA: 1 in 3 Brits travel abroad without checking advice about their holiday destination

  63. 15/06 21:19

    Religious Tourism: Exploring ancient Christian churches in Turkey

  64. 15/06 21:08

    Poll: 99% of women hate their partner wearing tight Speedos

  65. 15/06 20:37

    Alexandria’s Greek graves in Egypt form moving monument to Diaspora

  66. 15/06 20:30

    Cavo Paradiso club in Mykonos island celebrates 25th anniversary

  67. 15/06 18:26

    Bus work stoppages in Athens on Tuesday and Thursday

  68. 15/06 16:22

    New objective tax rates for property in Greece approved by finance ministry

  69. 15/06 14:17

    First run for trimaran Superspeed linking Thessaloniki with Sporades islands

  70. 15/06 12:06

    Rainy weather front to affect parts of Greece until Tuesday

  71. 15/06 10:00

    New Mykonos Art festival aims to redefine the popular island destination

  72. 15/06 00:04

    ESM approves 1 billion euros disbursement to Greece

  73. 14/06 23:49

    Nine of the most incredible insurance claims in the history of travel experiences

  74. 14/06 23:38

    Hellenic Heritage Foundation of Toronto celebrates 22nd Annual Gala

  75. 14/06 23:32

    Piraeus to receive €2 million in countervailing benefit from Cosco-run port

  76. 14/06 23:27

    Rich Indians turn to Cyprus for coveted European Union passports

  77. 14/06 20:56

    Bank of Greece: Apartment values down by 40% in the country since 2007

  78. 14/06 20:49

    Retracted and redone Med diet study shows same result: Good

  79. 14/06 20:47

    Athens city council and Mastercard to promote Greek capital abroad

  80. 14/06 20:18

    Sky Express starts flights to and from Chania in Crete and Athens

  81. 14/06 18:34

    Greek Tourism Minister highlights country's attractions for Russians

  82. 14/06 18:32

    Media report: Celebrities making their way to Greece for Summer 2018

  83. 14/06 16:03

    Manasis School in Australia dances “Zorba the Greek” at rugby game

  84. 14/06 14:56

    The Tiger Lillies tour Greece between June 19-24

  85. 14/06 10:33

    Airlines’ ‘hidden’ fees report: Better know before you go

  86. 14/06 01:49

    Guardian: Mykonos and Santorini among 10 classic European islands on a budget

  87. 14/06 01:40

    The essential guide to drinking Ouzo

  88. 14/06 01:34

    Andros island museum hosts tribute to expressionist Dimitris Mytaras

  89. 14/06 01:27

    Tourism, food and beverage sectors boost new hirings in May

  90. 14/06 01:18

    The full agreement between Greece and FYROM on name dispute in English

  91. 14/06 00:55

    The six best toilets in the 2018 International Toilet Tourism Awards

  92. 14/06 00:24

    Work stoppages to affect most transport means in Athens on Thursday

  93. 14/06 00:08

    All-night performance at Temple of Epicurean Apollo in Peloponnese

  94. 13/06 23:13

    Supplementary tax hike on Greek islands and Athens city center

  95. 13/06 22:07

    Tickets to travel to four European countries to 315 young Greeks

  96. 13/06 20:48

    Dior launches pop up store in Mykonos with exclusive Myconian collection

  97. 13/06 20:02

    Athens Taxi owners go again on strike over Uber return fears

  98. 13/06 19:42

    Expert presentation: The color and design of the Parthenon frieze

  99. 13/06 16:24

    Report: Tiffany Trump and Lindsay Lohan planning Mykonos trip together

  100. 13/06 12:52

    Russian Foreign Minister: Economic ties with Greece growing strongly